Oklahoma had chances. Plenty of them. But in a game that hardly gave either side many possessions, the Sooners couldn’t turn enough of those opportunities into points and Kentucky made the defining plays late in a 21-13 win Saturday night at Oklahoma Memorial Stadium.
John Mateer was under siege most of the night. He was sacked five times behind a battered offensive line and threw three interceptions, including a backbreaking pick six in the final minute.
The loss dropped Oklahoma to 3-3 overall and 1-2 in Southeastern Conference play, while No. 15 Kentucky improved to 6-1 and 4-1 in SEC action.
The first half was all about efficiency, or the lack of it. Each team had just three full offensive drives before halftime.
Kentucky got the start it wanted, driving for a touchdown on its opening possession and becoming the first team this season to do that against Brent Venables’ defense. Oklahoma answered with a solid march of its own, but that series ended with a Tate Sandell field goal, not seven points.
Mateer and offensive coordinator Ben Arbuckle kept pressing. Another promising drive reached the red zone, only to end on an interception after Oklahoma tried a fourth-and-2 fake field goal pass. Later, though, Mateer did finish a drive the right way, connecting with Rocky Beers on a 20-yard touchdown with 30 seconds left before halftime to give the Sooners a 10-7 lead.
That lead didn’t last, and neither did Oklahoma’s rhythm. The Sooners opened the third quarter with a punt, then watched the defense force another. Sandell added another field goal on a long drive to make it 13-7, but the offense never quite finished the job.
The turning point came when Mateer’s pass toward Isaiah Sategna was disrupted as he threw deep. What might have been a 38-yard touchdown became a 43-yard interception return by Kentucky’s Ty Bryant. From there, the Wildcats went 44 yards for the go-ahead touchdown, capped by Kenny Minche’s 12-yard scoring throw to Willie Rodriguez, for a 14-13 lead early in the fourth quarter.
Oklahoma’s final chances disappeared quickly. A possession with 6:04 left ended in a three-and-out, with Mateer sacked twice. Then he was intercepted on each of the Sooners’ last two drives, the final one returned 41 yards for a touchdown that pushed Kentucky ahead 21-13 with 67 seconds remaining.
Sategna was the main outlet for Oklahoma and got the ball early and often after catching just three passes last week. He hauled in four catches in the first half alone, though those went for only 23 yards, and he also nearly sprang loose on a 16-yard punt return.
He came close to a touchdown late in the half, but Mateer’s throw was slightly behind him and the defender broke it up before Beers scored on the next play. Sategna finished with eight catches for 83 yards.
Another bright spot was Deion Burks Choice, who got his first career start and made an early third-and-5 catch count with an 18-yard toe-tapping grab along the sideline. He then added the kind of play that changes field position in a hurry, catching a pass over the middle just before halftime, shaking off Terhyon Nichols and turning it into a 34-yard gain. Choice had three catches for 70 yards in the first half and ended with a team-high 98 yards on five receptions.
Freshman defensive end Kreul also flashed after a shaky start. On Kentucky’s second possession, he bit on a keeper and opened a lane for 13 easy yards.
But he responded immediately, dropping Kenny Minchey for a 1-yard loss on the next play and then closing the first quarter with a sack for a 2-yard loss. Kreul finished with six tackles, 2.5 quarterback sacks and three tackles for loss.
The fake field goal was another wasted opportunity. Holder Jacob Ulrich’s throw - whether improvised or drawn up that way by special teams coordinator Doug Deakin - sailed behind Rocky Beers in the end zone and was intercepted by Jordan Castell. A clean throw would have left Beers alone for an uncontested touchdown, but the awkward jump before the pass wrecked the play.
Ulrich did deliver as a punter, though. His first punt of the second half traveled 54 yards and pinned Kentucky inside its 10. He finished with three punts and averaged 45.0 yards per kick.
Oklahoma heads to Mississippi State next week. The Bulldogs are 3-3 and have been blown out in each of their last two SEC games.
In Other News...
Oklahoma Still Has One Big Problem After Beating Texas
Oklahomas win over Texas gave the Sooners a much-needed jolt, but it also did not erase the larger concern hanging over the program as it turns to No. 15 Kentucky. The victory showed the group can still find enough to get through a rivalry game, yet the bigger issue remains on the offensive side, where consistency has been too hard to count on. Ben Arbuckle, Lloyd Avant, Tate Sandell and John Mateer all sit at the center of that effort as Oklahoma tries to turn one good result into something more stable.
The next stretch will be about whether the Sooners can carry that energy into practice and then into actual execution on game day. Momentum in October can disappear quickly if the offense does not clean up its rhythm, and Oklahoma cannot afford to waste the confidence it gained against Texas. Kentucky offers the kind of test that will show whether the Sooners are building something dependable or still relying on flashes to get by. [Read more 🡒]
Oklahomas Offense Still Has One Big Problem After Texas
The Texas win gave Oklahoma a useful reminder of what its offense can look like when it settles in and strings plays together, but the larger picture still shows a group searching for a steadier ceiling. The Sooners have slipped in the national rankings across total offense, passing, rushing and scoring compared with last season, a sign that the flashes have not yet turned into week-to-week production.
Ben Arbuckle has kept the approach flexible, saying the goal is to score on every drive while also leaning into complementary football and taking care of the ball. That balance matters more now, because Oklahoma has shown enough promise to suggest the pieces are there, but the next step is proving the execution can hold up once the emotion of a rivalry win fades and the grind of the schedule picks back up. [Read more 🡒]
These Overlooked Sooners Could Decide Oklahomas Edge Against Kentucky
Sullivans return from injury gave Oklahoma another useful piece on defense in the Red River matchup with Texas, where he worked 13 snaps and got back into the rotation at a time when depth matters more than ever. The Sooners have been leaning on a mix of contributors across the roster, from Jonathan Hattons start at running back and his early promise beside Lloyd Avant to Isaiah Sategnas steady production as the teams leader in receptions and yards.
Now the focus shifts to Kentucky, where Oklahomas edge could hinge on some of those same understated names carrying their weight again. Adepoju Adebawore and Jayden Jackson have been important through five games, and Adebawore in particular is expected to be a factor in trying to keep quarterback Kenny Minchey contained while also helping disrupt the Wildcats ground game. [Read more 🡒]