College sports just got a new wrinkle, and Oklahoma fans suddenly have a strange little thought exercise on their hands: who, if anyone, could theoretically walk back into Norman because of the new federal ruling?
The offseason “5-for-5” rule was designed to cap careers and wipe away redshirt years, whether they came from limited game action in football or medical issues. It was supposed to apply to athletes already in college.
But federal judge Charlotte Sweeney of the U.S. District Court of Colorado has ordered the NCAA to declare all Class of 2022 athletes who exhausted four seasons this spring, according to On3.
That opens the door, at least on paper, to a handful of former Sooners.
The most obvious name is R Mason Thomas. He put together a big-time career in Norman, finishing with 25.5 tackles for loss and 17 sacks while becoming one of the SEC’s most relentless pass rushers. Thomas was selected in the second round of the 2026 NFL Draft by the Kansas City Chiefs.
Gracen Halton would also be a major addition if this ever became real. Oklahoma has questions about interior defensive line depth, and Halton would help solve them fast. He closed out his Sooners career with 17.5 tackles for loss and 8.5 sacks, then went in the fourth round of the 2026 NFL Draft to the San Francisco 49ers.
Damonic Williams belongs in that same conversation. He finished with 18.5 tackles for loss and seven sacks and gave Oklahoma a steady interior presence that, as the source notes, probably didn’t get enough attention. He signed as an undrafted free agent, which puts him near the top of the list of players who could possibly return.
Robert Spears-Jennings is another former Sooner who would change the equation in a hurry. He wrapped up his Oklahoma career with 178 tackles and two interceptions and formed one of the best safety duos in the SEC last season alongside Peyton Bowen. The Pittsburgh Steelers took him in the seventh round of the 2026 NFL Draft.
Then there’s Jaren Kanak, whose career took a different route. He began as a linebacker before shifting to tight end for his final season, and he caught 44 passes for 533 yards last year. Another year of learning the position - especially under Jason Witten - would help, but he was also taken in the seventh round of the 2026 NFL Draft by the Tennessee Titans.
Marvin Jones Jr. is in the mix as well. A five-star recruit in the 2022 class, he spent time with Georgia and Florida State before arriving in Norman.
Last season, he was a regular part of the Oklahoma defense, finishing with 21 tackles, five tackles for loss and two sacks. He also signed as an undrafted free agent.
Jaydn Ott is the longest shot of the bunch. Technically, he could come back to college, though the source says it likely would not be in Norman.
His lone season at Oklahoma fell well short of expectations after he arrived as one of the biggest transfer portal pickups last year to help fix the running back room. He ended up with 21 carries for 68 yards and multiple DNPs, then signed as an undrafted free agent with the Kansas City Chiefs.
In an ironic twist, he’ll be coached there by DeMarco Murray, his running backs coach at Oklahoma.
The reality is that none of this looks likely. Most of these players are already in NFL training camps, several have rookie deals, and there are still real questions about how the NCAA’s ruling would apply to players who’ve already moved on to the pros.
Still, the possibility itself is enough to make you stop and think. For Oklahoma, Thomas, Halton and Spears-Jennings would instantly shore up already strong spots, while Kanak and Jones Jr. could add useful depth and flexibility. Whether any of them ever plays in crimson and cream again, the ruling has created a scenario that would have sounded impossible just a few months ago.
In Other News...
Oklahoma Tight End Battle Is Suddenly One Of OUs Biggest Questions
With Jaren Kanak gone after leading Oklahoma in receiving in 2025, the Sooners are reworking one of the more interesting spots on the offense. Jason Witten, in his first season coaching the tight ends, now has a room built around two veteran transfers in redshirt seniors Rocky Beers and Hayden Hansen, each bringing prior college experience into a position that suddenly needs a new identity.
Spring practices suggested there is at least some traction to work with, but the job is still wide open and the Sooners are treating it as an honest competition rather than a settled depth chart. For a team that has leaned on the tight end in key moments, the next few months will determine whether this becomes a quiet strength or another question mark heading into the season. [Read more 🡒]
Parker Livingstone Could Change What Oklahoma's Offense Looks Like
Oklahoma added Parker Livingstone from the transfer portal to give its offense another outside weapon, and the fit makes immediate sense. The former Texas receiver is expected to work on the perimeter, where the Sooners have been looking for more punch as they reshape the passing game around a deeper receiver room and a new look under center.
Livingstones arrival also matters beyond just this season, because his role could help define how Oklahoma wants to attack with John Mateer now and with Bowe Bentley down the road. If he settles in the way the staff hopes, he could become more than just another addition to the rotation and instead a player who helps change the way the Sooners deploy their offense going forward. [Read more 🡒]