Herbstreit's Oklahoma Insult Crosses The Line

ESPN's Kirk Herbstreit isn't holding back as he labels Oklahoma's season "trash" and questions the latest College Football Playoff rankings.

Kirk Herbstreit didn’t hold back when he looked at the latest College Football Playoff rankings, and Oklahoma ended up taking the hardest hit.

On “The Pat McAfee Show,” the ESPN analyst went after the Sooners after they landed at No. 22 in the committee’s Top 25. Herbstreit’s frustration was aimed at the way the bottom of the rankings shook out, especially with Oklahoma slotting in behind South Carolina and ahead of Louisville.

“What happened at the bottom doesn’t make a lot of sense to me with South Carolina losing at Arkansas,” Herbstreit said. “Oklahoma has been trash all year.”

Herbstreit also had praise for Arizona, which moved up four spots to No. 19 after a 40-39 loss to unbeaten Utah. But he wasn’t interested in giving much credit to the group of four-loss SEC teams clustered below the Wildcats.

“I’m not a big fan of a lot of those teams down there [in the rankings] from the SEC,” Herbstreit said.

The committee’s placement of Oklahoma comes after a season that has been uneven from the start. The Sooners entered the year No. 10 in the AP poll after finishing 10-3 last season and reaching the playoff, with quarterback John Mateer back for his senior year. Instead, the offense stumbled early and often.

Oklahoma opened with a 17-10 loss at Michigan, followed by a 14-6 win over New Mexico and a 41-13 defeat at Georgia. The Sooners then pulled off a shocker, beating then-No. 1 Texas 27-24 in Dallas, only to turn around and lose 21-13 at home to Kentucky the next week after Mateer threw three interceptions.

A 42-25 home loss to South Carolina dropped Oklahoma to 4-4, and coach Brent Venables didn’t sugarcoat what he saw afterward.

“We just didn’t coach well, didn’t have [them] well prepared, didn’t play good,” Venables said.

Two days later, Venables fired offensive coordinator Ben Arbuckle and handed play-calling duties to tight ends coach Jason Witten. At that point, Oklahoma ranked 111th nationally in total offense, and Mateer had already been charged with nine turnovers in the first six games.

The change has helped steady things. Oklahoma won 23-7 at Florida and then held off Ole Miss, and Venables said he’s “really proud of John, everything he’s had to fight through and overcome this season.”

The Texas win is the one result that complicates Herbstreit’s criticism. Before that game, he picked the Longhorns and said, “I just don’t think they can win, with the offense the way they are playing.”

Venables’ long-term future is secure after Oklahoma gave him a six-year, $63 million extension in August, with a $51.67 million buyout if he were fired after this season. Still, he has already made two in-season coordinator changes during his time in Norman, firing Seth Littrell in 2024 and Arbuckle this year.

Oklahoma now turns to Texas A&M at home on Saturday at 3:45 p.m. ET on ESPN2, before finishing the regular season at Missouri on Nov. 28.

In Other News...

Oklahomas Ranking Just Reignited A Brutal National Debate

Oklahomas return to the College Football Playoff Top 25 has put the Sooners back in the middle of a familiar national argument, and not everyone is buying the committees logic. ESPN analyst Kirk Herbstreit was openly critical of Oklahoma landing at No. 22, especially as the rankings continue to sort through the mess of four-loss SEC teams and the broader question of how much weight should be given to recent results versus the full body of work.

For Oklahoma, the placement comes after a win over Ole Miss and a season that has been far more uneven than anyone in Norman expected. The Sooners have four losses, including a home defeat to South Carolina, but there has been some improvement since Brent Venables made the midseason move to fire offensive coordinator Ben Arbuckle and hand the offense to Jason Witten. Even with that uptick, the ranking has only sharpened the debate over where Oklahoma really stands. [Read more 🡒]

Kip Lewis Sees What Oklahomas Next Linebacker Group Could Become

Oklahomas linebacker room is headed for a transition soon, with Kip Lewis and Owen Heinecke expected to move on and leave the next wave of players to carry more of the load. For now, Lewis is still in the middle of that group, and he has had a close view of what comes next as younger linebackers start to work their way into the conversation under Brent Venables.

Lewis has pointed to the hunger and eagerness of players like Cole Sullivan and James Nesta, the kind of traits that can speed up a rooms growth if the learning curve is handled well. His message to the younger group has been about adjusting to Venables coaching style and embracing the demands that come with it, which makes the position groups future feel promising even as the present remains in flux. [Read more 🡒]

Oklahoma May Have Found Another In-State Back Worth Watching

Oklahomas 2027 recruiting work in the state may be adding another name worth tracking, as Newcastle High School running back Ben Rogers is set to make an official visit to Norman. The Sooners are expected to extend an offer during the trip, and Rogers has already started to draw attention after a strong senior season. Rivals lists him as a three-star prospect, while the other major recruiting services have not yet rated him, and his only reported offer so far has come from Abilene Christian.

For Oklahoma, the appeal is obvious: another in-state back with a chance to strengthen a class that is already building local momentum. If Rogers leaves campus with the offer and eventually commits, he would become the third running back in the Sooners 2027 class and the sixth in-state pledge overall, a sign that the staff is still leaning hard into nearby talent as it fills out the future roster. [Read more 🡒]