Ohio State’s freshmen have already started to show a little of everything in practice, and that’s exactly why the debate around their scoring total is so interesting. The Buckeyes now have a four-man freshman class for 2026-27, with the summer additions of Vuk Lazarevic and LJ Smith joining Anthony Thompson and Alex Smith, and the question is simple: will that group combine to score more than 30.5 points per game?
A quick look from Tuesday’s 30-minute practice window offered a few early clues. Jimmie Williams looked like a player whose floor is a quality sixth man and whose ceiling could reach All-Big Ten Honorable Mention.
Josh Ojianwuna appeared to be in great shape and moving freely without any pain or hesitation when cutting. Justin Pippen brought some edge, willing to mix it up, talk, and get nose-to-nose with anyone, especially when guarding on the ball.
Alex Smith and Curtis Givens, meanwhile, were knocking down shots at a very consistent rate.
The over/under debate itself centers on how much production Ohio State can squeeze from the freshman group right away. Connor took the over, and his case starts with Thompson. He put Thompson at 17.5 points per game, then projected 8.0 for LJ Smith, 4.5 for Alex Smith, and 1.0 for Lazarevic.
Connor said Thompson’s scoring profile is the kind that jumps off the page: an effortless three-point shot that’s tough to block or even contest, easy dunks, and the wingspan to become a strong rebounder. He also made the case that Thompson is the freshman most people already expect to be really good in his lone college season.
From there, Connor leaned into the two Smiths. He said both Alex and LJ have looked better than expected in practice, and that the coaching staff has described LJ Smith as “fearless.”
Connor pointed to Smith’s ability to get downhill quickly, his shifty game, and his high-level three-point shooting, while also noting he hasn’t seen enough yet to know whether Smith can consistently hit mid-range shots. On Alex Smith, Connor said the freshman has grown more comfortable as summer has gone on, cited his size at 6-foot-9 and 215 pounds, and noted that he hit at least four or five threes on Tuesday.
Connor also expects some games where Smith doesn’t play much at all, but others where he reaches double figures, especially in the non-conference portion of the schedule. Lazarevic, in Connor’s view, won’t play much and won’t have a meaningful freshman impact.
Justin took the under, but he made clear he likes the class overall. He said all four freshmen should eventually be productive players, just not necessarily right away.
The one exception, in his view, is Thompson. Even so, Justin projected Thompson closer to 13-16 points per game, arguing that while he’s an elite scorer, Ohio State has too many other players who will take shots, including John Mobley, Amare Bynum, Justin Pippen, and Jimmie Williams.
Justin was also skeptical that Alex Smith and Lazarevic will provide much scoring this season, putting their combined output at just 4-6 points per game. That leaves LJ Smith, and Justin thinks the late arrival to campus matters. He said Smith could have some games in the 10-15 point range, but with so many mouths to feed on offense, he expects his average to land around 6-8 points per game rather than the 10-12 needed to push the group over the line.
In Other News...
Bryce Underwood Just Gave Ohio State Fans Another Reason To Laugh
Bryce Underwood has already given Ohio State plenty to work with after a rough first run in the rivalry, and now the Michigan quarterback is back in the conversation for another reason. His previous season included a difficult showing against the Buckeyes and more struggles in the bowl game against Texas, the kind of stretch that made his first year in Ann Arbor look a lot less like a breakthrough than Michigan had hoped.
Underwood then added another layer at a youth camp, where he made a bold self-assessment that is sure to travel fast around the Big Ten. For Ohio State fans, it is the sort of thing that practically writes its own punchline, especially with the rivalry still looming and plenty of time for the noise around Michigan's quarterback situation to grow louder before the next meeting. [Read more 🡒]
Buckeyes Face A Pricey Recruiting Test For Elite RB Target
Ohio States push for David Gabriel-Georges has turned into more than a simple recruiting battle. The Buckeyes are in the mix with Ole Miss and Tennessee for the top-ranked running back in the 2027 class, and the conversation around him has already shifted from talent evaluation to the kind of financial commitment it may take to land him.
On3s Pete Nakos has reported that Gabriel-Georges could command a record-setting NIL package for a running back recruit, which puts Ohio State in a difficult spot as it weighs upside against cost. The Buckeyes have to decide how far they want to go in a market where elite freshmen are getting treated like proven commodities, and where every big offer carries the risk of crowding out other roster-building priorities. [Read more 🡒]
Ohio States Next Receiver Rise May Already Be Taking Shape
Jerquaden Guilford already looks like the kind of receiver Ohio State can mold into something bigger down the line. The highly regarded 2026 commit brings the polished route running and athletic upside that has long fit the Buckeyes receiver pipeline, and his pledge was a notable recruiting win over Michigan, Ole Miss, Indiana and other Power Four programs. He arrives with the sort of skill set that suggests he can eventually fit right in with the programs next wave of pass-catchers.
For now, though, the usual Ohio State blueprint still applies. Freshman receivers typically spend their first year learning the offense and adding the physical polish needed for Big Ten football, and Guilford is expected to follow that path rather than jump straight into major snaps. The more interesting part may come after that, when the roster turns over and the depth chart opens up in a way that could make his second season look very different from his first. [Read more 🡒]