Oklahoma’s afternoon against South Carolina unraveled in almost every phase, and the 42-25 final at Gaylord Family - Oklahoma Memorial Stadium told only part of the story.
The Sooners were undone by a messy offensive showing, shaky tackling, and a defense that couldn’t sustain the few bright spots it created. A game that briefly felt salvageable kept slipping away, and Oklahoma never found a clean answer.
John Mateer’s line ended at 26 of 43 for 244 yards and two touchdowns, but the numbers only hint at how uneven his day was. He avoided an interception, which kept him from an even lower grade, yet the rest of the performance was littered with the same issues that have shown up before: missed reads, balls thrown into danger, sacks that should have been avoided and pockets he didn’t step up into when the chance was there.
He came close to coughing it up late when an apparent fumble was overturned to an incomplete pass with 4:01 left. Then, in the final two minutes, he threw what looked like an interception, only for a roughing-the-passer penalty to wipe it away. By then, the frustration had already boiled over enough that the OU student section was chanting for backup Whitt Newbauer.
The running game never gave Oklahoma much help, either. The Sooners finished with 115 rushing yards, but that total was misleading.
They entered the fourth quarter with only 23 yards on the ground, and much of what they did gain came while South Carolina was content to let the clock run and protect against the deep ball. No running back topped Tory Blaylock’s 32 yards, and the final chance to punch one in from the 1 on fourth-and-goal went to Lloyd Avant, who was stopped short.
One of the few real offensive positives came from junior Ivan Carreon, who delivered the best game of his career. He caught five passes for a career-high 88 yards and scored his first two touchdowns as a Sooner. Carreon had not had a catch this season before Saturday, but he broke through with a 34-yard touchdown early in the fourth quarter and added a 10-yard score later in the period, powering through two Gamecocks defenders on the way to the end zone.
Isaiah Sategna, coming off his biggest game of the season a week earlier, was held to 13 yards on four catches. Rocky Beers was also quiet early, with Mateer missing him on two throws before the Colorado State transfer finally hauled in a 10-yard grab.
By then, Oklahoma was already down 42-16. Beers finished with four catches for 54 yards, but all of it came in garbage time.
The problems up front were impossible to ignore. After a better showing last week with Michael Fasusi back at left tackle, Oklahoma’s line was pushed around again by South Carolina’s front. The Sooners used their seventh different offensive line combination in eight games, with Caleb Nitte making his first OU start at center in place of Jake Maikkula.
Fasusi, who had looked excellent against Mississippi State, had a rough first half. He was flagged twice for holding and once for false start before halftime, and he drew four flags overall after an illegal formation penalty was declined. He was also called for another false start in the final two minutes.
The defense had its moments, but not nearly enough of them. Oklahoma’s tackling issues, which had seemed to be under control, resurfaced in a big way.
That showed up most clearly on South Carolina’s first drive of the second half, when the Gamecocks converted both a third-and-short and a fourth-and-short after initial contact behind the line of scrimmage. On the fourth-down play, David Stone couldn’t finish the stop.
The Sooners did avoid points on that drive, but the missed tackles were still a bad sign for a unit that has been strong for much of the season. Danny Okoye and Kip Lewis combined for Oklahoma’s only sack of the day, and Lewis supplied the game’s biggest highlight with his third career Pick Six, which tied the game at 7 early before South Carolina answered right back.
Lewis’ interception was one of the few moments that gave Oklahoma a lift. Markel Ford added another pick with 1:53 left for the Sooners’ third South Carolina turnover, and Michael Boganowski had a second-half interception as well. But Oklahoma managed only one pass breakup all day, and the secondary was under pressure from the start.
The Sooners were already thin at cornerback, with Eli Bowen out again and Dakoda Fields and Jacobe Johnson also unavailable because of injury. Courtland Guillory and Trystain Haynes had trouble containing South Carolina’s receivers, and the safeties had their own issues at times. The staff needs depth back on the back end, and fast.
Linebackers had a hard time dealing with South Carolina quarterback LaNorris Sellers’ legs, too. His ability to extend plays made Oklahoma’s second level look hesitant at times, though Owen Heinecke still turned in another 10-tackle performance.
Special teams offered a few small wins. Tate Sandell hit field goals from 52 and 34 yards, and Jacob Ulrich averaged 45.7 yards on six punts, with two downed inside the 20.
But even there, Oklahoma couldn’t quite string together a clean finish. An apparent onside kick recovery with about three minutes left was overturned because James Nesta touched the ball before it had gone 10 yards, and Sandell then missed on the next onside-kick attempt.
What could have been a late spark instead became another reminder of how much went wrong for Oklahoma on a day when almost nothing came easy.
In Other News...
Oklahomas Offensive Collapse Just Raised A Bigger Brent Venables Question
Oklahomas 42-25 loss to South Carolina was the kind of night that leaves a coaching staff with more questions than answers, and the Sooners offense was at the center of it. Brent Venables watched his team struggle to keep pace for much of the game while LaNorris Sellers put together a dominant performance for the Gamecocks, throwing for 301 yards and three touchdowns and adding 96 rushing yards with two more scores.
Venables was asked afterward about possible coaching changes, but he declined to get into that topic after the defeat. For a program trying to steady itself, the bigger issue now is whether this was just a bad offensive night or a sign that something more significant has to change before the season moves on. [Read more 🡒]
Sooners Fans Turned On The Offense As Pressure Mounted Fast
The frustration inside Norman was hard to miss as the Sooners offense labored through a 42-25 home loss to South Carolina, a game that left fans voicing their displeasure from the stands. Oklahoma never found much rhythm, even with John Mateer finishing 26 of 43 for 244 yards and two touchdowns, and the pressure only grew as the night wore on against a Gamecocks team that kept answering with big plays.
South Carolina quarterback LaNorris Sellers helped keep the Sooners on their heels with both passing and rushing touchdowns, turning a difficult evening into a lopsided one. For Oklahoma, the defeat marked its second consecutive home loss for the first time since 2024, and the timing makes the next stretch even more important as the Sooners turn to Florida on November 7. [Read more 🡒]
Oklahomas Offense Just Became The Center Of Fan Anger
The frustration around Oklahomas offense boiled over in a home loss to South Carolina, a game that turned sour quickly as the Sooners managed only 71 yards in the first half. By the time the scoreboard had tilted to 42-25, the mood in the stadium had shifted from disappointment to open anger, with fans making their feelings known in no uncertain terms.
Ben Arbuckle became the focus of that backlash, as boos rolled through the stands and chants of Fire Arbuckle echoed during the game. The crowd thinned noticeably after halftime, a sign of how fast the patience had evaporated as Oklahomas offense continued to sputter in a defeat that only deepened the pressure around the unit. [Read more 🡒]