Jeremiah Smith has already done enough at Ohio State to force his way into the Buckeyes’ wide receiver immortality debate.
That’s saying something in a program that has spent decades turning out elite pass catchers and can point to 14 first-round NFL Draft picks at the position, the most of any school ever. Ohio State fans have long argued over the receiver version of Mount Rushmore, usually circling the same familiar names: Cris Carter, David Boston, Chris Olave, Garrett Wilson and Marvin Harrison Jr.
Smith is crashing that party before even finishing his college career.
The case starts with the standards Ohio State wideouts are usually judged by: All-America recognition and first-round draft status. Those two markers separate the legends from the merely great, and Smith has already checked one of them twice.
He was a first-team All-American as a true freshman in 2024, then became a unanimous All-American in 2025. Among Buckeye receivers, only Harrison has matched back-to-back All-America honors, and Smith is the only one to do it in his first two seasons.
That kind of start is rare even by Ohio State standards. The Buckeyes have had 21 first-team All-Big Ten receivers since 1979, but only nine consensus first-team All-Americans. Smith is already one of them twice over, and he’s still got another season ahead of him.
The production backs up the awards. Through two seasons, Smith has 163 catches, 2,558 yards and 27 touchdowns, all already good for a spot in Ohio State’s career top ten.
He and Harrison are the only Buckeyes to put together back-to-back 1,000-yard receiving seasons, and Smith got there faster than anyone in school history. He was the fastest to 100 receptions, 1,000 yards, 1,500 yards and 25 touchdown catches.
He’s also on track to pass Emeka Egbuka’s school records for career receptions and receiving yards in 2026, and he’s closing in on Michael Jenkins’ all-time receiving yardage mark.
What makes that even more striking is how quickly he reached those milestones compared with the other names in the Buckeye receiver conversation. Carter, Boston, Olave and Harrison all built their résumés over more time. Smith has matched or exceeded their pace in a way that’s hard to ignore, even allowing for the fact that modern offenses throw the ball more than Ohio State teams of earlier eras ever did.
He also brings efficiency that stands out on its own. Through two seasons, his yards-per-target and catch rate are as strong as any receiver to wear scarlet and gray.
The one thing Smith hasn’t done yet is get drafted, and that matters because the classic Ohio State receiver résumé usually includes both All-America honors and a first-round NFL selection. He’s expected to enter the 2027 draft as one of the most hyped receiver prospects in recent memory, and some evaluators have already floated him as a candidate to become the first wide receiver taken No. 1 overall since Keyshawn Johnson in 1996. It’s also realistic to project him as a top-five pick, in the same range as Harrison and Tate.
Until that happens, the final box remains unchecked. It’s only a matter of time in the eyes of most observers, but technically it’s still open.
Even so, Smith already has enough on his résumé to belong in the discussion. Two All-America seasons, including a unanimous selection, put him in the same conversation as the best Ohio State receivers ever. Terry Glenn has long occupied that space on the strength of one dominant All-American season in 1995, and Smith has already surpassed that level of recognition.
If the standard is whether he has already met the criteria that define Ohio State’s greatest receivers, the answer is yes. If the standard is whether he has completed the full package - All-American and first-round pick - the answer is not yet, though that finish line appears close.
Barring injury or some other unexpected setback, Smith is on pace to leave Ohio State as the program’s all-time leader in every major receiving category, with multiple All-America honors and a top-five draft slot behind him. At that point, the argument won’t be whether he belongs on the mountain. It’ll be whether anyone else still does.
In Other News...
Which Ohio State 5-Star Could Matter First For The Buckeyes Defense
Ohio States 2027 recruiting class already has a star-heavy look, and the Buckeyes are expecting all three of their committed five-stars to get on the field early. Marcus Fakatou, DJ Jacobs and Jamier Brown each bring a different kind of upside, but the conversation around immediate help on defense naturally starts with the players who can fill the most urgent needs.
Jacobs, an edge defender with the kind of frame and burst that make him an obvious pass-rush candidate, appears best positioned to matter first. He and Fakatou both line up at spots where depth is thinner, which gives them a clearer path to meaningful snaps once they arrive, and it is easy to see why Ohio State would want that kind of athleticism ready sooner rather than later. [Read more 🡒]
Ohio State Offense Is Already Being Framed As USCs Biggest Test
The buildup to Ohio States trip to the Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum already has the feel of a measuring-stick game, even before the calendar flips to Oct. 31. It will be the first time the Buckeyes and USC meet as Big Ten opponents, and the spotlight naturally falls on an Ohio State offense that brings back Julian Sayin at quarterback, Bo Jackson in the backfield and Jeremiah Smith out wide, a trio that gives the Buckeyes the kind of firepower most opponents spend all week trying to contain.
USC has made its own defensive changes, bringing in Gary Patterson, but the Trojans still have a demanding run of games ahead before Ohio State arrives. The Buckeyes, meanwhile, are also adjusting to new voices on their staff with Matt Patricia taking over as defensive coordinator and Arthur Smith as offensive coordinator, which only adds another layer to a matchup that already looks like one of the early tests of the Big Ten season. [Read more 🡒]