Ohio State walked into its home matchup with Oregon needing a response and got one for about 15 minutes. The Buckeyes jumped out to a 14-point lead, then watched the game tilt sharply the other way in an ugly loss that turned into a rout.
It was, by the source’s own framing, the worst home performance from an Ohio State football team in a long, long time, maybe since 1999 against Wisconsin. And when a game goes that sideways, the list of takeaways is not a cheerful one.
One of the biggest is simple: Jeremiah Smith cannot disappear from the plan. The best player in college football needs the ball, whether Ohio State is ahead, trailing, or trying to claw back into a game. Somehow, Smith went almost two quarters without a target while the Buckeyes were struggling, and that’s going to raise questions.
He still finished with seven catches for 133 yards and a touchdown, but most of that production came when the outcome was still in doubt. At one point in the fourth quarter, after a catch for no gain, he was visibly frustrated and appeared to be screaming at someone or a group. He is expected to go down as the best receiver to ever wear the Ohio State uniform and could be the best college receiver ever, so the idea that he was left out of the flow for that long is hard to ignore.
The quarterback situation brought its own questions. Luke Fahey’s stat line looks fine at a glance - 360 passing yards - but the game told a messier story. He had volume, sure, but there were plenty of yards and points left on the field.
Fahey struggled with his progressions, had footwork issues, and showed some misfires and overthrows. He also seemed to panic at times and check the ball down too quickly, which left receivers exposed to big hits. He rarely looked to Jeremiah Smith until late, and even with the yardage total, he did not do enough in the middle of the game to steady things.
That leads to another obvious question: where was Tavien St. Clair?
The source makes clear this is not a claim that St. Clair is better than Fahey, and that the coaches see more than anyone outside the program.
But when a game is spiraling, a change can sometimes reset everything, and the question is why Ohio State never tried to get St. Clair on the field to see if a different look could spark something.
The defense didn’t do the offense any favors, either. For the second straight week, Ohio State gave up too many big plays. The early approach of dropping defenders into coverage and making Dylan Raiola find open receivers worked for a while, but once he settled in and realized he had time to throw, he started making confident, efficient plays.
Raiola’s numbers weren’t massive, but he was poised. Oregon also found success in the run game, and when Ohio State needed stops, they didn’t come.
The Ducks finished with more than 400 yards, and the Buckeyes have now allowed 30 points or more in back-to-back weeks. That is not the standard for this defense, and the refusal to shift into a more aggressive style is hurting the team.
Now the bigger picture gets uncomfortable. The source says it likely means curtains for the College Football Playoff and the Big Ten Championship game, a place Ohio State hasn’t been in this position in a long, long time. What happens next will say plenty about this group.
Can the Buckeyes get off the mat and finish strong, or does the slide continue? There is still belief that the pride and talent on the roster can show up, and maybe there is still an outside path back into the mix for something bigger. Northwestern is next, and that game will tell plenty because it figures to be a blue-collar affair that won’t be easy.
In Other News...
Ohio State Still Has A Path But Two Problems Need Fixing Fast
Cris Carter still sees a route for Ohio State to play its way back into the College Football Playoff picture, but the margin for error has shrunk fast. With recent losses raising the pressure on Ryan Day, the Buckeyes are staring at a stretch where every detail matters, and the conversation around the program has quickly shifted from expectations to repairs.
Two areas stand out most: the defense has to tighten up, and Luke Fahey needs to keep developing at quarterback if Ohio State is going to stabilize its offense. The upcoming games now carry far more than ordinary Big Ten weight, because they will help determine whether the Buckeyes can keep their national championship hopes alive or whether this season turns into a lesson in missed chances. [Read more 🡒]
Urban Meyer Just Added Fuel To Indianas CFP Debate
Urban Meyer added another layer to the College Football Playoff debate by questioning how the committee is handling Ohio State and Indiana in the latest rankings. His concern centered on the gap between No. 12 Ohio State and No. 4 Indiana, especially with the Buckeyes owning the head-to-head win. Meyer said the placement did not seem to match what the teams have shown on the field, and he took aim at the committees approach to nonconference scheduling as part of the broader evaluation.
Indianas rsum has been strong enough to keep it firmly in the conversation, with an 8-1 record and wins over Michigan and Nebraska. Still, Meyer pointed out that the Hoosiers do not have a victory over a ranked opponent, which only sharpened the debate over how much weight the committee is giving different parts of the schedule. For Ohio State, the issue is less about needing outside validation and more about whether the rankings are reflecting what happened when the two teams actually met. [Read more 🡒]
Ohio State Just Saw Oregon Flip This Game With Zero Fear
Oregon spent the first quarter looking like a team that had walked into a bad matchup, falling behind 14-0 and giving Ohio State every reason to think it was in control. But the Ducks did not play like a group interested in simply surviving the moment. A successful fake punt helped shift the tone, and Oregons aggressive approach kept the Buckeyes from settling in before halftime.
By the break, the Ducks had turned the game around and taken a 17-14 lead, a swing that fit the way Dan Lanning has talked about his team needing to play. He has stressed staying true to Oregons identity and cutting down on turnovers, a formula that looked especially bold against an Ohio State team carrying the heavier burden of College Football Playoff pressure. With the Ducks already having less to lose because of earlier losses, they played with a looseness that made every decision feel a little more dangerous for the Buckeyes. [Read more 🡒]