John Mateer heads into the biggest stage of Oklahoma’s season with his confidence intact, even if the opening month has given him plenty to shake off.
The Sooners come out of the bye week and straight into Saturday’s Red River Rivalry against No. 1 Texas, carrying a 2-2 record and an offense that has yet to find its rhythm. For Mateer, the reset comes at the right time after a stretch that has featured uneven play and some of the loudest scrutiny of his college career.
Through four games in 2026, Mateer has completed passes for 883 yards, eight touchdowns and four interceptions. In Oklahoma’s 41-13 loss to No. 2 Georgia on Sept. 26, he also lost two fumbles and threw an interception, a rough outing that fit the larger struggles around the Sooners’ offense.
The numbers tell the story of a unit still searching for answers. Oklahoma is averaging just 22 points per game and an SEC-worst 321.3 yards per game, and Mateer has already been pressured 45 times. His play has been inconsistent, but the offense around him has not offered much relief.
Still, Mateer isn’t backing away from the moment.
“I’m more excited,” Mateer said. “It’s the game. It’s what everybody says it is, and I’ve always wanted to play in it.”
He has taken more criticism than anyone else on the roster, which comes with the territory at quarterback for Oklahoma. Mateer said he has handled that by staying away from social media and keeping his focus on improving.
“I’m off (social media), so I don’t see it, it’s not good for anybody to see,” Mateer said. “The fact that I haven’t performed is disappointing, but I’m blessed to play ball today and get better… Even when you struggle, you get judged, it’s because I’ve done good in the past. I’m learning.”
The bye week gave Mateer and the rest of the offense a chance to clear their heads after three rough outings. He said the time away helped him personally and gave the group a chance to reset together.
“I had a good break, personally,” Mateer said. “We had some good practices, and I got to hang out with some of the guys, go out to dinner, reset. It was good being around the guys - we’re ready to go.”
Last season’s Red River matchup offers a reminder of how quickly the spotlight can turn. Mateer returned for that game only a few weeks after hand surgery and threw three interceptions in Oklahoma’s 23-6 loss to Texas.
That kind of result stings, and Mateer knows Saturday could swing momentum for the Sooners. But he says his confidence won’t ride on one game.
“If your confidence is results-based, it will fluctuate in that way,” Mateer said. “Have I been challenged to put my confidence in the process?
Yeah. But I stand firm in that.
Obviously there would be a smile on my face for 24 hours, but you get better as the season goes on to play every game consistently.”
In Other News...
Oklahomas Early Losses Are Raising An Even Bigger 2026 Fear
The early part of Oklahomas 2026 season already looked shaky, and it has only gotten harder to frame those losses in a flattering way. The Sooners lone notable win was a shutout of UTEP, but that result has lost some shine as the Miners have continued to struggle and have been beaten by wide margins on average.
More troubling for Oklahoma is what the rest of the schedule is saying about those defeats to Michigan, Georgia and New Mexico. As those teams have shown their own flaws since facing the Sooners, the concern around Norman is not just about a rough start, but about what those games might be revealing about Oklahomas level of competitiveness this fall. [Read more 🡒]
Ben Arbuckle May Need A Drastic OU Offensive Rethink
Josh Heupel showed against Auburn that an in-game reset can change the feel of an offense in a hurry. Tennessee moved away from freshman quarterback Faizon Brandon, turned to sophomore George MacIntyre to steady the operation and leaned heavily on DeSean Bishop as the running game took over. It was the kind of practical adjustment that can make a staff look decisive in real time, especially when the original plan is not producing much rhythm.
For Oklahoma, that kind of flexibility is the conversation point around Ben Arbuckle. John Mateers struggles have left the Sooners searching for a cleaner path on offense, and the Tennessee example is a reminder that a coordinator sometimes has to be willing to reshape the plan instead of waiting for it to click on its own. Whether Arbuckle goes that far is the unanswered question, but the pressure to find something more workable is only growing. [Read more 🡒]
Oklahomas Biggest Red River Problem Could Decide Everything
When Oklahoma heads into the Red River showdown with Texas, the rushing battle looms as one of the clearest indicators of which side will control the afternoon. History in this rivalry has leaned heavily toward the team that runs the ball better, and that makes the Sooners ground game a central concern after recent struggles on both sides of the line.
John Mateer gives Oklahoma a different kind of answer because his legs can change the math even when the traditional run game is stuck. Against a Texas defense that has been stout enough to make every yard work, the Sooners may need Mateers scrambling and designed runs to keep the offense balanced and give themselves a chance to win the most important matchup on the field. [Read more 🡒]