In the world of basketball, few comparisons spark as much debate as that between Shai Gilgeous-Alexander and James Harden. Both have graced the Oklahoma City Thunder with their talents, each has claimed an NBA MVP award, and while Harden boasts three league scoring titles, both are known for their knack at drawing fouls-a skill that often draws both admiration and criticism.
The debate over who stands taller in their prime recently took center stage on the "All the Smoke" podcast. Former NBA champion Vernon Maxwell was asked to weigh in on whether he'd choose Harden or SGA as the better player and scorer.
His answer? Despite his fondness for Harden, Maxwell leaned towards Gilgeous-Alexander.
Maxwell's choice surprised co-host Matt Barnes, who noted the influence of Harden's game on SGA's style. Barnes recalled Harden's peak years, marked by his uncanny ability to draw fouls by initiating contact-a skill that SGA seems to have mastered in his own right, using his shoulder or forearm to similar effect.
The similarities between Harden and Gilgeous-Alexander are undeniable. Both players excel below the rim, score prolifically, and frequently visit the free-throw line.
Harden, over his career, has averaged 8.2 free throw attempts per game, peaking at 11.8 in the 2019-20 season. His career scoring average sits at 24.1 points per game, a figure he's matched this season while splitting time between the Clippers and Cavaliers.
SGA, though earlier in his career, is not far behind. He's averaged 7.3 free throw attempts per game, and during the 2022-23 season, he was making nearly 11 trips to the line each night. His career scoring average of 25.2 points per game has surged to an impressive 31.7 this season.
Whether you side with Maxwell or Barnes, the comparison between Harden and Gilgeous-Alexander is a testament to their shared brilliance on the court. Both have carved out their own unique paths to greatness, leaving fans eager to see what heights they’ll reach next.