The Oklahoma Sooners have carved out a reputation as a quarterback factory, consistently churning out talent that leaves a mark on college football. Names like Josh Heupel, Jason White, Sam Bradford, Landry Jones, Baker Mayfield, Kyler Murray, and Jalen Hurts are etched in the annals of Oklahoma's storied history. Among these, four have hoisted the coveted Heisman Trophy, while two others came tantalizingly close.
But let’s pose a hypothetical: if you were building a team from scratch today and could select any quarterback from Oklahoma's illustrious past, who would get the nod?
Former All-American Gerald McCoy recently weighed in with his choice, and it might surprise you. He bypassed the likes of Mayfield, Murray, and Bradford, opting instead for a quarterback who made headlines with his departure via the transfer portal.
"Caleb (Williams)," McCoy confidently stated in a conversation with Kyle Odegard for RotoGrinders. "I don't even have to think about it.
Baker's missing some athleticism, Kyler's on the smaller side, and while Jalen knows how to win, his passing isn't top-tier. Caleb, though?
He's the complete package. If I'm choosing one quarterback to thrive in any system with any coach, it's Caleb."
During his brief yet impactful tenure in Norman, Caleb Williams demonstrated why he's a standout talent. In just one season, he racked up 1,912 passing yards, 21 touchdowns, and only four interceptions, while also rushing for 442 yards and six touchdowns. His ability to deliver in clutch moments was epitomized in the showdown against Texas, where he orchestrated a thrilling comeback from a 28-7 deficit to secure a 55-48 victory.
Following that season, Williams made the move to USC with coach Lincoln Riley, where he continued to shine, eventually capturing a Heisman Trophy and being selected as the No. 1 pick in the NFL draft.
McCoy's endorsement of Williams underscores the immense talent he brought to Oklahoma, even if his exit via the transfer portal still stings for many Sooners fans. His legacy in Norman is a testament to his skill and potential, making him a compelling choice for anyone dreaming of building a powerhouse team.
In Other News...
Brent Venables Just Landed A Massive Defensive Commitment For 2027
A major early piece is in place for Oklahomas 2027 recruiting class, with another highly regarded defender giving Brent Venables staff a marquee addition to build around. The Sooners have landed a prospect who sits among the nations top 100 in multiple recruiting services, a profile that says as much about his ceiling as it does about the level of programs chasing him.
For Oklahoma, the appeal goes beyond rankings. The staff sees a defensive piece who can fit multiple spots in Venables scheme, with safety and cheetah both on the table as he develops. It also gives the Sooners another strong marker in a class that is starting to stack blue-chip talent, and one more reason for the rest of the country to keep watching how this group comes together. [Read more 🡒]
David Stone Is Suddenly Facing Oklahomas Biggest Defensive Question
David Stones progress from his first season to his second gave Oklahoma something to feel good about along the defensive line. The former five-star recruit was far more active in Year 2, finishing with 42 tackles, eight tackles for loss and 1.5 sacks after a quieter debut, and that kind of jump is exactly why the Sooners still view him as a cornerstone piece up front.
Gerald McCoy sees the same upward trend and thinks Stone is close to a different level altogether. The former Sooner has pointed to Stones ability to move from simply being a good player to becoming a dominant defensive lineman, and that is where Oklahomas biggest question now starts to form - whether Stone is ready to own a much bigger piece of the defense when the pressure rises next season. [Read more 🡒]