Ohio State walked out of Austin with a painful lesson: Jeremiah Smith can still look unstoppable, and it still might not be enough.
For stretches against Texas, the Buckeyes’ star receiver was exactly what the hype says he is. Ohio State built a 20-3 lead, Smith was shredding the Longhorns, and his numbers were soaring.
By halftime, he was already making a loud early-season push for the Heisman Trophy. Then he ripped off a 43-yard catch in traffic to convert a third-and-10 midway through the third quarter, pushing him to 164 yards on eight catches.
After that, the production stopped.
Texas stormed back with 21 points in the fourth quarter and escaped with a 24-23 win, and Ohio State was left staring at the same problem that has followed it into the fall: the passing game has too much riding on Smith and not enough coming from anywhere else.
That became even clearer once the Buckeyes’ offense went cold after halftime. Julian Sayin was sharp before the break, going 12 of 16 for 192 yards.
After halftime, he finished 5 of 16 for 86 yards with an interception. Ohio State managed only three points in the second half.
Smith dropped one pass early in the fourth quarter, and the rest of the wideout room combined for just two catches and 24 yards.
"I mean, when you go 2 for 12 in the second half throwing the football, there's not a rhythm in the pass game," Ohio State coach Ryan Day said Tuesday, using a count that left out a few snaps in the final seconds.
The workload on Smith has only grown. According to Pro Football Focus, he has been targeted on 42% of his routes this season, up from 29% last season.
His average target is traveling 16.1 yards downfield, nearly five yards deeper than a year ago. His catch rate has dipped from 82% to 64%.
Against Texas, he drew 16 of Ohio State’s 30 targets.
That kind of usage can overwhelm a defense. It can also make the offense predictable when the other options don’t hold up.
Last season, Ohio State had Carnell Tate giving the Buckeyes a dependable second punch. Tate caught 51 passes for 875 yards and nine touchdowns, and Ohio State quarterbacks posted a passer rating of 151.8 when targeting him, even better than the 149.3 they had when going to Smith.
Tate is gone now. Tight end Max Klare, who was the team’s third-leading pass catcher last year and drew 55 targets, is gone too.
Ohio State’s tight ends have combined for just eight targets this season.
"So we've got to get other guys involved," Day said. "We've got to take some pressure off of Jeremiah, be consistent in the run game and then find ways to spread the ball out. That's definitely part of where we've got to go moving forward."
That’s the assignment now, and it has a deadline attached. Ohio State has four weeks to build something sturdier before its Oct. 17 trip to Bloomington to face reigning national champion Indiana.
The Buckeyes will be favored in their next four games, starting Saturday against Kent State, but the real issue isn’t the schedule. It’s whether somebody besides Smith can become a threat defenses have to respect.
The alternatives have been inconsistent. Devin McCuin flashed against Ball State with six catches for 97 yards and a touchdown, but against Texas he had one catch on three targets for 5 yards.
Freshmen Chris Henry Jr. and Brock Boyd weren’t targeted at all against the Longhorns, even though Henry Jr. had already caught a touchdown in the opener and arrived as the nation’s No. 2 receiver in the class of 2026, per 247Sports. Brandon Inniss, the senior many around the program hoped would be more dependable this season, finished with one catch for 19 yards.
The Buckeyes did create some early chunk plays against Texas zone coverage, but the Longhorns changed the look after halftime. Will Muschamp shifted the defense, dialing up more pressure and leaning on man coverage. Ohio State’s offense never adjusted well enough to answer.
And in the biggest moment, the dependence on Smith showed up again. With Ohio State clinging to the lead late in the fourth quarter, the Buckeyes called a fade to Smith on third-and-4 in an attempt to finish the game.
The throw fell incomplete at the 2-yard line after a Texas cornerback carried him toward the sideline. Ohio State then missed the field goal, and Texas got another chance to go win it.
"Yeah, I absolutely own that," Day said of the call.
There was another miss that may haunt Ohio State even more. With 8:20 left in the third quarter, Texas busted coverage in the middle of the field and McCuin slipped free for what should have been a touchdown.
Sayin, under pressure from his right on second-and-10, overthrew him. A completion would have made it 27-3 and likely put the game away.
"I ended up missing him high and, you know, I want that one back for sure," Sayin said.
Smith did his job in Austin. That part is not in doubt.
The question now is whether Ohio State can find anyone else who can do enough to make defenses pay for keying on him. Day said this summer that Smith is "by far, in my mind, the best player in the country."
Texas treated him that way. The next opponents almost certainly will too.
In Other News...
Ohio State Has A Ryan Day Problem Fans Cant Ignore
Ohio States recent habit of watching comfortable fourth-quarter leads shrink has turned into more than a bad stretch. The Buckeyes have had the kind of defensive fatigue and late-game confusion that can undo otherwise solid afternoons, and the issue has shown up in consecutive games enough to raise real questions about how the team closes.
Ryan Days program has been especially vulnerable when opponents keep pushing the pace and the defense is forced to hold up under pressure. The loss to Texas only sharpened the concern, since the Longhorns have brought a steadier offensive identity over multiple seasons while Ohio State has struggled to adjust and protect leads when games turn critical. [Read more 🡒]
Ryan Day Just Put Ohio State's Punt Decisions On Notice
Ohio States special teams already had a spotlight on them after the loss to Texas, and Ryan Day only sharpened it when he revisited the punt decision from Texas 39-yard line. The Buckeyes chose to kick on 4th-and-4, and the result was a 26-yard net that left plenty of room for second-guessing. Day still defended the call, while also pointing to punter Joe McGuires talent and framing the issue as more about execution than philosophy.
Robby Discher was brought in this offseason as special teams coordinator with the expectation that this phase would get cleaner, and Days comments suggested the Buckeyes are watching closely to see whether that happens. If the operation stays inconsistent, the comfort level on similar fourth-down decisions may start to change, especially in the kinds of high-leverage spots that can swing a top-end game. The message was clear enough: the punts are not automatic if the returns keep coming up short. [Read more 🡒]
Ohio State May Have Found A Young Defensive Difference Maker
Riley Pettijohns role in Ohio States loss to Texas was one of the quieter bright spots for a defense that spent much of the night under pressure. The young linebacker logged a career-high 37 snaps while moving around to multiple spots, and he flashed enough disruption to stand out even in a tough result. He also fit in with a broader theme from the game, as other young Buckeyes like Jay Timmons and Khary Wilder showed they may be ready for bigger chances too.
Ryan Day has already signaled that Pettijohns workload should keep growing, and it is easy to see why the staff is intrigued. The linebacker has shown a knack for slipping blocks and finding the football, the kind of trait that can change how a defense feels from one week to the next. Ohio State still has to sort out the bigger picture after the loss, but Pettijohns emergence gives the Buckeyes something real to build on. [Read more 🡒]