John Mateer’s Oklahoma run has gone from electric to uneasy in a hurry.
A year after arriving in Norman as the Sooners’ headline quarterback, Mateer is now heading into a matchup with No. 2 Georgia with questions hanging over him after Oklahoma’s last two games. The Sooners lost 17-10 to Michigan and then barely escaped New Mexico at home, a stretch that even brought boos from the Oklahoma crowd after one of Mateer’s interceptions against the Lobos.
That reaction would have been hard to imagine when Mateer first took over as one of the sport’s hottest breakout names.
Mateer is from Little Elm, Texas, and came out of high school as a three-star quarterback in the 247Sports Composite. Washington State was his only Division I offer aside from NMSU, and he joined the Cougars in 2022. He spent two seasons behind Cam Ward before finally winning the starting job in 2024, then exploded in his first year as the starter with 3,139 passing yards, 29 touchdowns and seven interceptions, plus 826 rushing yards and 15 scores on the ground.
That production followed him to Oklahoma before the 2025 season, when he transferred to Norman with offensive coordinator Ben Arbuckle.
The fit was immediate. Oklahoma opened 4-0, picked up ranked wins over No.
15 Michigan and No. 22 Auburn, and Mateer piled up 1,215 passing yards with six touchdowns and three interceptions while adding five rushing touchdowns.
For a while, he looked like exactly what the Sooners had been waiting for.
Then came the injury.
In Oklahoma’s win over Auburn on Sept. 20, Mateer broke a bone in his throwing hand in the first quarter and stayed in the game. He had surgery three days later, and a bye week gave the Sooners some breathing room before the Oct. 11 game against Texas.
Even so, there were obvious questions about what he would look like only 13 days after surgery. The answer was a rough first outing back: 202 passing yards, three interceptions and a season-low 52.6% completion rate in a game where Oklahoma managed just 258 total yards. Afterward, Mateer said his hand was fine.
He settled down after that and helped Oklahoma move to 5-1, with the Sooners’ only loss in that stretch coming in a 34-26 defeat to Ole Miss in late October. Across the next five games, he threw just one interception.
But the finish to 2025 turned messy again. Against LSU in the College Football Playoff first round, Mateer threw three interceptions, though Oklahoma still slipped past the Tigers 17-13.
Against Alabama, the Sooners came out flying. Mateer ran for a touchdown and threw for another in the first half as Oklahoma built a 17-0 lead early in the second quarter.
Then the tide turned. Alabama forced an interception before halftime, and in the second half its defense held Oklahoma to four three-and-outs.
The Sooners managed only one touchdown, missed two field goals, and Alabama left with a 34-24 road win.
Now the frustration has spilled into 2026. In Oklahoma’s 14-6 win over New Mexico, Mateer threw two first-half interceptions. After the second one, which put the ball back in New Mexico’s hands deep in Oklahoma territory, fans booed him.
“You don’t need to boo us,” Mateer said via The Oklahoman after the game. “Sure, do it.
You do whatever you want. But we know.
We’re people, too.”
Mateer also admitted that on Oklahoma’s second touchdown of the day, he only spotted his open receiver because he heard fans yelling that he was open.
The numbers tell the same story as the eye test. In 2024, Mateer posted a 64.6% completion rate, 3,139 passing yards, 29 touchdowns, seven interceptions, 826 rushing yards and 15 rushing scores.
In 2025, he finished at 62.2% with 2,885 passing yards, 14 touchdowns, 11 interceptions, 431 rushing yards and eight rushing touchdowns. This season, he has completed 62.7% of his passes for 652 yards, six touchdowns and three interceptions, with 69 rushing yards and no rushing scores.
Oklahoma’s depth chart still has Mateer at No. 1, with junior Whitt Newbauer behind him and freshman Bowe Bentley at No. 3. Newbauer transferred from Mercer ahead of the 2025 season after throwing for 1,398 yards with 12 touchdowns and four interceptions as a freshman in 2024.
In Other News...
Oklahoma Suddenly Has A QB Problem Brent Venables Can't Ignore
Oklahomas trip to No. 2 Georgia turned into a blunt reminder that the Sooners have bigger offensive issues than one bad afternoon. Dillon Mateers costly mistakes were a major part of the 41-13 loss, and they came at a time when the rest of the offense was not built to help cover them up. The running game still has not taken a meaningful step forward from last season, which has left the passing attack carrying too much of the load.
Brent Venables has already acknowledged that a quarterback change is something the staff is weighing, but there is no decision yet. With No. 1 Texas up next, the timing only sharpens the pressure on Oklahoma to find some stability before the rivalry game arrives. For a team trying to keep its season from slipping, the question under center is suddenly unavoidable. [Read more 🡒]
Sooners First Half Meltdown Has Fans Fuming Over One Costly Trend
Oklahomas first half against Georgia quickly turned into a frustration-filled stretch, with John Mateer putting the ball on the ground and giving the Bulldogs extra chances to pull away. Georgia capitalized in a big way, turning one takeaway into an 85-yard fumble return by Chris Cole and later adding a 35-yard touchdown pass from Gunnar Stockton to Talyn Taylor as the Sooners struggled to steady themselves on either side of the ball.
There was at least one notable pregame development for Oklahoma, with junior defensive lineman David Stone taking the field after being listed as a gametime decision. Even so, the Sooners were left trying to dig out of a hole created by turnovers and a first-half surge from Georgia, a familiar kind of problem that had fans voicing their anger as the game got away from them. [Read more 🡒]
Oklahoma Heads Into Red River With One Alarming Problem
Oklahoma left Sanford Stadium with a result that felt bigger than just a tough night against No. 2 Georgia. The Sooners were overwhelmed 41-13, and the familiar issues from earlier in the season showed up again, with John Mateers early turnovers putting the offense in a hole before he settled in enough to complete more than 65% of his passes and find Rocky Beers for a touchdown.
The problem for Oklahoma is that the encouraging flashes did not offset the bigger picture. The running game never gave the offense much balance, and the defense could not fully cover for the mistakes on the other side of the ball. With a bye week now ahead, the Sooners have a little time to sort it out before facing No. 1 Texas in their next game, and that makes the margin for error feel even smaller. [Read more 🡒]