Ohio State May Need A Painful Reset With Key Transfers

Ohio State Buckeyes are considering benching four first-year veteran transfers as they strategize for long-term success amid a challenging 2026 season.

Ohio State’s season has reached the point where the conversation is no longer just about fixing what’s broken now. It’s about what the Buckeyes can learn from the wreckage before the calendar turns.

That’s the backdrop for Bucknuts’ Patrick Murphy, who pointed to four first-year veteran transfers who could be candidates to see their roles trimmed for the good of the program: safety Earl Little Jr., linebacker Christian Alliegro, receiver Devin McCuin and tight end/H-back Mason Williams.

Murphy framed the idea around giving younger players a chance to grow while also getting a clearer read on the roster heading into the offseason.

“The Buckeyes do have veterans who haven’t been with the program throughout their careers. Players such as Earl Little Jr., Christian Alliegro, Devin McCuin and Mason Williams arrived this offseason. While they have contributed this season, they don’t have the same "pride in this place" as those who have bled scarlet and gray for four or five years,” Murphy wrote.

He added: “Perhaps reducing snaps for some transfers could be a way to create more opportunities for young players. This would not only give Ohio State a better sense of what the team has at each position heading into the offseason, but also show those players there is a path to playing time, so the Buckeyes don’t face a mass exodus like they did last winter.”

The idea isn’t coming out of nowhere. Alliegro, the Wisconsin transfer, took time to settle in before breaking through in the Illinois win. McCuin, the UTSA transfer, just posted his best game in the Oregon loss, catching nine passes for 84 yards.

Even with those flashes, the bigger picture hasn’t changed. The veteran group brought in as a fast solution hasn’t been fast enough or effective enough to steady the season.

There’s also the question of what these snaps mean beyond this year. It may be worth finding out who fits in Matt Patricia’s defense and Arthur Smith’s offense for next season, if those two even get another shot in Columbus for the 2027 season.

And if some of these players are essentially auditioning for other teams, the logic still points the same direction: give the reps to the guys who need them most, not to players who may be better off protecting their bodies for what comes next.

The larger issue is that Ohio State’s big transfer portal bet in 2026 didn’t pay off. Ryan Day and his staff leaned on the portal to refill important depth, but the results haven’t matched the ambition.

That doesn’t mean the Buckeyes should suddenly stop valuing the portal. The 2024/2025 CFP championship was built in large part on major contributions from Kansas State transfer quarterback Will Howard, Ole Miss transfer running back Quinshon Judkins, Alabama transfer interior offensive lineman Seth McLaughlin, safety Caleb Downs and Ohio transfer tight end Will Kacmarek.

Still, the current season has raised a fair question about whether this staff handled the portal well enough to support championship-level football. Losing starting quarterback Julian Sayin shouldn’t have knocked the program off course this badly, and the source of the problem may be that a veteran portal quarterback should have been a bigger priority behind him.

For Ohio State, the expectation is simple: this program is supposed to survive storms like this. However the final stretch plays out, the Buckeyes need a coaching staff capable of building deeper, sturdier depth so they’re in a better place a year from now.

In Other News...

Northwestern Coach Sounds Off After Ohio State Call Changed The Game

Northwestern coach David Braun had plenty to sort through after Ohio States 28-19 win, and his postgame comments landed on both the Buckeyes level and his own teams shortcomings. Braun praised Ohio States performance and pointed to the programs recent success as the kind of standard Northwestern is trying to reach, even as he acknowledged the Wildcats have work to do with penalties that continue to hurt them.

The replay decision that helped swing the game was the part Braun clearly took issue with, as he disagreed with the ruling that led to an Ohio State touchdown. He also offered an update on injured quarterback Aidan Chiles, saying the recovery is moving week to week, leaving Northwestern to balance immediate cleanup with uncertainty at a key position. [Read more 🡒]

Ohio State Faces A Bigger Problem Than Just Beating Northwestern

Ohio State heads into its matchup with Northwestern knowing the margin for error is gone, but the bigger issue is what the Buckeyes have looked like lately on both sides of the ball. Sitting No. 20 in the College Football Playoff standings, they need a win just to keep their postseason hopes alive, yet the concern around the program goes beyond one Saturday. The offense has been uneven, the defense has had its own lapses, and only a handful of players have consistently stood out.

The Buckeyes are also watching the rest of the Big Ten and the broader playoff picture closely, because their path is tied to what happens elsewhere as much as what happens in their own building. UCLA, Indiana, USC, Oregon and Iowa all factor into the equation, which means Ohio State cannot afford to treat Northwestern as a simple get-right game. To stay in the race, the Buckeyes need more than a win - they need signs that they can actually play like a contender again. [Read more 🡒]

Ohio State Stopped The Slide But One Concern Still Lingers

Ohio State needed a steadier afternoon, and it got one at Ohio Stadium. The Buckeyes beat Northwestern 28-19 to snap a two-game losing streak and move to 7-3, with Luke Fahey providing a much-needed spark by throwing three touchdown passes. Jeremiah Smith was once again central to the offense, and his fourth-quarter touchdown gave the Buckeyes some breathing room in a game that had enough tension to keep the home crowd on edge.

Smith also left his mark on the record book, setting the Big Tens all-time receiving yards record during the game, a reminder of how much the Buckeyes still have going for them even as the season has been uneven. Northwestern dropped to 6-4 with its third straight loss, but for Ohio State the bigger takeaway was more immediate: the skid is over, though the questions around consistency are not going away just yet. [Read more 🡒]