Ohio State’s quarterback picture has taken an unexpected turn six weeks into the 2026 season, and the name at the center of it is not the one many assumed.
When the 2025 campaign ended, the expectation around the Buckeyes was pretty straightforward: Julian Sayin was there, and he looked the part of a Heisman candidate. The bigger debate was who would sit behind him once Lincoln Keinzholz entered the transfer portal.
At the time, Tavien St. Clair looked like the clear answer.
That hasn’t played out the way most people expected.
The 5-foot-11, 206-pound St. Clair entered his college career with plenty of buzz after a high school run at Bellefontaine that produced more than 10,000 passing yards and 100 touchdowns.
A three-star recruit, he wasn’t supposed to force his way into the conversation this quickly. But after three games this season, he has thrown for 203 yards, two touchdowns and two interceptions on 11 attempts, completing nine passes and averaging 18.5 yards per attempt.
He has seen action against Ball State, Kent State and the University of Maryland.
Still, the real surprise is what’s happening around him. Because while St.
Clair had looked like the obvious backup choice, another quarterback has surged forward in practice and on game day. Ryan Day made that clear in August when he said the freshman was closing fast and putting serious pressure on St.
Clair.
"He's been really doing a great job. He's putting a lot of pressure on Tavien," Day said in mid-August.
"He really is. He's been competing.
He's been making plays... So, that's been exciting to see him come in with a certain work ethic, run the offense at a pretty high level.
"We'll see how the rest of the camp plays out, but good to see him kind of step in and push Tavien."
Those words look even more meaningful now.
St. Clair has played in two games this season and gone 5-for-7 for 52 yards, one touchdown and one interception.
He dressed for the opener against Ball State, then got a shot against Kent State a few days later and threw an interception on his lone attempt. Since then, the opportunities have been limited.
The story isn’t that St. Clair has fallen apart.
It’s that he hasn’t separated himself, and the other quarterback has. The Buckeyes need more than arm talent or recruiting hype at the position.
They need command, quick processing and trust from the people around the huddle. Right now, that’s where the competition appears to be tilting.
Only time will tell whether St. Clair can climb back up the chart, reclaim the No. 2 spot or even push higher by the end of the season.
For now, though, the spotlight belongs to Fahey, and he’s not giving it up easily.
In Other News...
Ohio State Heads Into Indiana Showdown With Big Lineup Questions
Ohio State heads into its matchup with Indiana facing some early lineup uncertainty, with offensive lineman Austin Siereveld ruled out because of a non-football illness and running back JaKobi Jackson unavailable after suffering an ankle injury. Those absences alone would matter in a Big Ten game this size, but they are part of a larger injury picture for the Buckeyes, who have several other players still listed as questionable.
Indiana, meanwhile, has a much shorter injury report, with only two players listed. For Ohio State, the challenge now is less about the opponents health and more about how much flexibility the Buckeyes can preserve as they sort through the final availability questions before kickoff. [Read more 🡒]
Ohio State Freshman Legend Bey Suddenly Has A Real Chance To Earn Trust
An unexpected shakeup in the backfield has opened the door a little wider for Legend Bey. With Ja'Kobi Jackson ruled out for the upcoming game against Indiana and Isaiah West listed as questionable, Ohio State may need to lean on its freshman running back more than it had planned. The Buckeyes are also dealing with Austin Siereveld being out, which adds another layer of strain to the offensive line depth and could shape how the offense handles the ground game.
For Bey, this is the kind of moment that can change how a staff views a young player in a hurry. More snaps against Indiana would not just be about filling a need in the moment, but about showing he can be trusted if the Buckeyes have to keep adjusting on the fly. Ohio State has managed its backfield carefully so far, but the injury picture now gives Bey a real opening to make his case. [Read more 🡒]
Jeremiah Smith Just Gave Ohio State Fans A New Ranking Debate
ESPNs latest ranking stirred up a familiar kind of college football debate, and this one comes with a fresh Ohio State twist. The network put together a top-60 list of the best wide receivers in the past 50 years, blending talent and production, and it included some heavy company in Larry Fitzgerald, DeVonta Smith and Justin Blackmon.
Jeremiah Smith made the cut as the lone active college receiver on the list, which is already a notable honor for a player still early in his career. For Buckeyes fans, it is the kind of recognition that says plenty about how high Smiths ceiling already looks, even if the bigger conversation around where he fits historically is still very much ongoing. [Read more 🡒]