Ohio State’s offense has the numbers of a machine, but the part that matters most has started to sputter.
The Buckeyes are still piling up yardage at a high level, sitting 11th nationally in yards per game, 14th in yards per play and tied for 17th with 37 red-zone trips. That kind of production has been a Ryan Day staple since he arrived in 2017, first to help energize Urban Meyer’s offense and later to take over as head coach two years after that.
But the shine has come off in the games that matter most. Ohio State is 19th nationally in scoring with 36.6 points per game, and that number drops to 22.8 against AP Top 25 opponents. The issue is hard to miss: the Buckeyes are getting inside the 20, then coming away with too few touchdowns.
“That’s the talk of the town right now,” running back Isaiah West said as Ohio State gets ready to host Oregon on Saturday.
The Buckeyes have converted 62.2% of their red-zone trips into touchdowns, which ranks ninth in the Big Ten. That’s a step back from 75.8% in 2024 and 66.7% last season, making this Ohio State’s worst red-zone touchdown rate since the conference expanded to 18 teams.
The problem gets sharper when the opponent gets bigger. Since last year’s regular-season finale, Ohio State is 3-4 in games against Michigan, Indiana (twice), Miami, Texas, Iowa and USC.
Across those seven matchups, the Buckeyes have had 27 red-zone trips, not counting the final drive at Iowa when they ran out the clock. Only 11 of those possessions ended in touchdowns, a 40.7% clip.
The common thread has been self-inflicted damage. Penalties, sacks and negative runs have kept showing up at the worst possible time.
“Everybody has to be locked in and keyed in on that,” West said. “That’s a team effort.
There’s no reason we should be jumping offsides. There’s no reason we should have 12 people on the field.
There’s no reason we should be holding. This is Day 1 fundamental stuff.”
Of those 27 red-zone trips, 14 included a play or penalty that pushed Ohio State backward.
“We have to do a better job of focusing, making sure that it’s simple and it’s clean,” Day said.
The conversation around Ohio State’s offensive identity has also turned to personnel, especially with the Buckeyes having lost four of their last eight games against Power Four opponents. Day’s reputation as an offensive mind was built on quarterbacks and receivers producing at a high level, with Justin Fields, C.J. Stroud and Dwayne Haskins becoming major names while throwing to Garrett Wilson, Jaxon Smith-Njigba and Marvin Harrison Jr.
Yet down near the goal line, Ohio State has leaned into heavier packages and more tight end usage. That showed up in a notable sequence late in the first half of the Oct. 17 win at Indiana, when Jeremiah Smith was visibly frustrated as the Buckeyes ran three straight goal-to-go plays without a receiver on the field. Smith returned for fourth down, drew the attention of four defenders and helped set up an easy touchdown pass to running back Bo Jackson.
Asked Tuesday whether the team’s red-zone personnel matches the identity it should have, Day pointed back to execution while acknowledging the issue.
“We can continue to go back through and see if there’s schematically ways we can do better, which is exactly what we need to do,” Day said. “Ultimately, everything that happens on the field is my responsibility. I’m involved with everything.
“To say it’s working very well is not accurate. It’s hard for anybody to score touchdowns in the red zone nowadays.
When you see that across college football, it’s getting harder and harder. I’m not making excuses.
I’m just saying we have to execute cleanly down there. When we have negative plays and we have penalties, then it certainly sets us way back.”
Ohio State didn’t solve the issue at USC on Saturday. The Buckeyes managed touchdowns on only one of their four red-zone trips in a loss that counted as their second of the season.
A third loss would likely close the door on a third straight College Football Playoff appearance. In early November, the pressure in Columbus is as high as it has been since the field expanded to 12 teams in 2024, and West said better execution in Los Angeles could have changed the whole conversation.
“We turn those field goals or those missed opportunities into touchdowns, it’s a completely different game,” West said. “We’re having a completely different conversation right now.”
In Other News...
Jeremiah Smith Just Got A Huge Heisman Opening For Ohio State
Jeremiah Smith has spent this season looking every bit like the kind of receiver who can tilt the Heisman conversation, and the numbers back it up. He has 62 catches for 1,067 yards and 13 touchdowns, production that places him among the nations leaders in all three categories and has made him a central reason Ohio States offense has stayed so dangerous.
Now the path in front of Smith may be a little clearer after Miami receiver Malachi Toney suffered a high ankle sprain that required surgery and will keep him out for the rest of the regular season. For Ohio State, the development matters because Smith remains one of the Buckeyes most important weapons as they try to lock down a College Football Playoff spot, and any shift in the national award race only adds more attention to what he does next. [Read more 🡒]
Ohio States Oregon Matchup Just Got Complicated By Key Injury Changes
The build-up to Ohio States matchup with Oregon has taken on a different look after injuries started reshaping both sides of the field. The Buckeyes and Ducks were already bracing for a high-stakes game, but the latest injury updates have added another layer of uncertainty, with both teams now having to adjust their plans around key personnel changes before kickoff.
For Oregon, the biggest immediate concern is the status of running back Jordon Davison, who is expected to be out week-to-week with a lower-extremity injury. There is at least some encouraging news on the other side of the ball, with wide receiver Jeremiah McClellan probable to return from a foot injury, but the larger question remains how both teams will handle the ripple effects if the quarterback situation shifts again by game day. [Read more 🡒]
Ohio States Big Ten Path Now Comes Down To Tiebreaker Chaos
Ohio States Big Ten title path is still alive, but it has turned into the kind of standings puzzle that can make a November scoreboard-watcher reach for a calculator. The Buckeyes sit third in the conference, yet they remain in the mix for the championship game if they finish strong and get help from around the league, with the race tightening enough that a three-way tie could become part of the equation.
What makes it messy is how quickly the picture can shift from week to week. A tie involving Ohio State, Indiana and UCLA would send the league into a tiebreaker process built on common opponents and conference winning percentage, and the Buckeyes can still survive one more loss if the right results break their way elsewhere. Lose twice, though, and the margin for error shrinks to the point where Ohio State would need a lot of outside help just to stay in the conversation. [Read more 🡒]