Ryan Day Just Reignited Ohio States Jeremiah Smith Debate

Ryan Day's comments on Jeremiah Smith spark controversy, questioning Ohio State's offensive priorities amidst their latest win.

Ryan Day had a strange postgame message after Ohio State’s 28-19 win over Northwestern in Week 11, and it centered on Jeremiah Smith.

Day started with the obvious - winning comes first - but then immediately veered into a defense of why Smith was targeted 17 times, using the word “but” in a way that made the two ideas sound like they were at odds.

“Well, at the end of the day, the No. 1 goal is to win, but we also have an obligation to this young man. What he’s done for our program, who he is as a person, how he plays, what he does for his teammates, what he means for this program. He deserves the opportunity to touch the football,” Day said postgame.

That wording opened the door to a bizarre reading: that getting Smith the ball might not be what the staff believes gives Ohio State the best chance to win. That’s not the point Day was trying to make, but it’s the kind of slip that invites exactly that reaction.

Smith has been one of the biggest reasons Ohio State has kept winning this season, and there’s nobody else in the receiving room who can match what he brings. The source material goes even further, calling him the best receiver in Ohio State football history.

Day could have framed it better. He clearly wasn’t saying the Buckeyes were putting Smith ahead of winning, but the way he said it made the whole thing sound awkward and unnecessary.

Day also made a push for Smith to win the Heisman Trophy this year, something that had been a real possibility before Julian Sayin’s likely season-ending injury.

“Maybe there is a better player out there, but this guy is completely dominant. I think he deserves it in a big way. We still have to finish the season the right way,” Day said.

The source argues that if there’s a Buckeye with a real Heisman case after the recent turn of events, it’s Sayin, not Smith. Smith’s production dipped at the wrong time during a difficult stretch, and the drop-off in Central Ohio’s mood can be tied directly to Sayin being out. Even so, Sayin won’t qualify for the award.

At this point, the piece makes clear that no one from Ohio State is likely to take home the Heisman. The Buckeyes have brought too much chaos into the final month of the season for that kind of honor to land in Columbus.

Still, Day wasn’t wrong to call Smith the most dominant player around. He may have been stretching things by suggesting there could be a better player elsewhere, because when Ohio State’s offense was humming, Smith was producing like a future top NFL pick every week.

The Heisman window appears to have closed for No. 4, but there’s still a chance for one more big stage. The source notes that Smith could still help carry Ohio State past most opponents if he’s at his best in the CFP.

In Other News...

Ohio State Gets A Rare Late-Season Opening It Has To Exploit

Week 12 brings a rare kind of breathing room to the national title race, with no AP Top 25 matchups on the schedule for the first time in November since 2009. For Ohio State, that makes Saturdays visit from Nebraska more than just another Big Ten date on the calendar. It is a chance to stay sharp, stay healthy and keep building its case while the rest of the sport spends the weekend sorting out its own playoff questions.

The Buckeyes will be one of the most watched teams in a slate that also includes Texas Tech at Baylor and Notre Dame hosting SMU, games that could reshape the wider postseason picture. Ohio State does not need chaos elsewhere to matter, but it does need to handle the opportunity in front of it, because these are the weeks when a contender can either reinforce its standing or leave the door open for someone else to make a late push. [Read more 🡒]

Ohio State Recruiting Momentum Just Created Another Big Reason For Hope

The win over Northwestern kept Ohio State moving in the right direction on the field, pushing the Buckeyes to 7-3 and leaving them at No. 16 in the AP Polls with their College Football Playoff hopes still hanging around. But the bigger buzz around the program this week has come off the field, where the recruiting momentum has started to match the late-season urgency in Columbus.

Ohio State just flipped four-star running back Nigel Newkirk from Alabama and also landed among the top five for four-star cornerback Jai'lil Goley, another sign the staff is still selling a strong future even with the present season in flux. The Buckeyes' 2027 class is already sitting at No. 5 by 247Sports, built around top edge prospects DJ Jacobs and Wyatt Smith, though there is still some uncertainty surrounding Jacobs' commitment as the class continues to take shape. [Read more 🡒]

Ohio State Just Got Another Encouraging Sign From Luke Fahey

Luke Faheys first start for Ohio State came with the sort of validation every young quarterback hopes for. After steering the Buckeyes past Northwestern, the freshman was named Big Ten Freshman of the Week, a nod that adds another layer to a debut that already carried real meaning for him and his family. It was his first win as Ohio States starting quarterback, and the performance gave the program a fresh look at a player who is trying to settle into a bigger role.

For Ohio State, the honor is another encouraging sign that the quarterback room is starting to take shape around a young player who handled the moment well. Faheys rise into weekly conference recognition also puts him in select company within the program, which is no small thing for a freshman still building his rsum. The bigger question now is how he builds on this momentum, and whether this outing becomes the start of something more lasting for the Buckeyes. [Read more 🡒]