Fox’s Big Noon Saturday window had No. 6 Ohio State rolling past Kent State 59-3, but the conversation after the game quickly turned away from the scoreboard and toward Gus Johnson’s broadcast.
The Fox play-by-play man drew heavy criticism from college football fans for sounding unusually flat throughout the Buckeyes’ blowout. The most glaring moment came early in the fourth quarter, when freshman receiver Chris Henry Jr. turned a short pass from backup quarterback Luke Fahey into a 75-yard touchdown. Johnson delivered the call in a deadpan tone: "And he will record his first touchdown as a member of the Ohio State Buckeyes, 75 yards."
The problem, of course, was that the line wasn’t even accurate. Henry had already scored a 15-yard touchdown against Ball State in the season opener, making the Kent State play his second touchdown as a Buckeye, not his first.
Fox analyst Joel Klatt corrected the record during the replay.
"Obviously in Week 1, he was frustrated with a couple of drops," Klatt said. "One of them went for an interception. He could have had a touchdown and ended up scoring later."
Johnson’s subdued approach didn’t change on the next snap, when 349-pound freshman defensive tackle Jamir Perez recovered a Kent State fumble and rumbled into the end zone for another Ohio State touchdown.
That flat tone was there from the start, too. It showed up on running back Ja'Kobi Jackson’s opening touchdown run and carried over to receiver Nate Roberts’ first career touchdown catch. Johnson finally sounded more animated on the final play of the first half, when Julian Sayin connected with Brandon Inniss on a 49-yard Hail Mary to send Ohio State into the break up 35-0.
Fans immediately noticed the difference, and many vented about it on X. One Ohio State fan page wrote, "Gus Johnson is a shell of himself," while another fan posted, "The least energy I've ever heard on a Gus Johnson call."
Some viewers pointed to the broadcast setup as a possible explanation. Fox had sent its Big Noon Kickoff pregame show to Wembley Stadium in London for Arizona State vs. Kansas, with that game airing on FS1 at noon ET while Kent State at Ohio State aired on Fox in the same window.
This wasn’t the first time Johnson’s calls during an Ohio State blowout drew attention. Fans also went after him during the Buckeyes’ 45-0 win over Purdue in November 2024.
On Jack Sawyer’s fumble return for a touchdown in that game, Johnson said with little energy, "And a fumble on the play, Ohio State is there, they pick it up and run it in for a touchdown. Jack Sawyer."
At the time, some fans suggested Johnson might have been sending a message to Fox for slotting Ohio State into the Big Noon window so often. That Purdue game was Ohio State’s fourth Big Noon appearance that season.
Ohio State is now 2-1 and will open Big Ten play against Illinois on Sept. 26 at noon ET at Ohio Stadium.
In Other News...
Jeremiah Smith Just Entered Rare Ohio State Receiver Company
Jeremiah Smith has already put himself in some rare Ohio State company, and the numbers behind it only underline how quickly he has become the centerpiece of the Buckeyes passing game. By moving past Michael Jenkins to become the schools all-time leading receiver, Smith added another mark to a resume that keeps growing even as he still has plenty of football ahead of him.
Smith has made clear he is not finished, either, saying he wants to chase more school records as Ohio State moves through the season. Ryan Day has been just as effusive, praising both Smiths production and the way he carries himself, and for a program that has seen its share of star wideouts, that combination is what makes this climb feel especially notable. [Read more 🡒]
Ohio State's Most Unexpected Touchdown Came From A Player Fans Didn't Expect
Ohio States defense got an unexpected jolt in its rout of Kent State, and it came from a player built more for clogging the middle than finding the end zone. Freshman defensive tackle Jamir Perez turned a fumble recovery into a touchdown in the 59-3 win, a rare scoring moment for a position group that usually measures success in tackles and quarterback pressure rather than points.
For a Buckeyes team that cruised through the afternoon, Perezs run to the end zone stood out as one of the games most memorable moments. Ryan Day even had a little fun afterward when the play and the celebration came up, a reminder that sometimes the biggest surprise of a lopsided game is the one nobody saw coming. [Read more 🡒]
Ohio States Backup Quarterback Battle Just Took An Unexpected Turn
Ohio States quarterback depth chart has started to reveal a little more than it did in September, and the backup job behind Julian Sayin suddenly looks like it has a lean. In the Buckeyes recent games, true freshman Luke Fahey has been the one getting more live work when the offense has gone to its reserves, and he has used those chances to lead multiple drives and show enough poise to get noticed.
Tavien St. Clair, the five-star sophomore who entered with plenty of buzz, has not gotten the same run, which is why the competition now feels like it has a clearer edge than it did a short time ago. Ryan Day has not addressed the race publicly, so there is still no official word on how the staff views it, but the on-field rotation has already started to tell its own story. [Read more 🡒]