Ohio State’s defense has gone from promising to combustible in a hurry, and Matt Patricia is taking the heat.
For much of the first half of the season, the Buckeyes looked like they might have enough on that side of the ball even after losing three first-round picks from a year ago. The Indiana game seemed to back that up, with Ohio State holding the Hoosiers to 15 points.
But the last three weeks have told a very different story. Ohio State gave up 71 points in back-to-back games against USC and Oregon, then allowed Northwestern to score 19.
By the time Nebraska put up 21 points in the first half, fans had seen enough.
The reaction online was immediate and ugly, with plenty of Ohio State supporters calling for Patricia to be fired.
“Matt Patricia is garbage. Ryan Day has to stop hiring these overrated failed NFL coaches.”
“Matt Patricia when he has to construct a defense without Reese Styles and Downs pic.twitter.com/o1pp4WxWw0”
“Isn’t Matt Patricia the highest paid defense coordinator in college football? Isn’t Ohio State paying him that kind of money to be able to out scheme the opposing team? Just pathetic.”
The first quarter only added fuel to the fire. Ohio State allowed 124 yards in that opening frame, the most yards it had surrendered in any quarter all season. Given the way this defense has been trending, that might not even wind up being the low point.
Nebraska’s offense found room on the ground and in the intermediate passing game, and the Buckeyes never really settled in. The Cornhuskers even had a shot to score on their first drive, but penalties got in their way. Still, the overall picture was ugly from start to finish.
Jeremiah Smith was the one thing keeping Ohio State from getting buried. He caught two touchdown passes in the first half and kept the Buckeyes hanging around.
Without him, this game would have been a blowout. The source material makes the case plainly: he looks like the best player in college football and should win the Heisman.
The larger issue, though, is what this stretch says about Patricia’s future. Even if he survives this game, the argument for a change at defensive coordinator is already out there.
The source points to the idea that Patricia’s success last year may have had more to do with Caleb Downs, Arvell Reese, and Sonny Styles than with Patricia himself. Outside of that, there hasn’t been much to hang onto.
Ryan Day also comes into focus here. The source argues that he needs someone who understands the college game better, not another NFL name, and says the defense needs an up-and-coming coach who can actually handle the job. Patricia, the piece says, needs to be fired.
A midseason move seems unlikely. Day did fire Robby Discher during the season, but that’s the only in-season coaching change he has made. The expectation is that he usually waits until the year is over before making decisions like that.
And if Ohio State keeps stumbling, the pressure won’t stop with Patricia. The source says Day himself needs to worry about his job security too, because if the Buckeyes miss the College Football Playoff, there’s no guarantee he’ll be back on the sideline next year.
In Other News...
Ryan Day Sends Blunt Message After Another Ohio State Letdown
Ohio States latest setback did more than add another blemish to the season, it officially ended any College Football Playoff path and left Ryan Day searching for answers in the aftermath. Day, along with Carson Hinzman and Payton Pierce, spoke briefly after the loss and pointed to the same familiar issues that have dogged the Buckeyes at different points this year, especially a defense that couldnt hold up when it mattered and a team that gave away too many chances with penalties and turnovers.
The focus now shifts almost immediately to Michigan, which only raises the stakes on a season that has already slipped far from expectations. Day made clear the Buckeyes will have to sort through what needs to change after the season, but for the moment the message is about regrouping and getting ready for one more game that still carries plenty of weight in Columbus. [Read more 🡒]
Ohio State Faces Harsh New Reality After Crushing Nebraska Loss
Nebraskas 31-28 win over No. 14 Ohio State on its home field was the kind of result that can change the feel of a season in an instant. The Huskers snapped a 31-game losing streak against ranked opponents, and quarterback Anthony Colandrea played a central role by accounting for three touchdowns as Nebraska built enough of a cushion to withstand the Buckeyes late push.
For Ohio State, the sting goes beyond a single bad afternoon. The comeback attempt came up short, and with this loss the Buckeyes are effectively out of College Football Playoff contention this season, leaving little room for error and even less comfort after a defeat that was as damaging as it was surprising. [Read more 🡒]
Ohio States Same Defensive Problem Is Fueling A Bigger Matt Patricia Debate
Ohio States defense spent the Nebraska game looking a step behind in the same places it has been vulnerable before, and the result has only sharpened the conversation around Matt Patricias fit in Columbus. The Buckeyes have been trying to absorb the loss of key players who helped drive last seasons success, while opposing offensive coaches have found ways to attack the soft spots that remain. What looked like a one-game issue has started to feel more like a larger schematic question.
Patricias challenge is not just about calling a game plan, but about adapting it to a different roster and a different set of strengths. The Nebraska tape offered another reminder that the answers are not arriving quickly, especially when the defense is forced to defend the same problem in different ways. For Ohio State, the concern is no longer only what happened in one game, but whether the current approach can be adjusted before opponents keep making it a weekly theme. [Read more 🡒]
