When Oklahoma State opens fall workouts next week, the roster math alone tells you how much is being rebuilt. More than 100 players are set to compete for 22 starting jobs, with nearly 90 newcomers arriving through the transfer portal and only 13 players back from last year’s team. The rest of the group is made up of true freshmen.
That kind of turnover naturally brings questions, especially for a first-year head coach like Eric Morris. The Cowboys have talent in a lot of places, but how quickly all of it fits together is still an open question. Fall workouts are where that starts to get sorted out.
The conversation around Oklahoma State has mostly centered on the offense, and for good reason. The skill-position talent is there. But there’s one issue that deserves more attention because it could shape the entire season: what happens if starting quarterback Mestemaker goes down?
Mestemaker’s 2024 numbers at North Texas were huge. He threw for 4,379 yards and 32 touchdowns, led the nation in passing yards and three other categories, and finished in the Top 10 in several more. He ran Morris’ Air Raid offense at a high level as North Texas went 12-2 and won a bowl game, then followed Morris to Oklahoma State soon after.
It made perfect sense for him to come with his coach. And if he stays healthy for all 12 games, he has a real chance to put up numbers close to what he did with the Mean Green last season. That’s especially true because some of the pieces that helped him thrive at North Texas came with him, including running back Caleb Hawkins and wide receiver Wyatt Young.
But the backup plan is where things get murky.
Morris brought in four quarterbacks, and none of them were holdovers. The only one with significant FBS experience is Grant Jordan, a transfer from Yale and UMass.
The New Orleans native appeared in seven games for UMass last season and passed for 595 yards. Before that, he was more productive at Yale, where he started nine games in 2024 and threw for 1,938 yards and 22 touchdowns.
His path there was a long one: four years sitting out or waiting, including a COVID shutdown, an injury year and two seasons behind other players.
The other two quarterbacks on the roster are true freshmen, Luke Tepas and Broderick Vehrs.
That’s why the quarterback question looms so large. Oklahoma State’s outlook is tied in part to Mestemaker’s ability to stay on the field. If he can’t, the Cowboys have to figure out whether Jordan can handle the job or whether one of the freshmen can step in.
Nobody likes to spend much time on the possibility of a starting quarterback injury. But it’s a real concern here, and one that hasn’t gotten nearly enough attention.
In Other News...
Oklahoma State Is Still Alive For An In-State Recruit Fans Need
Recruiting in-state always matters in Stillwater, and Oklahoma State is still in the mix for one of the biggest names in the next wave. Kamieon Compton-Nero, the top-ranked athlete in the Class of 2028 and a standout from Owasso, is among the programs top 15 targets, a sign the Cowboys remain firmly in the conversation for a player who has already drawn attention on both sides of the ball.
Compton-Nero has put up eye-catching numbers as both a quarterback and a defensive player, which only adds to the intrigue around how he might be used at the next level. For Oklahoma State, the appeal goes beyond talent alone: the staff is tracking a local prospect who could become a major piece in the future, even with a quarterback room that already includes one 2027 commit and two true freshmen on campus. [Read more 🡒]
NCAA Twist Could Reopen Several Oklahoma State Careers
A federal judge in Colorado has thrown a fresh wrinkle into the NCAAs eligibility rules, ordering the association to declare eligible all high school class of 2022 athletes who used up four seasons of eligibility this spring. The ruling comes amid legal challenges to the NCAAs newer age-based "five-for-five" standard, and it has immediate implications for several student-athletes who suddenly have another path to keep competing.
For Oklahoma State, the decision touches three players and could reopen careers that looked finished at the end of the spring. The bigger picture for the Cowboys is obvious: roster planning, scholarship management and even offseason expectations can all shift when athletes who seemed out of eligibility may be able to return for another college season. [Read more 🡒]
Oklahoma State May Have Found A Breakout Answer In The Secondary
Eric Morris has spent his first months reshaping Oklahoma State with an avalanche of transfers, nearly 90 in all, as he builds a roster that looks very different from the one he inherited. The group includes quarterback Drew Mestemaker and former UCLA linebacker Isaiah Chisom, but one of the quieter additions could end up mattering just as much on the defensive side: Vincent Holmes, a safety who arrived from Washington looking for a reset.
Holmes was once a four-star recruit, but his time in Seattle never really took off, leaving him with little game action and a lot to prove. In Stillwater, he is trying to turn that pedigree into production in Skyler Cassitys 4-2-5 defense, where the structure gives him a real chance to push for a starting safety role and carve out the kind of breakout opportunity that never came before. [Read more 🡒]