A handful of new coordinators have already changed the shape of college football through Week 5, but the biggest jolts have come from the guys who walked into messy situations and made them look manageable fast. Some inherited talented rosters.
Others inherited rebuilds. A few inherited both.
What separates this group is how quickly they’ve translated that change into wins, production and, in a couple cases, outright surprise.
Northwestern’s Chip Kelly sits at the top because no one has flipped a script more violently. The Wildcats spent a decade buried near the bottom of the sport in scoring, ranking 132nd out of 137 teams from 2015 to 2025, and last year they managed just 23.4 points per game.
Now they’re 3-1, with the only loss a 29-23 defeat at Indiana, and they just blew the doors off Penn State 34-13 on Oct. 2 by rushing for 413 yards, their highest total since 2003. Caleb Komolafe powered that night with 188 yards and Joseph Himon II added 162.
“I just have to give Coach [Chip] Kelly and our entire offensive staff a ton of credit,” head coach David Braun said. ESPN has Northwestern’s offense eighth in efficiency against the 13th-toughest schedule so far, and Game on Paper’s opponent-adjusted model has it first nationally.
Texas defensive coordinator Will Muschamp has brought a different kind of edge back to Austin. The Longhorns are 4-0, and their defense is ranked second in ESPN’s efficiency ratings against the country’s second-toughest schedule.
That unit held Ohio State to just three second-half points in a 24-23 comeback win after Texas trailed 23-3, then followed it up by beating Tennessee 20-17, a game in which edge rusher Colin Simmons set a school record with 5 1/2 sacks. Steve Sarkisian said the hire was about restoring a familiar style: “We felt like we wanted to get back to playing a style of defense that I was accustomed to,” Sarkisian said.
Muschamp, who had been in a semi-retired role at Georgia, ranks second on this list because he walked into a defense that already had 41 sacks in 2025.
Florida’s Buster Faulkner has also hit the ground running, and his offense has done the heavy lifting in a 4-1 start. The Gators put up 66, 52, 44 and 52 points in their first four games and landed a top-10 win over Ole Miss along the way.
Faulkner reunited with quarterback Aaron Philo, who played for him at Georgia Tech, and running back Jadan Baugh has already piled up 600 rushing yards and 11 touchdowns through four games. The lone blemish was a 45-17 loss at Missouri, when Florida managed just 42 rushing yards and faced 10 third downs of 10 yards or longer.
“We need to make sure that at the end of this week, that is the outlier,” Faulkner said. ESPN has Florida’s offense seventh in efficiency, though the defense sits 77th, and that balance keeps Faulkner ahead of Ohio State’s Arthur Smith here.
Smith inherited the most talent of anyone on this list and has turned it into a top-five offense almost immediately. Ohio State ranks fourth in ESPN’s offensive efficiency numbers, and last Saturday the Buckeyes rolled up 484 yards in a 31-14 win at No.
14 Iowa. Julian Sayin found Jeremiah Smith for touchdown strikes of 12 and 57 yards in Iowa City.
Ryan Day said the January hire was about giving the room a true play-caller: “I just felt like going into this season in particular, we needed somebody with some play calling experience that really could take over that room and allow me to kind of step back,” Day said. The one real stumble came in a 24-23 loss at Texas after Ohio State led 23-3 heading into the fourth quarter.
UCLA’s Dean Kennedy has turned a 3-9 program into a 4-0 team that leans hard on the run game. Through four games, the Bruins are averaging 44.5 points, third-best in the Big Ten, with wins over Cal, San Diego State, Purdue and Maryland.
Kennedy followed Bob Chesney from James Madison, where the 2025 offense averaged 37.1 points per game during a College Football Playoff season, and running back Wayne Knight came with him too, giving Nico Iamaleava a proven backfield partner. “Both Colin and Dean played integral parts to our historic success at James Madison,” Chesney said of Kennedy and defensive coordinator Colin Hitschler.
ESPN has UCLA’s schedule ranked 113th, the softest of the teams above them here, so Saturday’s trip to Oregon is the first real measuring stick for the ground game.
Memphis offensive coordinator Kevin Decker has wasted no time making his system fit. He arrived from Old Dominion with a fast-tempo, wide-split spread and took over a roster that added more than 70 new players.
The Tigers are 4-1 and rank 11th nationally in offensive efficiency, with quarterback Marcus Stokes - a Division II transfer from West Florida - thriving in the scheme. Stokes threw for 384 yards in a road loss at Boise State and then went 26-of-32 for 258 yards and four touchdowns in a 45-21 win over UT Martin.
Charles Huff had long admired Decker’s work and had faced his offenses several times at Marshall before hiring him. “When you look at his track record, and you go all the way back to Fordham, that's my litmus test for a coordinator,” Huff said.
ESPN’s 88th-ranked schedule keeps Decker from climbing higher.
Oklahoma State’s Skyler Cassity rounds out the list after producing one of September’s sharpest defensive showings in the Cowboys’ 39-31 upset of No. 6 Oregon.
His defense held the Ducks to 281 total yards and a combined 5-for-17 on third and fourth down. The 31-year-old, son of former Cowboys defensive coordinator Mike Cassity, followed Eric Morris from North Texas, where his defense cut nearly 10 points per game from the previous year’s scoring average.
Morris says Cassity runs the defense with full autonomy. Oklahoma State is 3-1, and ESPN has the defense 26th in efficiency against the 51st-ranked schedule, a strong start even if the overall body of work still trails the names above him.
In Other News...
Oklahoma States Red Zone Problem Is Forcing Eric Morris To Adjust
Oklahoma States offense has been doing enough to move the ball, but the finish has been a different story. Eric Morris has already had to tweak his approach near the goal line after the Cowboys came away empty too often in recent games, and that has pushed the staff into a round of self-scouting as it looks for better ways to turn promising drives into touchdowns.
Drew Mestemakers passing has been cleaner in the red area, though it still has not become the reliable answer the Cowboys need. So Morris is weighing a more measured approach, with the kind of playcalling and personnel usage that can help Oklahoma State protect possessions and avoid settling for too many uneasy decisions once the field shrinks. [Read more 🡒]
Mike Gundys First Post Oklahoma State Move Will Surprise Cowboys Fans
Mike Gundys first move after Oklahoma State is heading to the broadcast booth, but only briefly. The former Cowboys head coach is set to make his television debut as a guest analyst on TNTs college football coverage this weekend, a notable turn for a coach who spent years as one of the most visible figures in the sport.
For Oklahoma State fans, the surprise is less that Gundy is showing up on TV than how selective hes been about it. He has limited his media schedule to spend more time with his family, and he already turned down other opportunities from ESPN and FOX Sports this season, making this TNT stint his only scheduled analyst appearance for now. [Read more 🡒]
Oklahoma State Now Has A Bigger Health Question Before UCF
Oklahoma States first availability report for the UCF game offered the kind of pregame snapshot teams usually prefer to keep simple, but this one carried a little more intrigue than expected. The Cowboys listed defensive tackle Landon Dean as out and offensive lineman Braydon Nelson as probable, a notable development for a lineman who has spent the season working his way back from offseason knee surgery.
The bigger wrinkle may have been the presence of wide receiver Wyatt Young on the report at all, since there was no obvious sign of an issue coming out of the West Virginia game or during the bye week. UCFs report brought its own concerns, with quarterback Alonza Barnett III among the players out because of a hamstring injury, but for Oklahoma State the focus is on whether Youngs status is a real new issue or just the first hint of a longer week of uncertainty. [Read more 🡒]