Ohio State’s defense came into 2026 with one unavoidable reality hanging over it: a drop-off was coming. Replacing the kind of talent the Buckeyes lost is never simple, and players such as Caleb Downs, Arvell Reese and Sonny Styles do not come around often. Even so, this group has stayed close to the championship level, even with a few rough patches along the way.
The overall numbers tell a strong story. Ohio State is giving up 13.4 points per game, which is tied for fifth nationally and second in the Big Ten.
Its worst outing on that front came against Texas, when the Buckeyes allowed 24 points. On the other end of the spectrum, Ball State and Kent State each managed only 3.
The efficiency numbers are just as sharp. Ohio State is allowing 4.21 yards per play, good for third in the country and second in the conference.
Illinois produced the highest figure against the Buckeyes at 6.5 yards per play, while Kent State was held to 2.4. Against the run, Ohio State is surrendering 3.11 yards per carry, which ranks 19th nationally and fourth in the Big Ten.
The Buckeyes’ toughest day there came against Illinois at 6.0 yards per rush, while Iowa managed just 1.9.
The passing game has been where Ohio State has been most dominant. The Buckeyes are allowing only 5.2 yards per passing attempt, the best mark in college football. Indiana posted the high point against that defense at 7.4, while Maryland was held to 2.6.
On the situational side, opponents are converting 38.3% of third downs against Ohio State, a number that ranks 79th nationally and 14th in the Big Ten. Fourth-down defense has been much stronger: opponents have converted just 25% of their tries, which is 10th in the country and first in the Big Ten. In the red zone, opponents are scoring touchdowns on 50% of their trips, tying Ohio State for 33rd nationally and seventh in the conference.
The defensive line has looked like two different units depending on the month. In September, the Buckeyes were pushed around by their two power conference opponents.
The Illinois game in the Horseshoe stood out in particular, and Kenyatta Jackson called that performance “unacceptable.” It was nearly 100 degrees in Austin, but that context did not make the Texas game any easier to stomach.
October, though, has brought a major shift. Ohio State has held each of its last three opponents to 15 points or fewer on offense, and the front has played a major role in that turnaround against the run. The Buckeyes entered the Iowa game ranked 54th in the country in rushing defense, and since then they have climbed into the top 20 and are still moving in the right direction.
The bigger concern up front has been the pass rush. Ohio State has had trouble creating pressure with four linemen all season. The pressure has been more available when the Buckeyes bring help from the back seven, which leads directly to the linebacker group.
James Lauranitis needed a few weeks to settle on his best options, but the rotation is clear now. Payton Pierce, Christian Alliegro, Riley Pettijohn and TJ Alford have emerged as the four-man group, and each brings a different set of traits depending on the matchup.
None of them are Arvell Reese. None of them are Sonny Styles.
But all four are useful players in their own right.
The back end may be the best unit on the roster. The only real debate for that distinction is wide receiver, and that is because Jeremiah Smith exists. Otherwise, the case is simple: Ohio State has the best pass defense in the country even though the pass rush has not been carrying its share of the load.
That matters for corners such as Devin Sanchez, who often end up covering the opponent’s top target while also spending too long waiting for pressure that never arrives. That extra time makes life harder on the secondary, and it changes how those snaps look on the outside.
Jermaine Matthews has been the most important piece in that group because of his versatility and consistency. He flashed late last season, and that level of play has carried over into this year.
With Brian Hartline gone, Matt Guerrieri has become the coach I’d point to as the best position coach on the staff. Over his three seasons, Ohio State has had the best safety play in college football, period.
Caleb Downs deserves plenty of credit, but the proof keeps piling up with Lathan Ransom, Jordan Hancock, Jaylen McClain, Earl Little Jr. and Jay Timmons. Buckeye fans ought to appreciate what Guerrieri has built while they still have him.
Earl Little Jr. may not have the same impact as Caleb Downs, but he has done exactly what has been asked of him in this defense. Jaylen McClain has also raised his level and is finally getting more recognition for it after spending so much time in Downs’ shadow.
Then there is Jay Timmons, who has been the best freshman at OSU since Jeremiah Smith while playing nickel. Taken together, it adds up to the best secondary in the country, and that group may end up being the biggest reason Ohio State reaches its goals.
In Other News...
Ohio States Bye Week Boost Comes With A Serious New Concern
BYUs double-overtime loss to UCF shook up the AP Top 25 and opened the door for some movement near the top, but Ohio States bigger concern has little to do with the rankings. The Buckeyes are coming out of the bye week with questions attached to two key pieces of the offense, as injuries to quarterback Julian Sayin and running back JaKobi Jackson threaten to affect how much the team can lean on its usual rhythm.
Miami stayed at No. 1 after handling Pitt, while Ohio State is left sorting through the more immediate reality of how it will look in the games ahead. The Buckeyes have had enough stability to stay in the national conversation, but the timing of these injuries adds a real layer of uncertainty at a point in the season when every week starts to feel more consequential. [Read more 🡒]
BYU Faces A Complicated Ranking Drop After Costly Upset
Miami held onto the No. 1 spot in the AP college football rankings after a convincing win over Pittsburgh, with quarterback Darian Mensah and wide receiver Malachi Toney leading the way. The bigger shift, at least for the teams chasing the top, came from BYUs upset loss to unranked UCF in double overtime, a result that is expected to send the Cougars sliding after they had been sitting at No. 2.
For Ohio State, the ripple effect could be significant. The Buckeyes are projected to move up to No. 2 as pollsters reshuffle the upper tier after a chaotic weekend, with several top teams now under closer scrutiny depending on how they handled their latest tests. [Read more 🡒]
Ohio State Suddenly Faces A Season-Defining Test After Julian Sayin Injury
Julian Sayins injury has forced Ohio State into a different kind of stretch run, one that now hinges on how the Buckeyes handle a sudden change at quarterback. Luke Fahey is stepping in, and with the bye week arriving at a key moment, the staff has a little time to stabilize the offense and keep the season on track while the rest of the roster tries to carry the load.
There is still a path here for Ohio State to finish strong, make the College Football Playoff and stay in the national title conversation, but the margin for error is tighter now. The bigger picture also leaves room for long-term optimism, from Jeremiah Smiths Heisman-level ceiling to the idea that Sayin could eventually reclaim the job down the road, even if this season has already taken a sharp turn. [Read more 🡒]