Ohio State got a reminder in Week 11 that Chip Kelly doesn’t have to be perfect to look like the better bet.
The Buckeyes beat Northwestern 28-19, and Kelly’s offense wasn’t exactly humming at vintage levels. Still, what Ohio State saw was enough to make the case that Kelly would be a better fit in Columbus than Arthur Smith.
Northwestern was working without starting quarterback Aidan Chiles, but backup Nicco Marchiol still threw for 225 yards. Ohio State’s defensive front spent plenty of time in the backfield, yet the Wildcats still managed to move the chains on 6 of 15 third downs and converted one of two fourth-down tries.
Kelly, in that sense, did less with more. Northwestern even showed some fight late, capped by Marchiol’s last-second touchdown pass to tight end Luke Dehnicke. That kind of resilience is something Smith hasn’t been able to point to much this season.
To be fair, Smith has done a strong job getting the ball to Jeremiah Smith. But the larger question is whether that alone makes him the right man to run the offense in Columbus.
Derrick Henry has shown he can thrive no matter who is calling the plays. The same can’t be said for every situation.
Smith also hasn’t been able to cover for the loss of Julian Sayin. Ohio State put up just 18 points against a USC defense that allows more than 24 points per game on average, and the offense didn’t really wake up until too late in last week’s loss to Oregon.
That’s the bigger concern: Smith hasn’t shown he can absorb the loss of even one key player. For a role that pays as well as this one does, that’s a tough mark to ignore.
And if Kelly becomes available again, the argument only gets stronger.
The question of whether Kelly could be on the move is a real one, and it may end up helping Ohio State. Nebraska could be in the mix, according to Nebraska Cornhuskers On SI’s Jeremy Pernell, because of Kelly’s ego.
The Cornhuskers just fired Dana Holgorson, and the early signs don’t suggest Glenn Thomas is safe unless he can quickly turn the scoring around. A 31-point game is a decent place to start, though Nebraska got that in Week 11 against Rutgers.
If Kelly is chasing a bigger stage than Northwestern, why wouldn’t Ohio State be on the list? He’s clearly comfortable calling plays without being a head coach right now, and a return to the Buckeye State would make plenty of sense if he wants to be the piece that steadies the offense in Central Ohio.
There’s a real pull to the idea. Brian Hartline was never the long-term answer beyond recruiting, and Smith’s NFL play-calling hasn’t moved the needle without star NFL-quality talent.
Unless Kelly feels like he’s already done this before and wants something new, a return to the Buckeyes makes too much sense. He worked well with Ryan Day, and together they delivered the best possible result.
In Other News...
Ohio State Gets A Rare Late-Season Opening It Has To Exploit
Week 12 brings a rare kind of breathing room to the national title race, with no AP Top 25 matchups on the schedule for the first time in November since 2009. For Ohio State, that makes Saturdays visit from Nebraska more than just another Big Ten date on the calendar. It is a chance to stay sharp, stay healthy and keep building its case while the rest of the sport spends the weekend sorting out its own playoff questions.
The Buckeyes will be one of the most watched teams in a slate that also includes Texas Tech at Baylor and Notre Dame hosting SMU, games that could reshape the wider postseason picture. Ohio State does not need chaos elsewhere to matter, but it does need to handle the opportunity in front of it, because these are the weeks when a contender can either reinforce its standing or leave the door open for someone else to make a late push. [Read more 🡒]
Ohio State Recruiting Momentum Just Created Another Big Reason For Hope
The win over Northwestern kept Ohio State moving in the right direction on the field, pushing the Buckeyes to 7-3 and leaving them at No. 16 in the AP Polls with their College Football Playoff hopes still hanging around. But the bigger buzz around the program this week has come off the field, where the recruiting momentum has started to match the late-season urgency in Columbus.
Ohio State just flipped four-star running back Nigel Newkirk from Alabama and also landed among the top five for four-star cornerback Jai'lil Goley, another sign the staff is still selling a strong future even with the present season in flux. The Buckeyes' 2027 class is already sitting at No. 5 by 247Sports, built around top edge prospects DJ Jacobs and Wyatt Smith, though there is still some uncertainty surrounding Jacobs' commitment as the class continues to take shape. [Read more 🡒]
Ohio State Just Got Another Encouraging Sign From Luke Fahey
Luke Faheys first start for Ohio State came with the sort of validation every young quarterback hopes for. After steering the Buckeyes past Northwestern, the freshman was named Big Ten Freshman of the Week, a nod that adds another layer to a debut that already carried real meaning for him and his family. It was his first win as Ohio States starting quarterback, and the performance gave the program a fresh look at a player who is trying to settle into a bigger role.
For Ohio State, the honor is another encouraging sign that the quarterback room is starting to take shape around a young player who handled the moment well. Faheys rise into weekly conference recognition also puts him in select company within the program, which is no small thing for a freshman still building his rsum. The bigger question now is how he builds on this momentum, and whether this outing becomes the start of something more lasting for the Buckeyes. [Read more 🡒]
