Drew Mestemaker was right where Oklahoma State needed him on Saturday afternoon: behind center for the Cowboys’ first possession against Arizona State.
That was far from a sure thing all week. Mestemaker had been listed as questionable with a shoulder injury and was viewed as a game-time decision, but he ended up starting for Oklahoma State and making his 25th straight start as a college player since his appearance for North Texas in its bowl game at the end of the 2024 season.
The Cowboys entered the matchup at 6-4 overall and 4-3 in the Big 12, already bowl eligible for the first time since 2023. With two regular-season games left, they’re trying to improve their bowl position by finishing strong.
The uncertainty around Mestemaker built through Saturday morning. ESPN’s Pete Thamel reported early in the day that he had a shoulder strain, while Mestemaker had said after last Saturday’s game that it felt like a shoulder stinger.
Two hours before kickoff, Cowboys Radio play-by-play voice Dave Hunziker said Mestemaker was “very limited” during the week and added that his gut said the redshirt sophomore wouldn’t play. But Mestemaker went through light jogging with his teammates, then individual work, and later took part in his usual pregame routine with the starters, according to Cowboys Radio Network.
Head coach Eric Morris said during the pregame show that the staff would talk with Mestemaker after workouts to see where he stood and that he wanted “honest communication” from Mestemaker about how he felt.
That conversation apparently left the door open for him to go, and he was in the lineup against Arizona State, which also came in at 6-4 and 4-3.
Mestemaker’s durability has been tested before. He suffered the injury on the first offensive possession against Texas Tech when he was sacked by defensive lineman T.J.
Holmes. He met with team trainers twice in the first quarter of that game and stayed in until midway through the fourth quarter, when he was pulled after Oklahoma State fell behind in a 52-27 loss.
Even with the setback, his streak of eight straight 300-yard passing games ended there as he went 27-of-42 for 277 yards with one touchdown and two interceptions. His run of 200-yard passing games, though, stayed alive.
Earlier this week, Mestemaker was named one of five finalists for the Johnny Unitas Golden Arm award. He entered Saturday leading the nation in passing yards with 3,239 and touchdown passes with 30.
In Other News...
Arizona State Faces A Dangerous Oklahoma State Test At The Worst Time
With both Oklahoma State and Arizona State sitting at 6-4, their Week 12 meeting arrives with plenty still hanging in the balance. The Cowboys have spent enough of the season showing they can be efficient on offense, while Arizona State has leaned on a defense that has generally held up well enough to keep games within reach. It is the kind of late-season matchup that can say a lot about where each program is headed, especially when records are this close and the margin for error is gone.
The wrinkle for Arizona State is that Oklahoma State brings a more dangerous overall profile than the Sun Devils may want this time of year, particularly against a defense that has had some vulnerable spots in the back end. The betting lean points toward the Cowboys not just winning, but doing enough to separate from the spread, which makes this feel less like a coin flip than the records suggest. For Oklahoma State, it is another chance to turn efficiency into a statement. [Read more 🡒]
Oklahoma State Showed Promise In Charleston Before One Problem Took Over
Oklahoma State had stretches in the Shriners Childrens Charleston Classic that suggested there was something to build on, but the Cowboys could not sustain it in an 85-70 loss to Minnesota. Kashie Natt gave them a needed lift with 22 points and nine rebounds, while Isaac Asuma paced Minnesota with 17 points as the game gradually tilted away from the Cowboys.
The bigger issue was the perimeter, where Oklahoma State never found a rhythm and kept coming up empty from deep. The Cowboys finished 6-of-27 from three-point range overall, and the second half offered no relief as the outside shots stopped falling just when they needed a push to get back into it. [Read more 🡒]
Oklahoma State Suddenly Has A Real Shot To Get Bedlam Back
The Bedlam rivalry has been on pause since Oklahomas move to the SEC ended the annual regular-season meetings, but there is at least a path to seeing it again in bowl season. Oklahoma State athletic director Chad Weiberg has signaled the Cowboys would be willing to play if the postseason selection process lines things up, which is enough to keep a long-dormant matchup on the radar for fans on both sides of the border.
The most realistic landing spots would be one of the Big 12-SEC bowls, with the Texas Bowl in Houston or the Liberty Bowl in Memphis the likeliest places for the schools to cross paths. It is still a lot of moving parts for a rivalry that has already been disrupted once, but the possibility alone gives this postseason a little extra intrigue for Oklahoma State supporters who have been waiting for Bedlam to feel real again. [Read more 🡒]
