Ohio State’s late-game kicking story in the 21st century is a lot messier than the memory bank might suggest.
After Connor Hawkins missed a 45-yard field goal with 4:16 left in Ohio State’s loss to Texas last weekend, it put a fresh spotlight on a question Buckeye fans have been asking for years: what have Ohio State kickers actually done when the pressure spikes in the fourth quarter? The answer, based on a look at every field goal attempt in one-score games with under 7:30 left in the fourth quarter or in overtime since 2000, is somewhere between reliable and nerve-wracking.
The Buckeyes have split those attempts into two buckets. “Money kicks” are the ones taken when the game is tied or Ohio State is down by three or fewer.
“Clutch kicks” are the attempts with Ohio State holding a one-score lead. Ohio State has not tried a field goal in that same late-game window while trailing by more than three but fewer than seven points since 2000.
In the money-kick category, Ohio State is 10-for-18, good for 55.6%. The headline moment in that group remains Mike Nugent’s 55-yard walk-off against Marshall in 2004, which stands alone as the only make longer than 40 yards by an Ohio State kicker in the final seven minutes of a game when the Buckeyes were tied or behind since 2000. Overall, the Buckeyes are just 2-for-7 on 40-plus-yard tries in those situations, and Jayden Fielding’s 40-yarder against Oregon in 2024 is the second-longest make in that span.
The misses can sting just as much as the makes matter. Tyler Durbin’s 21-yard miss in The Game in 2016 was the shortest miss in a money situation, though he later answered with a 23-yard make at the end of double overtime in a wild win.
Fielding’s 27-yard miss wide left in the Big Ten Championship Game loss to Indiana last season ranks as the second-shortest miss in that category. Other notable money kicks include Noah Ruggles’ 50-yard miss at the buzzer against Georgia in the 2022 Peach Bowl, his 19-yard make against Utah in the Rose Bowl, and Dan Stultz’s two kicks against Illinois in 2000, both of which came through.
The clutch-kick numbers are a little better: 10-for-16, or 62.5%.
That group includes Hawkins’ miss against Texas, a 45-yard try with Ohio State up six that helped turn the game. It also includes Jayden Fielding’s 33-yard make with 26 seconds left in the 2025 CFP National Championship Game against Notre Dame, plus Ruggles’ 48-yard make against Georgia in the 2022 Peach Bowl before the Buckeyes eventually lost in heartbreaking fashion.
Before Hawkins’ miss, Ohio State had made its last seven field goals in one-score games while leading in the second half of the fourth quarter, including three makes from 45 yards or longer by Ruggles. Last Saturday’s loss to Texas was only the fourth time since 2000 that Ohio State lost after attempting a field goal with a one-score lead in the second half of the fourth quarter. It was also the second time that kind of miss against Texas with a six-point lead ended in defeat, after Josh Huston’s 50-yard miss in 2005 set up a Longhorns touchdown drive to win it.
There were other painful turns in the data, too. Ruggles’ 48-yard make in the Peach Bowl was followed by a 50-yard miss after Georgia grabbed a one-point lead.
Tyler Durbin’s kick at Penn State in 2016 was blocked and returned for a touchdown. Sean Nuernberger missed from 43 yards against Michigan in 2017 despite Ohio State still winning comfortably.
When the numbers are stacked together, the list of Buckeye kickers looks a little different than the name most people might have guessed. Mike Nugent is the all-time Ohio State leader in made field goals, but he also has the most misses in these late-game clutch spots, with five. He did, however, hit the longest game-winner in Ohio State history.
The full breakdown tells the story plainly:
Drew Basil: 3-for-3
Dan Stultz: 2-for-2
Noah Ruggles: 6-for-7
Jayden Fielding: 2-for-3
Tyler Durbin: 2-for-4
Devin Barclay: 1-for-2
Sean Nuernberger: 1-for-2
Mike Nugent: 3-for-8
Connor Hawkins: 0-for-1
Josh Huston: 0-for-2
So if you’re looking for the most dependable late-game boots of the century, Basil, Stultz and Ruggles sit at the top. Ruggles’ lone miss was the huge one against Georgia, but he still made more clutch fourth-quarter field goals than any Ohio State kicker in the 21st century.
Jayden Fielding’s record is more mixed. Durbin and Nuernberger landed squarely in the middle.
Barclay missed once, then made up for it with a walk-off winner in the same game.
And then there are the guys who simply didn’t cash in when it mattered most. Hawkins and Huston both finished 0-for-2 in these pressure spots.
In Other News...
Ohio State Faces One Immediate Test After That Texas Collapse
Ohio State does not have much time to sit with the sting of a blown 20-point fourth-quarter lead, because Kent State is next on the schedule and the Buckeyes need a clean response. After a season-opening loss that raised immediate questions about composure and late-game execution, this one shapes up as a chance to steady things, clean up the rotation and get the offense moving with a little less pressure on every snap.
The matchup also invites some early-game watching points beyond the scoreboard, from how long the starters stay on the field to whether the ground game can set the tone quickly. Bo Jackson is expected to get plenty of runway in the first half, and Khary Wilder could see a larger role on defense, which makes this more than just a routine tune-up. For Ohio State, the bigger question is whether the Buckeyes can turn an uneasy week into something that looks, at least for one Saturday, like control. [Read more 🡒]
Legend Bey Gets A Crucial Ohio State Chance To Earn Trust Back
Legend Bey is getting another crack at a role that disappeared fast after the early-season loss of trust. The Ohio State freshman had been pulled from kickoff return duty after a shaky outing against Ball State, and Ryan Day turned to Devin McCuin for the Texas game while Beys involvement shrank to just one snap.
Now the Buckeyes are giving Bey his return job back for the upcoming game against Kent State, which makes this a clear chance to reset his standing. For Bey, the assignment is about more than handling kickoffs well. It is about showing he can follow instructions, stay within the framework of the staff, and earn back the trust that his play briefly cost him. [Read more 🡒]
Jeremiah Smith Could Make Ohio State History This Weekend
Jeremiah Smith has already become one of the defining players of Ohio States season, and the conversation around his place in program history is starting to catch up to the production. The junior wide receiver was at his best against Texas, piling up eight catches for 164 yards and two touchdowns, a reminder that he remains the Buckeyes most dangerous answer when games get tight and the ball needs to find a playmaker.
Ryan Day has pointed to Smiths focus on helping Ohio State chase a second national championship, and the last loss only seemed to sharpen that edge. There is also a milestone within reach that adds another layer to the weekend, one that would put Smith in rare company and further cement how quickly he has climbed among the programs greats. [Read more 🡒]