The Buckeyes are spending the week trying to solve a quarterback problem they never wanted, and the question at the center of it is a tricky one: could Luke Fahey actually be the safer backup even if he isn’t the better long-term starter?
Ohio State is trying to keep a National Championship push alive while turning to a reserve under center after the Julian Sayin injury. And with Sayin out, Fox’s Joel Klatt floated a viewpoint that gives this competition a different shape.
Fahey, a freshman, has been the first quarterback off the bench all season. That was the move again when Sayin exited the game against Indiana on Saturday, and Fahey’s role was simple: keep things moving and help Ohio State stay in front. He didn’t light up the box score, but he did help keep the train on the track.
The choice wasn’t shocking because Fahey had already been the next man up throughout the year. Still, it came with some surprise attached because of the buzz around Tavien St. Clair and the expectations that have followed him.
Klatt said that when he talks with coaches before kickoff, the key backup question usually comes down to this: is the second quarterback good enough to run the offense and steady the team, or is he simply the best player available?
That may be exactly what Ohio State is sorting out this week. The Buckeyes are trying to figure out whether Fahey is the cleanest option right now, or whether St. Clair gives them the better answer going forward.
Whoever wins the job, the assignment is straightforward. Ohio State doesn’t need fireworks.
With the defense playing well enough, the Buckeyes don’t have to chase 30 points a game. They need a quarterback who protects the ball, gets it to No. 4, and keeps the team in position.
The injury to Sayin is a major setback, and it landed at the worst possible time. Ohio State has dealt with adversity before, but this one figures to be a tougher road to the finish.
In Other News...
Ohio State's Running Back Board Is Nearing A Huge Recruiting Test
Ohio States work on the 2027 class is already starting to take shape at running back, where the Buckeyes have zeroed in on Jordan Hall and Tranard Roberts as priority targets with commitment decisions approaching. Both sit near the center of a recruiting push that has kept the staff active on the trail, and the position remains one of the key areas Ohio State is trying to firm up early in the cycle.
The board has not stopped there. The Buckeyes have also extended an offer to Kingston Allen, who is currently committed to Wisconsin, while continuing to stay involved with 2028 offensive lineman Ty Winn. With several choices on the horizon, the next stretch should give Ohio State a much clearer read on how its running back room might begin to come together. [Read more 🡒]
Ohio State's Off Week Just Brought Two Young Buckeyes A Big Step
Ohio States Week 8 off week is doing more than just giving the roster a chance to heal. It is also creating a little extra practice room for younger Buckeyes who have been waiting for more opportunities, and that setup produced a pair of notable milestones for two freshmen who have been grinding through the early part of the season.
Freshman tight end Nick Lautar and running back Favour Akih both had their black stripes removed, a tradition that marks a player earning his place in the program. It is the sort of small but meaningful step that can matter in a busy Ohio State season, and both players responded with gratitude toward the coaches and teammates around them after the announcement. [Read more 🡒]
Ohio States Offense Has A Post-Bye Concern Fans Cant Ignore
Ohio State reached the bye week with plenty to like about its overall position, but the offense has left enough questions behind to keep the conversation from drifting too far toward the positive. The numbers point to a unit that has leaned heavily on certain pieces while dealing with injury interruptions, especially around quarterback Julian Sayin and the broader health of the offensive line. Under offensive coordinator Arthur Smith, the Buckeyes have had to manage more than just game plans, with positional performance and availability shaping how reliable the group has looked from week to week.
The bigger concern is how much strain has landed on the rest of the pass-catching group. Jeremiah Smith has been the clear focal point, while the tight ends have not delivered the sort of consistency Ohio State would want from that room, and situational efficiency has not fully smoothed out the rough edges. As the Buckeyes look past the bye and toward the rest of the season, the lingering issue is whether the offense can get healthier and diversify enough to avoid becoming too dependent on a few key contributors. [Read more 🡒]