Oklahoma State Just Exposed A Bigger Problem Than One Bad Loss

Oklahoma State's defensive gaps were glaring as Texas Tech capitalized with big plays and quick strikes in a decisive victory.

Oklahoma State had a few moments that could have changed the feel of Saturday night. Instead, Texas Tech kept landing haymakers, and the Cowboys never recovered in a 52-27 loss at Boone Pickens Stadium.

The Red Raiders (9-1, 6-1 Big 12) did their damage with speed and space, ripping off four touchdowns of at least 30 yards. Their scoring drives were brutally short, too: two plays in the first quarter, one play for 75 yards in the second, one play for 45 yards in the third and two plays for 30 yards in the fourth. Four of those touchdown drives took fewer than 37 seconds, a pace that kept Oklahoma State (6-4, 4-3) on its heels all night.

The first gut punch came right away. Texas Tech receiver Malcolm Simmons took the opening kickoff 97 yards down the left sideline for a touchdown, with OSU kicker Joseph Kim colliding with him and briefly knocking him off balance before the Cowboys could get him down. It was the kind of start that drains a stadium fast.

Later, when Oklahoma State had trimmed the margin to four points late in the second quarter, Texas Tech answered with the play that summed up the night. Quarterback Tommy Castellanos slipped away from pressure for almost eight seconds, then found Micah Hudson downfield in traffic.

Hudson turned, three Cowboys tangled with each other, and safety Quinton Hammonds was the last defender with a shot before contact from behind knocked him off balance. Hudson was gone for an 80-yard touchdown.

The Cowboys’ offense had its own issues, starting with quarterback Drew Mestemaker. Whatever the mix was - a shoulder that didn’t seem fully right, pressure in the pocket and the rain - he never quite settled in.

On OSU’s first drive, he fumbled a wet ball and took a heavy shot on a sack from 300-pound lineman AJ Holmes Jr. On the sideline, Mestemaker raised his right shoulder above his head twice, as if testing it out.

He opened 4 of 7 for 25 yards with an interception, and while he finished 27 of 42 for 277 yards with one touchdown and two picks, the rhythm was off. He didn’t have a completion longer than 34 yards, and his streak of eight straight 300-yard passing games came to an end. Early in the second quarter, he dumped a pass to Caleb Hawkins for 3 yards in the red zone, then on the next snap drifted into a sack for an 8-yard loss, forcing the Cowboys to settle for a field goal.

There were still a couple of bright spots for Oklahoma State. Junior linebacker Isaiah Chisom kept filling in well for Tate Romney, who has now missed two games.

Chisom forced a Tommy Castellanos fumble in the second quarter to set up OSU’s first touchdown, extending the Cowboys’ streak of forcing a takeaway in every game this season. After leading the team with nine tackles against Kansas State last week, Chisom tied Ethan Wesloski for the linebacker lead Saturday with four tackles.

And then there was Morgan McPhaul, who delivered the night’s most physical highlight. The tight end caught a pass 4 yards past the line of scrimmage, ran through Malik Esquerra, powered past Amier Boyd’s arm tackle, lowered his shoulder at the 3-yard line and ducked under Brenden Jordan while reaching for the pylon on an 18-yard touchdown. The score stood after review.

McPhaul has now touched the ball six times this season and scored four touchdowns.

In Other News...

Oklahoma State Heads To Tempe With One Big Concern

Oklahoma State heads to Tempe on Saturday looking to steady itself after a recent loss, and the matchup with Arizona State brings a familiar kind of challenge. The Cowboys have split their six previous meetings with the Sun Devils, and this one comes at Mountain America Stadium with both teams carrying reasons to believe they can control the tone of the game.

Arizona State has leaned on its defense during a two-game winning streak, but the bigger concern for Oklahoma State is how it handles the Sun Devils on the ground. Cardae Mack has been the engine of the run game and has given Arizona State a reliable way to stay on schedule, which puts added pressure on the Cowboys to clean up the issues that showed up last week and avoid letting the game get dictated by the home side. [Read more 🡒]

Oklahoma State Suddenly Faces A Bigger Question Than Just One Loss

Texas Tech wasted no time putting Oklahoma State on its heels Saturday, turning the game into a lopsided 52-27 defeat before the Cowboys ever found a rhythm. The Red Raiders got an early spark from special teams and then kept stacking quick scoring drives, while Oklahoma State spent much of the afternoon chasing the game and trying to recover from a start that never allowed its offense or defense to settle in.

The bigger concern for the Cowboys is not just the loss itself, but how many of the same problems showed up at once. Turnovers, missed chances and repeated breakdowns on critical downs left Oklahoma State with little margin for error, and coach Eric Morris did not hide the teams shortcomings even as he pointed to the programs overall progress. For a team trying to build momentum, this was the kind of setback that raises questions well beyond one Saturday. [Read more 🡒]

Steve Lutz Calls Out What Oklahoma State Must Fix Fast

Oklahoma State is still trying to settle into its early-season rhythm, and Steve Lutz made it clear the Cowboys cannot afford to let their standards slip. After an 88-69 loss to Texas A&M, the coach pointed to preparation and mental focus as the areas that need the quickest correction, a familiar message for a team that is still sorting out its identity and looking for cleaner execution on both ends.

Kanye Clarys return from injury gave the Cowboys a needed jolt in the backcourt, even if the night was uneven. He scored 14 points despite shooting struggles, and Oklahoma State will need more poise around him as it turns to a matchup with Central Arkansas, which is coming off a loss to Arkansas and arrives with its own urgency. [Read more 🡒]