Ohio State is set to kick off its season against Ball State on Saturday, and with fall camp wrapping up, one of the clearest concerns to emerge is at quarterback. Tavien St. Clair entered August with plenty of attention, but the month did not go the way many around the program probably hoped.
St. Clair was never expected to beat out Julian Sayin for the starting job this year, since Sayin is entering his second season as the Buckeyes’ starter.
Still, there was a path for St. Clair to put himself in position to be the obvious next man up if Sayin leaves for the NFL.
That hasn’t happened. Instead, St.
Clair did not secure the No. 2 quarterback role and is now battling true freshman Luke Fahey for the backup spot behind Sayin.
Ryan Day addressed that competition on Tuesday and made it clear the staff may try to get both quarterbacks work once the season starts. "If we can get them both reps in the game, we'll try to do that," Ryan Day said on Tuesday. "We'll just kinda see how the game goes."
The preseason buzz around St. Clair had been real.
247Sports rated him the No. 3 quarterback in the 2025 high school recruiting class, and The Athletic’s Manny Navarro listed him as the No. 5 backup quarterback in college football this season. Navarro’s July writeup came before fall camp, though, and it painted a much brighter picture than the one Ohio State appears to have now.
"St. Clair has only taken 13 snaps and attempted two passes in his college career, but his size (6-4, 230) and potential as a former five-star recruit make him one of the country’s most tantalizing backups," Navarro wrote in July. "He is in position to take over in 2027 if Julian Sayin declares for the NFL Draft."
That assessment may not hold after camp, with the latest signs suggesting St. Clair is no longer viewed as one of the elite backup options in the country.
And for Ohio State, that matters. The Buckeyes are loaded across the roster, but a setback at quarterback would change the equation fast if Sayin were to miss any time. Backup quarterback play can swing a season, and Ohio State knows that better than most.
The program has already lived through that kind of turbulence. In 2014, Braxton Miller went down in fall camp and missed the entire year, opening the door for J.T.
Barrett to take over as the starter. Then Barrett was injured against Michigan, and Cardale Jones was forced into the spotlight.
Jones ended up leading Ohio State to the first-ever College Football Playoff title, beating Alabama and Oregon along the way.
In Other News...
Ohio State Defense Faces An Early Test It Can't Dodge
Ohio States defense has no shortage of names to sort through after losing a wave of elite production from last season, and the first real chance to start answering those questions comes against Ball State. The Buckeyes are trying to replace proven playmakers at multiple spots, with the linebacker room drawing particular attention and several transfers expected to be part of the solution as the staff figures out what this group looks like in live action.
Jay Timmons is one of the more intriguing pieces in that mix, a freshman cornerback whose role could grow as the season settles in. For a defense that needs both confidence and chemistry, a game like this matters beyond the final score because it gives Ohio State a chance to see which combinations hold up, which ones need more time, and where the early uncertainty still lingers. [Read more 🡒]
Ohio State Is Giving Jim Tressel One Of Its Highest Honors
Ohio State is adding Jim Tressel to one of the programs most visible tributes, with his name set to join the Ring of Honor at Ohio Stadium. It is a fitting nod to a coach whose tenure in Columbus helped define an era, from the 2003 national championship to eight Big Ten titles, all of which will now be part of the display alongside his name.
Tressels place in Buckeyes history has long been secure, and this honor only reinforces how central his run from 2001 through 2010 remains to the programs identity. Already in the College Football Hall of Fame, he now gets another permanent reminder inside the stadium where his teams built so many of their biggest moments. [Read more 🡒]
Jaxon Smith-Njigba Just Reopened A Debate Ohio State Fans Never Settled
Jaxon Smith-Njigba revisited one of the most lingering Ohio State what-ifs during an appearance on The Ryen Russillo Show, where he addressed the hamstring injury that kept him out of the College Football Playoff and his decision not to play. He said he wanted to be on the field to help Ohio State win a national championship, but the injury left him unable to go, putting a painful cap on a season that had already made him one of the Buckeyes most electric playmakers.
Since then, Smith-Njigba has only added to the intrigue around that missed opportunity. He has become one of the NFLs top receivers, leading the league in receiving yards and earning a contract extension, which only sharpens the old debate over how much Ohio State might have gained if he had been able to suit up. For Buckeyes fans, it is the kind of conversation that never really dies, especially when the player at the center of it has gone on to prove just how high his ceiling really was. [Read more 🡒]