Oklahoma State left Morgantown with more than a 41-24 win over West Virginia. It walked out with a clearer identity, too - one built around quarterback Drew Mestemaker, running back Caleb Hawkins and wide receiver Wyatt Young.
Call them “The Big Three,” as one beat writer did Saturday night. Or go with Oklahoma State’s own version, the “Three-Headed Monster.” However it gets labeled, Eric Morris’ offense is leaning hard on a trio that followed him to Stillwater and delivered in a big way against the Mountaineers.
After the game, Morris couldn’t hide how much these three mean to him.
“They’re extremely tough football players,” Morris said to reporters, including the Tulsa World’s Eric Bailey, after the game. “They are gritty.
They came from nothing. They only had one offer out of high school and earned everything they’ve gotten.”
That message matched the performance. Mestemaker threw for 389 yards on 20-of-27 passing with three touchdowns and one interception in his second game against a power conference opponent.
Young was right there with him, finishing with eight catches for 192 yards and a touchdown. And Hawkins churned out 180 yards on 31 carries with a score, his best game as a Cowboy.
The passing game, in particular, turned explosive. Oklahoma State produced 10 big plays through the air for 334 yards, and Young accounted for five of them. His final four catches of the night went for 40, 48, 48 and 28 yards, the kind of late-game damage that can break a defense’s spirit.
Mestemaker and Young already had a built-in connection from their time at North Texas, and Saturday showed exactly why Morris wanted that partnership back in his system. Last season with the Mean Green, North Texas piled up 7,174 total yards, and Mestemaker’s 4,379 passing yards plus Hawkins’ 1,434 rushing yards made up 5,813 of them - 81% of the offense. Young added 1,264 receiving yards and led the team in that category.
That kind of production helped North Texas finish 12-2, reach the American Conference title game and win a bowl game. Once Morris left for Oklahoma State and the trio entered the transfer portal, they had every reason to end up somewhere else. Instead, Morris landed all three.
His confidence in Mestemaker started early, even if the quarterback’s path was anything but ordinary. Mestemaker had no college offers after never playing a varsity snap at quarterback.
A personal quarterbacks coach reached out to Morris and his staff just to get him a tryout. He walked on at North Texas, became the starter last season and now has already flashed against power conference competition.
Young came with a more crowded recruiting board. Out of Tompkins in Katy, Texas, he had offers from Arizona, Memphis, Rice, Army West Point, Air Force, Western Kentucky and Tulsa.
Hawkins’ route was just as unusual. Morris and his staff found the Shawnee, Okla., native after he attended a UNT camp. Running backs coach Patrick Cobbs - a North Texas legend and also from Shawnee - had gone to Morris and said, “You have to come see this guy.”
No one else was on Hawkins, but North Texas snapped him up anyway. Last season, he set a new FBS record for most touchdowns scored by a freshman.
Saturday also showed that Oklahoma State is not a one-trick offense. Justin Bowick has emerged as a productive receiver.
Chris Barnes, Terrence Lewis and Miles Coleman are all filling important roles. The offensive line has started to come together and will get Braydon Nelson back in two weeks.
On the other side of the ball, the defense doesn’t have a star-heavy feel, but it made enough plays when it mattered. West Virginia finished with 466 yards, yet Oklahoma State’s defense still came up with the stops and big moments the Cowboys needed.
Now the program is back in the AP Top 25 for the first time since 2024, and the bye week will keep it there for a couple of weeks. Bigger questions sit ahead, though, including whether Morris can push this group into Big 12 contention in his first season.
If that happens, it will be driven largely by the players nobody else seemed to want.
The “Triplets,” the “Big Three” or the “Three-Headed Monster” - whatever name sticks, Oklahoma State has found its engine. And with eight games ahead and NIL money to be made, the next stretch gives this group a chance to keep building on a moment that already feels significant.
In Other News...
BYU May Be Getting A Much Different UCF Than Expected
UCF has quietly become one of the more interesting defensive stories in the Big 12 this season. The Knights are giving up just 15 points per game, sitting fourth in the league in scoring defense, and they have already forced nine turnovers while backing up the numbers with a recent win over TCU.
Now comes the part that could tell us a lot more about where this team really stands. UCF is heading into a brutal stretch against one ranked opponent after another, and the next few weeks will show whether this defensive turnaround is built to last or just a strong run against a softer part of the schedule. [Read more 🡒]
Oklahoma States Bye Week Just Made One Lineup Battle Feel Bigger
Oklahoma States win over West Virginia did more than keep the Cowboys moving toward Big 12 contention. It also offered a cleaner look at the offensive front, with all five starting linemen on the field for every snap for the first time this season. With Joseph Hanson back at right guard and other key pieces logging major minutes, the staff got a rare chance to see what the group can look like when it stays intact.
The timing matters because the Cowboys now have a bye week to sort through the details before the schedule picks back up, including a matchup with UCF. There was also a notable defensive moment in the win, with Phillips starting at free safety and helping swing momentum with an interception, another reminder that the team is beginning to settle into a more complete version of itself just as the next stretch arrives. [Read more 🡒]
Oklahoma State Finally Has The Big 12 Breakthrough Fans Needed
A long-awaited reset finally arrived for Oklahoma State with a win over West Virginia, a result that did more than just get the Cowboys back in the conference win column. It also snapped a stretch that had dragged on since November 2023, giving the program its first Big 12 victory in nearly a year and a half and its first league road win in that same span.
Eric Morris made clear how much it meant inside the building, especially for defensive end and captain Jaleel Johnson, who has lived through the entire skid and stayed with the team through it all. The Cowboys are back in the AP Top 25, too, which only sharpens the stakes as they try to turn one breakthrough into something more lasting in Big 12 play. [Read more 🡒]