Ohio State's head coach, Ryan Day, finds himself at the pinnacle of preseason rankings, but a deeper dive raises questions about whether he truly deserves the No. 1 spot. College football analyst Josh Pate has placed Day at the top, citing factors like on-field results, recruiting prowess, program culture, and future outlook, all evaluated over a three-year period.
While the Buckeyes had a solid 2025 season, finishing 12-2, they stumbled in crucial moments. Losses in the Big Ten championship against Indiana and in the College Football Playoff quarterfinals highlight some of the challenges Day faces. These setbacks prompt a reevaluation of whether he currently stands as the nation's best coach.
Pate's ranking method leans heavily on sustained success, but recent achievements can’t be overlooked. Indiana's head coach, Curt Cignetti, led the Hoosiers to an impeccable 16-0 season, culminating in a national championship. Many argue that such accomplishments should place Cignetti ahead of Day for 2026.
Day’s track record is undeniably strong, but in college football, recent performance is paramount. The inability to clinch critical games or adapt under pressure raises doubts about his top billing. While Ohio State remains a powerhouse, these key losses suggest they might not be at the absolute peak.
The debate intensifies when considering other coaches who have secured championships or advanced further in the playoffs, like Cignetti and other national contenders. Consistent winning is crucial, but true coaching greatness is defined by championships and excelling against elite opponents.
Looking ahead, Ohio State faces a significant test in Week 2 of the 2026 season with a high-stakes matchup against Texas in Austin. This game will be an early indicator of the Buckeyes' trajectory and whether Day can guide them to reclaim the top spot in college football.