Ohio State left Bloomington with a 19-15 win over Indiana on Saturday, but the conversation around the game quickly shifted from the final score to the officials. The Buckeyes snapped the Hoosiers’ 22-game winning streak, yet plenty of fans came away convinced Big Ten referees had spent the afternoon leaning toward the home side.
The flashpoint came late, with Indiana trailing 19-15 and pushing for the lead. Officials hit Ohio State cornerback Jermaine Mathews Jr. with a roughing-the-passer penalty that extended the drive, even though quarterbacks Josh Hoover was already dealing with a right arm injury after landing on his elbow earlier in the game. The call came with the game at the two-minute mark, and officials ruled against targeting but kept the 15-yard penalty in place.
Ben DiNucci, who played quarterback for Indiana coach Curt Cignetti at James Madison in 2019, wrote on X that it “has to be the softest roughing the passer call I’ve ever seen on Josh Hoover.”
That sentiment spread fast. One Ohio State fan on X posted, “Refs absolutely rigging this for Indiana.”
Indiana’s best chance after that came on fourth down with just over a minute left, when Hoover found Nick Marsh alone in the end zone. Marsh couldn’t get both feet down, and the drive ended there.
Ohio State fans were also upset earlier in the game over a deep ball to Jeremiah Smith. Quarterback Julian Sayin underthrew a wide-open Smith, and no pass interference flag came on the play. A clip posted with the caption, “NO PASS INTERFERENCE ?”, drew more than 234,000 views.
That anger had been simmering before kickoff. The Columbus Dispatch reported earlier this month that Smith had gone 10 games without drawing a pass interference flag, and Ohio State coach Ryan Day said the junior’s size makes contact harder to spot.
“When you’re that big and that strong, a foul doesn’t look the same,” Day said.
Indiana had also heard the advice Nick Saban gave Saturday morning: the best way to slow Smith was to affect the quarterback. Sayin finished 15 of 29 for 235 yards with two touchdowns and two interceptions before leaving in the fourth quarter with a right arm injury. Day said Sayin will be out "several weeks."
The penalty count didn’t all go one direction. Ohio State got a first-half break when Indiana’s Kellan Wyatt was flagged for roughing, which moved the Buckeyes to the Indiana 11 on the possession that ended with Bo Jackson’s fourth-down touchdown run before halftime. After Sayin exited, Indiana linebacker Isaiah Jones was called for a late hit on backup quarterback Luke Fahey.
By the end, Ohio State had been flagged seven times for 50 yards, while Indiana had four penalties for 42 yards.
Some Buckeyes supporters took that as proof their team handled everything thrown at it. College football analyst Brandon Walker wrote that Indiana “had the refs, home field, an all time bad showing by Sayin and then Sayin getting hurt and they still couldn’t win.”
Indiana fans weren’t thrilled with the officiating either. “Horrible game by the refs. Horrible game by Hoover,” one Hoosiers supporter wrote.
Sayin entered the day as the No. 1 quarterback in the Big Ten rankings, and he returned to the sideline with his throwing arm in a sling. Both teams are now 6-1, and Indiana plays Michigan on Oct. 24 at noon ET on FOX.
In Other News...
Indiana Was At The Center Of A Costly Officiating Controversy
The latest officiating debate in college football has put Indiana back in the middle of the conversation, this time because of a roughing the passer call in its game against Ohio State that kept a drive alive longer than it otherwise would have. Even though the Buckeyes still won, the penalty added to a familiar frustration for fans who watch these games closely, where one decision can ripple through the rest of the night and change the feel of everything that follows.
It comes on the heels of another end-of-game controversy in the Notre Dame-BYU matchup, where a clock error helped bring the game to an end with one second still available for another play. The Big 12 has already acknowledged that mistake and said it will review its end-of-game officiating process, which only adds to the broader scrutiny now facing the officials and the system that is supposed to get these moments right. [Read more 🡒]
Ohio State's Huge Win May Have Come With A Serious Cost
Ohio States 19-15 win over Indiana carried all the weight youd expect from a top-tier road result, snapping the Hoosiers 22-game winning streak and handing them their first home loss in 19 games. Julian Sayin supplied the defining play with a 38-yard touchdown strike, and the Buckeyes did just enough in a tight, physical game where every possession felt magnified.
The concern afterward centered on Sayin, who appeared to injure his right arm during the game, leaving an already significant victory with a lingering question for Ohio States offense. Indiana also had a chance to flip the afternoon when Nick Marsh appeared to score a go-ahead touchdown, only for the play to be wiped away because he stepped out of bounds, a sequence that only added to the drama of a game decided by thin margins. [Read more 🡒]
Ohio State Just Got A USC Problem It Didn't Want
Ohio State left Indiana with a hard-fought 19-15 win, but the postgame mood was quickly tempered by a more troubling development. Quarterback Julian Sayin suffered a shoulder injury in the comeback victory and is expected to miss several weeks, forcing the Buckeyes to turn to freshman Luke Fahey at a position where continuity matters plenty as the season moves deeper into the grind.
Kenyatta Jackson Jr. also exited limping with an ankle injury, adding to a growing list of bodies the Buckeyes may have to manage in the coming stretch. For a team still sorting through other absences, the timing is less than ideal, and it puts extra pressure on the supporting cast to steady things while Ohio State waits to learn how much it can get back and when. [Read more 🡒]