Michigan got the win, but Saturday did not feel like a clean start for Bryce Underwood or for the staff around him.
The Wolverines needed a review, a lucky extra second and a 47-yard touchdown pass to JJ Buchanan to escape Western Michigan in Week 1, and the final score did little to hide how rocky the performance was. Underwood finished 12-of-22 for 170 yards with one touchdown and one interception, while also leading Michigan on the ground with nine carries for 47 yards and a rushing score.
Afterward, Kyle Whittingham made the message plain: Underwood is the starter for now, not forever. “It’s not something that’s infinite,” Whittingham said.
“At some point, we’ve got to turn a corner, and we’ve got to see improvement.” He also said the staff has to own part of the problem, not just the quarterback, after Michigan never really found a rhythm beyond the opening drive.
That tone stood in sharp contrast to the way Whittingham talked about Underwood during fall camp, when the sophomore was reportedly sharp almost every day. Saturday, Whittingham didn’t have a clean explanation for the drop-off.
“It’s unfortunate and disappointing because we see him every day and he’s been very sharp all through fall camp,” Whittingham said. “I don’t have a great explanation right now.”
The stat line only gets rougher when you dig deeper. Underwood threw a pick-six before halftime and then lost a fourth-quarter fumble that led to a Western Michigan field goal. His late miracle throw made up for nearly a third of his passing yardage.
The setup makes the next step even more important. Oklahoma comes to Ann Arbor next, and that’s a much stiffer test than the one Michigan just barely survived.
Whittingham’s bigger issue is not simply whether Underwood keeps the job. It’s getting the highest-rated recruit in program history to fit the offense the staff wants to run.
Underwood’s path has already come with massive expectations, and Michigan leaned even harder on his legs Saturday because the passing game never really got rolling. The quarterback said he thought the game was over before the clock correction gave him one last chance.
“When I saw zeros on the clock, it looked like we lost the game,” Underwood said. “And then we had one second, and the thought was, give my guys an opportunity, and that’s what I did.”
In Other News...
Oklahoma Just Got An Unexpected Late Boost In A Thin Secondary
A thin secondary got a little more help late in the cycle when Brent Venables landed a transfer commitment from former Wisconsin starter DYoni Hill. Hill brings a journeyman path through Miami, Marshall and Wisconsin, and he arrives with the kind of experience Oklahoma has been hunting as it tries to steady a cornerback group that needed more bodies and proven reps.
Jaydon Southard from Stephen F. Austin is another name worth watching as Oklahoma keeps working the transfer market for help on defense. The Sooners have been aggressive about adding depth where it matters most, and Southards fit could give Venables another option if the interest turns into a commitment. [Read more 🡒]
Red River Just Got More Personal For Oklahoma After One Transfer
The Red River rivalry has always carried enough emotion without any extra backstory, but the player movement between Oklahoma and Texas has given this years meeting a different kind of edge. Parker Livingstones move from Texas to Oklahoma adds a fresh layer to a matchup that already lives on history, bragging rights and every small detail that can tilt the week one way or the other.
Hollywood Smothers going the other direction only sharpens that feeling for Sooners fans, because these swaps turn a familiar rivalry into something more personal on both sidelines. Steve Sarkisians acknowledgment that some departures were made to create room for new transfers only underscores how modern roster building now bleeds into one of college footballs most traditional games, making the next Red River showdown feel even more charged. [Read more 🡒]
Oklahoma Transfer LB Is Earning Praise Before A Very Personal Test
Cole Sullivan has settled into a useful role for Oklahoma as the Sooners continue building depth on defense, and his work in the 51-0 win over UTEP drew a little more attention than usual. The junior linebacker finished with one tackle and one pass breakup, and Pro Football Focus gave him a 71.2 grade, a small but encouraging sign for a player who has made his value by being athletic, reliable and quick to process the action in front of him.
Now comes a much more personal matchup. Sullivan is getting ready to face Michigan, the program he transferred from, and the Sooners will be watching to see how he handles a game that carries more meaning than the average nonconference date. He has been backing up at middle linebacker while fitting smoothly into Oklahomas defense, but this one gives him a chance to show how far he has come since leaving Ann Arbor. [Read more 🡒]