How Ohio States New Punter Reached The Game From Melbourne

Joe McGuire's unexpected path from Melbourne to Ohio State highlights a remarkable journey marked by cultural adjustments, athletic achievements, and the fierce rivalry known simply as "The Game."

When Joe McGuire first got the nod as Ohio State’s starting punter, it was a debut in more ways than one. The sophomore from Melbourne, Australia wasn’t just stepping into his first role with the Buckeyes - he was playing in his first American football game, period.

That kind of leap can feel impossible from the outside. For McGuire, it started with ProKick Australia, the kicking and punting academy that has produced six of the NFL’s 32 current starting punters. He arrived there in 2021 and quickly found himself around a group of future college specialists, including Cameron Peasley, James Burnip and Brett Thorson.

At that first tryout, McGuire said he felt like the outlier.

“Three massive legs, and I’m just this sort of skinny, scrawny little kid who’s come in, not knowing too much what to expect, not even knowing it was a tryout, and seeing these guys kick bombs,” he said.

ProKick gave him the technical foundation and the routine that would eventually carry him to Columbus. McGuire said the academy taught him the details that matter behind the scenes - training, nutrition, lifting and the punting craft itself.

“They’ll teach you how to lift, what sort of lifts to do, how strict some coaches can be, what the routine might look like,” he said. “They’ll teach you nutrition, but most importantly, they teach you how to kick and refine your technique from Australian rules kicking.”

Ohio State came calling after two years with ProKick, and McGuire earned a walk-on spot in 2023.

“Eventually Ohio State sort of reached out to ProKick, and they put my name forward and sent the film, and Ohio State liked it enough, thankfully, to bring me over,” McGuire said.

Once he got to Columbus, the rivalry education came fast. McGuire said former Ohio State punter Jesse Mirco was the one who first explained the Buckeyes’ hatred for Michigan, and the lesson came after McGuire made the mistake of wearing blue shorts inside the Woody Hayes Athletic Facility.

“What are you doing?’ Mirco asked incredulously.

‘You’re wearing blue?”“ I said, ‘Oh, yeah,’ and he’s like, ‘You can’t’” McGuire recalled.

“As a result, I really don’t have much blue in my closet.”

McGuire said the scale of “The Game” is still hard to fully explain back home in Australia.

“They definitely understand it’s a big thing and it’s significant for sure,” McGuire said. “But until you actually come and experience it, it’s just tough to really understand. Even for me, I was living and breathing it, but until I moved here, I didn’t know exactly the magnitude of it.”

The adjustment wasn’t only about football. McGuire also had to get used to being far from family, with trips home limited to two or three weeks each year. He said Mirco and Cameron Johnston, Ohio State’s punter from 2013-2016 and now with the Pittsburgh Steelers, helped him settle in.

“They sort of taught me what to do, what not to do, where to go, all that sort of thing,” McGuire said.

Another Australian punter, Nick McLarty, later joined the Buckeyes after Mirco graduated. McLarty transferred to Arizona State in January after two seasons at Ohio State, but he said McGuire made the transition easier even while they battled for the job.

“The whole time while [I was] there we had a pretty fierce competition punting-wise,” McLarty said. “But off the field, he was a really good bloke, someone that I could really count on.”

McGuire’s next reminder of home will come Nov. 18, when Ohio State faces Michigan and he lines up against Cam Brown, another ProKick Australia alum who transferred from UNLV to the Wolverines in January.

“I did send him a message when he committed to [the] team up north, and I sort of said ‘good luck mate, but I hope your team comes second’ [that] sort of thing,” McGuire said.

McGuire has now played in Ohio State’s last 39 games, a stretch that includes a national championship in 2024 and both a win and a loss against Michigan. Even with all that, he said the Buckeyes still mean more than any spotlight he might get elsewhere.

His father, Eddie, hosted the Australian version of “Who Wants to Be a Millionaire?” and McGuire said that gives him a different kind of recognition at home.

“It’s funny I’m less in the spotlight here than back home just because of who he is,” McGuire said.

Still, the football part has taken on a life of its own. McGuire said he barely understood college football a decade ago, let alone the idea of wearing an Ohio State uniform.

“Seven or eight years ago, I would barely ever know what college football really was,” McGuire said. “I knew it was a thing, but I didn’t know the scale of it or anything. If you told me 10 years ago that I’d be playing here, I’d think you’re crazy, absolutely crazy.”

And when it comes to Michigan, he doesn’t hide how he feels.

“I genuinely hate ‘em,” McGuire said of Michigan.

In Other News...

Ohio State Just Lost A Huge Piece Of Its Offense Down The Stretch

Ohio States backfield took a major hit down the stretch when Ryan Day confirmed that running back JaKobi Jackson will miss the rest of the season with a foot injury. Jackson had become one of the Buckeyes more reliable offensive pieces, piling up 354 yards and six touchdowns on 59 carries while giving the offense a steady presence on the ground.

With Jackson out, the pressure shifts to the rest of the running back room to help stabilize a rushing attack that will be especially important for freshman quarterback Luke Fahey. Ohio State does not have much margin for error in the weeks ahead, and replacing Jacksons production and consistency is now one of the biggest tasks facing the offense. [Read more 🡒]

Ohio State Gets A Rare Late-Season Opening It Has To Exploit

Week 12 brings a strange kind of calm to the college football calendar, with no AP Top 25 matchups on the slate for the first time in November since 2009. For Ohio State, the timing is useful in a way the Buckeyes can appreciate, because a lighter national schedule puts even more attention on their trip to Nebraska and the chance to keep stacking wins while the rest of the sport sorts itself out around them.

There are still plenty of games with playoff consequences elsewhere, including Texas Tech at Baylor and Notre Dame hosting SMU, but Ohio States path is simpler: handle business and let the rankings conversation take care of itself. With the weekend spread across the usual TV windows and networks, the Buckeyes have a rare late-season opening to make a clean statement, and in a month like November, those are the opportunities teams are expected to seize. [Read more 🡒]

Ohio State Recruiting Momentum Just Created Another Big Reason For Hope

A win over Northwestern kept Ohio State at 7-3 and still sitting at No. 16 in the AP Polls, which is enough to keep the Buckeyes College Football Playoff conversation alive for another week. But even with the on-field picture still carrying its share of uncertainty, there was another encouraging development for the program as it continued to build out its future roster.

Ohio State picked up a flip from four-star running back Nigel Newkirk, pulling him away from Alabama, and also landed among the top five for four-star cornerback Jai'lil Goley. The Buckeyes' 2027 class is already ranked No. 5 by 247Sports, with top edge prospects DJ Jacobs and Wyatt Smith helping drive the early momentum, even if there is still some uncertainty around Jacobs' commitment. [Read more 🡒]