Oklahoma doesn’t need John Mateer to play like a superhero. It needs him to handle the easy stuff.
That’s the message Ben Arbuckle has been driving home after the Sooners’ loss to Michigan, where even the simple throws turned messy and the offense never found a steady rhythm. The Oklahoma offensive coordinator said the issue wasn’t one single thing, but the common thread was clear: Mateer has to take the layups.
“John will be the first one to come up here and tell you he didn't play his best,” Arbuckle said this week. “He didn't take the layups, if you would, whenever he needed to in certain situations. And so, in regards to the sailed throws, the play all day, it was just uneven.”
That unevenness showed up in a few different ways against the Wolverines. Mateer missed open receivers, sailed throws and didn’t connect with Elijah Thomas, who was left wide open several times. OU’s offense also had only 10 full possessions in that game, and eight of them ended in a punt or a turnover.
For a quarterback who was expected to look more settled in his second season with the Sooners, that was a rough reminder of what still needs cleaning up. The questions now are less about whether Mateer can flash and more about whether Oklahoma can build something functional around the version of him it actually has right now.
There is still time for a turnaround. The Sooners have 10 games left, and Mateer has already shown toughness and playmaking ability in the past.
But with a loss already on the board and No. 1 Texas and No.
2 Georgia still ahead, Arbuckle knows the clock is ticking.
“It starts with me as the coach,” Arbuckle said. “If (Mateer’s) play is uneven, then there's something I'm doing as a coach that there's a disconnect there. It's not all his fault and I have to continue to be better whenever we get in those moments, we get in those situations in the game and especially if there's easy layups that we're executing, because that helps keep the offense on rhythm.”
Brent Venables said the staff went through the tape right away to sort out what happened against Michigan. Was it a defense doing something special, or was it Oklahoma failing at the basics?
His answer was both.
“Is that them making a play? Is that us getting got?
Or is that us not doing some of the most basic fundamental things?” Venables said.
“If we're a little better, and we nail the basics in, again, it's a game of fundamentals and execution. It's not over that everybody else wants to make it more complicated than it is, and at times we can get in our own way.”
Mateer owned his performance after the game and has gone back to work since then. Around him, the message from teammates has been steady, not shaky.
Running back Lloyd Avant said he expected to see Mateer down after the loss in Ann Arbor, but instead found a quarterback trying to keep everyone else level. Wide receiver Mackenzie Alleyne pointed to preparation and daily habits as the way Mateer can settle himself before games.
"We're aware of (the pressure) but he keeps coming to practice with those daily habits,” Alleyne said. “Preparation is the key. Having good preparation, knowing what to expect and knowing what to do in that moment, when gameday comes it's way less pressure and lots less fear so you can feel more comfortable going into each play."
Offensive lineman Eddy Pierre-Louis said the support goes both ways.
“John, that's my guy, and everybody knows John got our back, and we got his back all the time. We know what we got, and we know what we can be. So we just have to keep doing the little things.”
One possible way to make things easier is to trim down how much Mateer is asked to process on a given snap. He threw 33 passes against Michigan, and Oklahoma may want that number to come down. He also ran for 45 yards on 13 carries, and there’s been discussion about leaning more on that part of his game to help the offense find a better rhythm.
Arbuckle sounds open to that approach.
“Whenever the moments, the situations, the scheme and the structure that you’re playing call for it?” Arbuckle said. “Alright, it’s probably a good idea if we do it, especially given John’s track record as a runner and how effective and how efficient and how tough he can be running the football.”
The Sooners will get their next chance to see whether that adjustment helps when they host New Mexico on Saturday. The standard is straightforward: hit the screens, take the easy throws, avoid the unnecessary mistakes and keep the offense on schedule.
Mateer does not have to be perfect. He just has to make the layups.
And if he does, Oklahoma’s offense has a chance to move in the right direction. If he doesn’t, the way the Sooners build around him becomes a much bigger issue.
In Other News...
Oklahoma Faces A Big Depth Test Against New Mexico
The Sooners are heading into their meeting with New Mexico with some early-season depth already being put to the test. Starting left tackle Michael Fasusi and wide receiver Trell Harris are both unavailable, which pushes Ryan Fodje and freshman Noah Best into bigger roles up front and leaves Elijah Thomas with a chance to absorb more of the passing-game load.
On defense, linebacker Kip Lewis is also sidelined, so James Nesta is in line to start in his place. The good news for Oklahoma is that the backfield remains intact, with Jonathan Hatton Jr. and Tory Blaylock both healthy and available, giving the offense at least one experienced area to lean on while the Sooners sort through a few key absences. [Read more 🡒]
Brent Venables Just Turned Oklahoma's Offense Into A Bigger Problem
A win over New Mexico did little to quiet the noise around Oklahomas offense, and Brent Venables didnt try to soften it afterward. The Sooners coach was blunt in his criticism of offensive coordinator Ben Arbuckle after a sluggish showing, saying the unit has to improve significantly as the season moves forward. For a program that expected more balance and a cleaner product on that side of the ball, the message landed as a public warning as much as a postgame assessment.
The frustration wasnt confined to Venables comments. During the game, fans were already chanting for Arbuckle to be fired, a sharp sign of how quickly patience is wearing thin. Venables declined to express confidence in Arbuckles current performance, leaving an already uneasy situation even more exposed as Oklahoma tries to steady an offense that has become its own problem. [Read more 🡒]
Oklahoma Has One Problem Brent Venables Cant Ignore
Oklahoma has spent enough time under Brent Venables proving it can lean on defense, but the broader picture still leaves little room for comfort. The Sooners have been sturdy on that side of the ball while the offense has lagged behind, and after the loss to Michigan, the imbalance is hard to ignore as the team heads into games against New Mexico and Georgia.
Venables has made it clear he wants complementary football, the kind where the offense can stay on the field, sustain drives and give the defense a little breathing room. That remains the next step for Oklahoma, because without a more reliable attack, the Sooners can keep hanging around, but they will keep asking too much of a defense that has already done its part. [Read more 🡒]