Oklahoma’s quarterback situation is once again under the microscope, and Brent Venables isn’t ruling anything out.
John Mateer remains the starter for now, but the Sooners spent the bye week giving Bowe Bentley and Whitt Newbauer extra snaps as Venables and his staff evaluated every option ahead of Saturday’s Red River Rivalry showdown with No. 1 Texas at the State Fair of Texas.
Venables said the staff even debated pulling Mateer during Oklahoma’s 41-13 loss to No. 2 Georgia, though they stayed with him in the game. That decision came against the backdrop of an offense that has struggled badly with Mateer at the controls, with the Sooners averaging just 11.5 points per game against Power Four opponents.
“I have no idea,” Venables said. “We're not there right now … John's our starting quarterback.”
Mateer’s season has gone from promising to problematic. The former Washington State transfer arrived as the No. 1 quarterback transfer two years ago and was viewed as a major get when he signed with Oklahoma. But after a strong start before hand surgery in 2025, both he and the offense have stalled.
The senior is completing 66% of his passes for 883 yards, but he’s averaging only 1.9 yards per carry and has thrown four interceptions in his last three games. Oklahoma’s offense has been one of the worst in the SEC, sitting last in total offense and 15th in scoring offense as the Sooners have stumbled to a 2-2 start.
The timing is rough, even by Oklahoma’s recent standards. The Sooners have dropped three of their last four games, and in those three losses they’ve scored just 3.0 points per game. Three of the four worst Red River scoring outputs in Oklahoma’s last 50 years belong to Venables.
If Oklahoma does decide to move on from Mateer, the options are thin.
Newbauer, a former Mercer transfer, is the more experienced backup. The 6-foot-6, 240-pound quarterback started seven games as a freshman at Mercer in 2024, completing 56% of his passes for 1,398 yards, 12 touchdowns and four interceptions while helping the program reach the FCS quarterfinals. Since arriving at Oklahoma, though, he has attempted only five passes for 12 yards across two seasons.
Bentley offers more upside. The freshman was a four-star recruit who led Celina, Texas, to a state championship in high school. He was rated the No. 109 player in the Class of 2026, finished his senior season with 2,911 passing yards, 32 touchdowns and a 77% completion rate, and has already logged one incomplete pass against UTEP.
“We've got great belief in them, trust in them,” Venables said. “There's a body of work that both of those guys, both Bowe and Whitt, have put out there and for us to evaluate. They're doing a nice job, they're working hard, improving incrementally and doing all the things that we want our quarterback to do as a whole, as a group.”
Venables has been through this kind of quarterback turbulence before. Two years ago, he turned away from blue-chip passer Jackson Arnold after a slow start, giving true freshman Michael Hawkins Jr. a shot.
Hawkins beat Auburn in his first start, then struggled badly in a 34-3 loss to then-No. 1 Texas.
He lasted one more game before Arnold got his job back in a 35-9 loss to South Carolina, and offensive coordinator Seth Littrell was also dismissed.
Since Jeff Lebby left for Mississippi State and Dillon Gabriel moved on to Oregon, Oklahoma has still not found steady answers. Venables can make another change at quarterback or go in a different direction with offensive coordinator Ben Arbuckle, but the bigger issue has lingered for years. The Sooners have not finished higher than 97th in yards per play offense over the past three seasons, and their rushing offense has declined every year since Riley departed.
In Other News...
Oklahomas Early Losses Are Raising An Even Bigger 2026 Fear
The early part of Oklahomas 2026 season already looked shaky, and it has only gotten harder to frame those losses in a flattering way. The Sooners lone notable win was a shutout of UTEP, but that result has lost some shine as the Miners have continued to struggle and have been beaten by wide margins on average.
More troubling for Oklahoma is what the rest of the schedule is saying about those defeats to Michigan, Georgia and New Mexico. As those teams have shown their own flaws since facing the Sooners, the concern around Norman is not just about a rough start, but about what those games might be revealing about Oklahomas level of competitiveness this fall. [Read more 🡒]
Ben Arbuckle May Need A Drastic OU Offensive Rethink
Josh Heupel showed against Auburn that an in-game reset can change the feel of an offense in a hurry. Tennessee moved away from freshman quarterback Faizon Brandon, turned to sophomore George MacIntyre to steady the operation and leaned heavily on DeSean Bishop as the running game took over. It was the kind of practical adjustment that can make a staff look decisive in real time, especially when the original plan is not producing much rhythm.
For Oklahoma, that kind of flexibility is the conversation point around Ben Arbuckle. John Mateers struggles have left the Sooners searching for a cleaner path on offense, and the Tennessee example is a reminder that a coordinator sometimes has to be willing to reshape the plan instead of waiting for it to click on its own. Whether Arbuckle goes that far is the unanswered question, but the pressure to find something more workable is only growing. [Read more 🡒]
Oklahomas Biggest Red River Problem Could Decide Everything
When Oklahoma heads into the Red River showdown with Texas, the rushing battle looms as one of the clearest indicators of which side will control the afternoon. History in this rivalry has leaned heavily toward the team that runs the ball better, and that makes the Sooners ground game a central concern after recent struggles on both sides of the line.
John Mateer gives Oklahoma a different kind of answer because his legs can change the math even when the traditional run game is stuck. Against a Texas defense that has been stout enough to make every yard work, the Sooners may need Mateers scrambling and designed runs to keep the offense balanced and give themselves a chance to win the most important matchup on the field. [Read more 🡒]