Kirk Herbstreit didn’t hide his frustration with the College Football Playoff rankings on Thursday, and Oklahoma ended up taking the sharpest hit.
Appearing on “The Pat McAfee Show,” the ESPN analyst zeroed in on the lower end of the committee’s Top 25 after the Sooners landed at No. 22 in their first CFP ranking of the season. Herbstreit’s bluntest line came when he addressed Oklahoma’s place in the mix: “What happened at the bottom doesn’t make a lot of sense to me with South Carolina losing at Arkansas,” Herbstreit said. “Oklahoma has been trash all year.”
The Sooners’ ranking came after Sunday’s 24-17 win over Ole Miss, a result that pushed them into the Top 25 at No. 22. They checked in one spot behind South Carolina, which beat them 42-25 in Norman, and one spot ahead of 7-3 Louisville.
Herbstreit did give the committee credit for moving Arizona up four spots to No. 19 after its 40-39 loss to unbeaten Utah. His complaint was aimed at the cluster of four-loss SEC teams sitting below the Wildcats.
“I’m not a big fan of a lot of those teams down there [in the rankings] from the SEC,” Herbstreit said.
He also touched on the conference-strength conversation that Heather Dinich raised earlier this week, a debate that feels especially relevant in a league that placed nine teams in the rankings. Oklahoma does have one eye-catching win - over then-No. 1 Texas - but four losses, including two at home, make the No. 22 spot look generous.
The Sooners opened the year ranked No. 10 in the AP poll after a 10-3 finish and a playoff appearance, with quarterback John Mateer back for his senior season. That optimism faded quickly. Oklahoma lost 17-10 at Michigan, then slogged through a 14-6 win over New Mexico before getting thumped 41-13 at Georgia.
The season’s biggest spike came in Dallas, where Oklahoma stunned top-ranked Texas 27-24. But the momentum vanished the next week in a 21-13 home loss to Kentucky, with Mateer throwing three interceptions. Then came the 42-25 loss to South Carolina that dropped the Sooners to 4-4, prompting Brent Venables to offer a blunt postgame assessment.
“We just didn’t coach well, didn’t have [them] well prepared, didn’t play good,” Venables said.
Two days later, Venables made a major change by firing offensive coordinator Ben Arbuckle and handing play-calling duties to tight ends coach Jason Witten. At the time, Oklahoma ranked 111th nationally in total offense, and Mateer had already accounted for nine turnovers in the first six games.
Since the switch, the Sooners have steadied themselves. They won 23-7 at Florida and then held off Ole Miss, with Venables saying he’s “really proud of John, everything he’s had to fight through and overcome this season.”
That Texas win is the one result that cuts against Herbstreit’s criticism. Before that game, he backed the Longhorns and said, “I just don’t think they can win, with the offense the way they are playing.”
Venables’ future is already secured after Oklahoma gave him a six-year, $63 million extension in August, with a $51.67 million buyout if he were fired after this season. Even so, he has now made two in-season coordinator changes, having also fired Seth Littrell in 2024. A strong finish would at least calm some of the noise in Norman.
Oklahoma hosts Texas A&M on Saturday at 3:45 p.m. ET on ESPN2 before closing the regular season at Missouri on Nov. 28.
In Other News...
Kip Lewis Sees What Oklahomas Next Linebacker Group Could Become
Oklahomas linebacker room is headed for a transition soon, with Kip Lewis and Owen Heinecke expected to move on and leave the next wave of players to carry more of the load. For now, Lewis is still in the middle of that group, and he has had a close view of what comes next as younger linebackers start to work their way into the conversation under Brent Venables.
Lewis has pointed to the hunger and eagerness of players like Cole Sullivan and James Nesta, the kind of traits that can speed up a rooms growth if the learning curve is handled well. His message to the younger group has been about adjusting to Venables coaching style and embracing the demands that come with it, which makes the position groups future feel promising even as the present remains in flux. [Read more 🡒]
Oklahoma May Have Found Another In-State Back Worth Watching
Oklahomas 2027 recruiting work in the state may be adding another name worth tracking, as Newcastle High School running back Ben Rogers is set to make an official visit to Norman. The Sooners are expected to extend an offer during the trip, and Rogers has already started to draw attention after a strong senior season. Rivals lists him as a three-star prospect, while the other major recruiting services have not yet rated him, and his only reported offer so far has come from Abilene Christian.
For Oklahoma, the appeal is obvious: another in-state back with a chance to strengthen a class that is already building local momentum. If Rogers leaves campus with the offer and eventually commits, he would become the third running back in the Sooners 2027 class and the sixth in-state pledge overall, a sign that the staff is still leaning hard into nearby talent as it fills out the future roster. [Read more 🡒]
Oklahomas Bowl Path Suddenly Includes A Matchup Fans Would Love
Back-to-back wins have pushed Oklahoma to 6-4 and made the Sooners bowl eligible for the 28th straight season, keeping a familiar postseason streak alive even as the final shape of the year is still taking form. With the regular season winding down, attention is already shifting to where Brent Venables team could land and which opponent might await once the bowls are sorted out.
Several projections have started to surface, and one in particular would grab plenty of attention in this part of the country: a possible Texas Bowl meeting with Oklahoma State. Other forecasts have the Sooners headed elsewhere, including a Las Vegas Bowl matchup with USC or a Texas Bowl date with Iowa State, but those outcomes will keep moving as the rest of the season plays out and the bowl picture sharpens. [Read more 🡒]
