Luke Fahey’s path to Ohio State’s starting job can be traced back to one bad answer on a whiteboard.
Two years ago, at a meeting with USC’s coaching staff, Fahey was asked a simple question: What’s your best third-and-long play? He picked curl-flat, and Chad Johnson still remembers the moment with plenty of pain.
“Luke draws up curl flat,” Johnson said. “That’s the worst third-and-long call you could’ve made.”
Fahey knew it wasn’t the right answer. The meeting didn’t go the way he wanted, but Johnson, his coach at Mission Viejo High School in California, turned that setback into a teaching tool. From there, Johnson started putting Fahey through board interviews, then had him install plays and explain the offense to everyone else.
“I go, ‘Brother, let’s start working,’” Johnson said. “After he blew that meeting, I made him do board interviews all the time.
Then in spring, I made him install the plays. ‘You tell everybody the coaching points.
I’ll sit back here and make sure you don’t miss anything.’”
The goal was to get Fahey thinking like more than just a quarterback. Johnson pushed him into a deeper understanding of the offense, almost like an on-field coordinator running the operation from behind the scenes.
He was helping with game plans, running practices and installing plays for teammates. By his senior year, he had enough command to change things at the line.
“That taught me that between the ears this kid has it,” Johnson said. “He really has it.
In the season, he had the green light to change a lot of things for us. That preparation has helped him up to this point in handling a pro-style offense where you’re expected to know fronts, know coverages and checks.”
Johnson saw that growth for himself when he visited Ohio State during spring practice and sat in quarterback meetings while Ryan Day, quarterbacks coach Billy Fessler and offensive coordinator Arthur Smith installed the offense.
Julian Sayin stood out for how dialed in he was. But Fahey, still early in his college career, was hanging right in there.
“I’m not gonna say he was getting them like Julian Sayin was getting them with the amount of detail he was giving,” Johnson said. “But it was clear Luke was grasping the offense.”
That understanding eventually pushed Fahey past former five-star recruit Tavien St. Clair and into the No. 2 quarterback role at Ohio State.
Then came Oct. 17, when Sayin was injured with 7:38 left at Indiana. Suddenly, Fahey was the next man up in a top-five matchup against the reigning national champions.
Now the job is even bigger. Fahey is filling in for a Heisman Trophy finalist on a one-loss team trying to keep its College Football Playoff hopes alive, and Johnson thinks the mental work that started after that USC meeting is a big reason the Buckeyes trust him to do it.
“The reason why Luke is probably getting this opportunity is that he’s proven to the coaches that mentally he can be an extension of the offensive coordinator,” Johnson said.
Johnson doesn’t expect Ohio State to ask Fahey to carry the offense by himself. The assignment, in his view, is to steer the unit, read what the defense is showing and get the Buckeyes in the right spots.
That lesson all started with a wrong play call, one whiteboard, and a quarterback who learned fast.
Now Fahey gets another crack at USC.
“I’ll tell you one thing,” Johnson joked. “USC is going to be preparing for curl flats.”
In Other News...
Ohio State Heads Into USC With Key Availability Still Unsettled
Ohio States first injury report ahead of USC offered a clearer picture of the Buckeyes health, and it was not a particularly comforting one. Quarterback Julian Sayin was listed as out indefinitely, while safety Leroy Roker and running back Ja'Kobi Jackson were also ruled out, leaving Ryan Day and his staff with some important holes to account for as the matchup approaches.
There were a few brighter notes in the report, with players such as Jay Timmons and Brandon Inniss showing up as questionable rather than unavailable. Day also addressed availability and practice status, but with several key names still uncertain, Ohio State is heading into a major Big Ten test with more decisions left to settle than it would prefer. [Read more 🡒]
Ohio State's Latest Recruiting Push Centers On Two Elite Visitors
Ohio States recruiting staff is staying busy on the West Coast and beyond, with a new offer out to 2029 athlete Kuika Moaalii from powerhouse St. John Bosco. At 6-foot-3 and 205 pounds, Moaalii is already drawing attention from multiple major programs, which fits the Buckeyes ongoing push to stay in the mix early with some of the nations most coveted young prospects.
The broader target list also includes 2028 offensive lineman RMonie Edwards and linebacker Tahj Gray, two highly ranked players who already have plenty of offers on the table. Ohio State is working to line up campus visits and keep building relationships, a familiar part of the process for a program that wants to be in position when the recruiting picture starts to get clearer. [Read more 🡒]
Ohio State's USC Trip Now Rides On Ryan Day's Toughest Call
Ryan Day is staring at one of his toughest personnel calls of the season heading into Ohio States trip to USC, with Julian Sayin sidelined by injury and the Buckeyes needing to choose between two very different options at quarterback. Freshman Luke Fahey has flashed promise with quick reads and mobility, while sophomore Tavien St. Clair brings the size and arm strength that can change a defenses outlook, even if his passing has not always been as precise.
The choice matters because it will shape how Ohio State tries to attack a USC defense on the road, and it also says plenty about where the offense is headed in the short term. Fahey gives the Buckeyes a more improvisational feel, while St. Clair offers a more classic downfield profile, leaving Day to weigh immediate stability against the kind of ceiling that can swing a big conference matchup. [Read more 🡒]