Urban Meyer didn’t hold back when he took aim at the College Football Playoff rankings, and Ohio State sat right at the center of his criticism.
During an appearance on Fox CFB on Saturday, the former Buckeyes coach and current sportscaster questioned how the committee is sorting out teams, especially when it comes to nonconference scheduling and the value of head-to-head results. His biggest issue: No.
12 Ohio State is eight spots behind No. 4 Indiana, even though the Buckeyes beat the Hoosiers.
He also brought up Ohio State’s recent win over USC.
“You got Indiana eight spots ahead of the Buckeyes. The Buckeyes beat Indiana, and this one's confusing to me.
This is eight spots,” he said on the program. “USC is eight spots behind Ohio State, and they’re 7-2.
Ohio State is 6-2, and they just beat them by double digits recently.”
Meyer then widened the complaint beyond just those two teams, arguing that the current system discourages programs from taking on tough early-season matchups.
“My concern as we continue to move down this path is the preseason games or non-conference games are awful,” he said. “We watch them every year. 50-point spreads.
Last year, Texas was penalized by playing at top-ranked Ohio State. They were kept out of the playoff.
Ohio State goes and plays Texas. Now they're number 12.
That’s not the number 12 team in America. There’s no chance.”
He finished that thought with a blunt challenge to the incentives behind scheduling.
“So, my concern is this: If Ohio State would've played Akron at home, they're probably five in the country. Why go play those games?”
There’s at least a case to be made for Meyer’s frustration. Ohio State owns the head-to-head win over Indiana, and the Buckeyes also have a narrow loss to Texas on their résumé. The USC loss, though, is the kind of blemish that complicates the picture.
Indiana is 8-1 and has wins over Michigan and Nebraska, but it hasn’t beaten a ranked opponent this season. That makes the eight-spot gap between the Hoosiers and Buckeyes hard to square, even if Meyer’s long history with Ohio State gives his take an obvious tint.
Still, the point he’s pushing isn’t hard to understand: if the committee is going to reward teams for testing themselves, it has to explain why results like these don’t carry more weight.
In Other News...
Ohio State Still Has A Path But Two Problems Need Fixing Fast
Cris Carter still sees a route for Ohio State to play its way back into the College Football Playoff picture, but the margin for error has shrunk fast. With recent losses raising the pressure on Ryan Day, the Buckeyes are staring at a stretch where every detail matters, and the conversation around the program has quickly shifted from expectations to repairs.
Two areas stand out most: the defense has to tighten up, and Luke Fahey needs to keep developing at quarterback if Ohio State is going to stabilize its offense. The upcoming games now carry far more than ordinary Big Ten weight, because they will help determine whether the Buckeyes can keep their national championship hopes alive or whether this season turns into a lesson in missed chances. [Read more 🡒]
Ohio States Oregon Collapse Exposed A Problem Buckeyes Fans Feared
Ohio States loss to Oregon at home was the kind of game that left Buckeyes fans replaying the same first-half promise and second-half unraveling over and over. The start was encouraging enough to suggest the day could go differently, but the collapse that followed only sharpened the sense that this team still has issues it cannot afford to ignore, especially when a marquee opponent forces it out of its comfort zone.
Jeremiah Smith was not used nearly enough, Luke Faheys performance came under scrutiny, and the defense looked like it had slipped from the standard Ohio State expects. The bigger concern, though, was how little changed as the game tilted away from the Buckeyes, with coaching decisions and the lack of in-game adjustments adding to the feeling that the problems were as much about direction as execution. [Read more 🡒]
Ohio State Just Saw Oregon Flip This Game With Zero Fear
Oregon spent the first quarter looking like a team that had walked into a bad matchup, falling behind 14-0 and giving Ohio State every reason to think it was in control. But the Ducks did not play like a group interested in simply surviving the moment. A successful fake punt helped shift the tone, and Oregons aggressive approach kept the Buckeyes from settling in before halftime.
By the break, the Ducks had turned the game around and taken a 17-14 lead, a swing that fit the way Dan Lanning has talked about his team needing to play. He has stressed staying true to Oregons identity and cutting down on turnovers, a formula that looked especially bold against an Ohio State team carrying the heavier burden of College Football Playoff pressure. With the Ducks already having less to lose because of earlier losses, they played with a looseness that made every decision feel a little more dangerous for the Buckeyes. [Read more 🡒]