Ohio State Faces An Uncomfortable Big Ten Reality

As the Big Ten Championship game era approaches its end, Ohio State grapples with its legacy and future in a shifting college football landscape.

The Big Ten Championship game is on its way out after the 2026 season, and that has me thinking about Ohio State’s strange place in the story of the event. For a program that has treated Indianapolis like a familiar destination for years, there’s a real chance the Buckeyes won’t even be part of the final chapter.

That would be a fittingly odd ending, considering where this all started. The last time Ohio State lost three games in a season was the first year of the Big Ten Championship game.

After a 6-7 finish tied to the Tattoogate scandal, the Buckeyes stumbled into the new era of conference title games. They missed the next one too, even after going 12-0 in the regular season, because of the Tattoogate bowl ban.

And yet, over time, the Big Ten Championship became Ohio State territory. The Buckeyes appeared in 2013, 2014, 2025 and every season from 2017 through 2020.

They won it in 2014 and then rattled off four straight appearances from 2017 on. Since the game launched in 2011, Ohio State has more appearances, seven, and more wins, five, than any other Big Ten program, even if six current league teams weren’t in the conference back then.

There was a stretch when getting to Indy felt like part of the job description for Ohio State. The title game wasn’t supposed to be a novelty. It was supposed to be the place where the Buckeyes reminded everybody who set the standard.

That’s why this season feels so jarring. Ohio State is still alive mathematically, but the road is almost absurdly narrow.

At 7-3 with two conference losses, the Buckeyes need a very specific chain of results over the final two weeks. Indiana, for one, has to lose to either Washington or Purdue, and that’s only one piece of a much longer “If this AND this AND this all happen” scenario.

So, realistically, the Buckeyes are staring at a future where they watch the final Big Ten Championship game from home.

That part is disappointing, sure. But the bigger issue is what it says about Ohio State’s recent run in Indianapolis.

The Buckeyes haven’t won a Big Ten Championship game since 2020, the COVID season. They didn’t even make the game in 2024, the same year they went on to win the National Championship.

You can make the case that the conference title matters less now that the playoff is bigger and the national championship is the main prize. But Ohio State is still supposed to chase Big Ten titles. That has always been part of the program’s identity, long before there was a championship game to play in.

Five straight seasons without a conference championship is a real drought for a program with Ohio State’s resources, recruiting edge and expectations. And it gets more uncomfortable when you remember the Buckeyes have still been nationally relevant throughout that stretch, even good enough to win it all.

This isn’t some struggling team wandering through the last half-decade. It’s Ohio State.

The comparison to Michigan only sharpens the point. The Wolverines won three straight Big Ten titles from 2021 through 2023. And the sting grows even more when you think back to the 2025 Big Ten Championship, Ohio State’s only appearance since 2020, when Indiana won 13-10 after the Buckeyes missed a 27-yard field goal.

That’s the weird part about this era: Ohio State has been elite, even national-champion level, without being the team that owns its conference.

The expanded Big Ten has changed the path to Indianapolis. The league is deeper, the travel is different, and the regular season has more traps.

But those changes have hit everyone, not just Ohio State. That’s part of what makes the Buckeyes’ failure to adjust so frustrating.

And now the timing has turned cruel. This is the final shot for Ohio State to reclaim the conference title before the game disappears, and the Buckeyes are sitting at 7-3. That’s a letdown no matter how the rest of the season plays out.

A 7-3 season at Ohio State should not be celebrated. Still, the larger question is how success gets measured for this program now.

Take 2024. The Buckeyes lost to Michigan and didn’t win the conference, but they won the National Championship, so the season was rightly treated as a success. At the time, even I was saying I didn’t care about the conference title if they won the whole thing.

But now that the Big Ten Championship is going away, that line of thinking feels different. Winning the conference has somehow stopped carrying much weight at all, and that’s hard to square with what Ohio State is supposed to be.

The Buckeyes don’t need to win every Big Ten game or every conference title to prove they belong among the elite. But they should be expected to put themselves in position to win the league more often than not. Ryan Day has done a lot with the program, but as the scrutiny rises after this season’s collapse, the lack of recent conference dominance has to be part of the conversation too.

Ohio State hasn’t won a post-COVID Big Ten title. That feels like a real part of Day’s tenure, not a footnote to ignore. And with the conference championship game fading away, it would be a strange ending to the Buckeyes’ relationship with the event.

The Buckeyes still have a slim path to Indianapolis. If they miss, that history is set. And in a future without the Big Ten Championship game, Ohio State will need to decide what success in the conference is supposed to look like - without ever letting the standard slip.

In Other News...

Curt Cignetti Just Reopened Ohio States Julian Sayin Flashpoint

Julian Sayins season-ending fractured elbow already left Ohio State dealing with a major hit at quarterback, and the ripple effects have been hard to ignore. Since the injury in the game against Indiana, the Buckeyes have dropped two of three and are suddenly fighting to keep their College Football Playoff hopes on track, with the offense under a different kind of pressure than it was a few weeks ago.

Curt Cignettis comments this week brought the whole episode back into focus, especially the blunt way he described what happened in that game. For Ohio State, it is another reminder that the Sayin injury is not just a medical update from earlier in the season, but a flashpoint that still hangs over the team as it tries to steady itself down the stretch. [Read more 🡒]

Ohio State Faces A Tense Nebraska Test With Plenty Still Unsettled

Ohio State got past Northwestern at home despite a few self-inflicted hiccups, and now the attention shifts to a road trip that figures to say more about where this team really stands. The Buckeyes have been steady enough to keep winning, but the recent performance also left room for the kind of cleanup work that tends to matter once the schedule gets more demanding.

Nebraska offers a different kind of test, one that comes with the usual road-game pressure and a chance to see how well Ohio State can tighten things up away from home. BetMGMs numbers and the broader conversation around the matchup reflect a team that is still sorting through its best version, and with the schedule moving forward, there is still plenty left to settle about how high this group can climb. [Read more 🡒]

Ohio State Just Turned A Recruiting Weak Spot Into A Real Strength

Ohio States 2027 recruiting class has started to look a lot deeper at running back, and Carlos Locklyn is a big reason why. The Buckeyes have now landed two commitments at the position, with the latest coming from Alabama four-star Nigel Newkirk after a visit to Columbus. Newkirk is ranked No. 14 nationally among running backs, and his switch adds another high-end piece to a class that is already climbing the national rankings.

The momentum at the position has been notable because it comes on the heels of another flip, as four-star Daylan Gordon moved from Texas State to Ohio State. For a program that has long expected to recruit at a national level, the Buckeyes are now showing they can do it at running back too, and that matters in a class sitting No. 5 overall. The bigger question now is whether this early surge is the start of something even more significant for Locklyns room. [Read more 🡒]