Curt Cignetti Just Reopened A Painful Ohio State What-If

Curt Cignetti defends Indiana's accomplishments and argues for their rightful place in college football's elite, despite a tough loss to Ohio State.

Curt Cignetti didn’t hold back when asked about Indiana’s College Football Playoff case, and he used Ohio State as the clearest example of why he thinks the Hoosiers deserve more respect.

Speaking in Columbus, Ohio, the Indiana coach pushed back on the idea that his team’s 2026 résumé has been inflated by a soft schedule. Since arriving in 2024, Cignetti has guided IU to a 36-3 record, back-to-back CFP trips, a 16-0 national title season in 2025 and a 21-game winning streak that Ohio State ended with a 19-15 win in October.

Cignetti pointed to that game as proof that Indiana can stand with anyone.

“We play Ohio State, who everybody picked to win the national championship this year,” Cignetti said. “We’re 5-0, they’re 5-1.

You saw what happened. We knocked the quarterback out.”

Ohio State did win the game, but the Buckeyes lost quarterback Julian Sayin to a season-ending injury to his throwing arm on a sack in the third quarter. Since then, the season has gone sideways for OSU, with losses to USC and Oregon while true freshman Luke Fahey has been forced into the quarterback job.

What was once viewed as a national title contender now has no control over its postseason path.

“We ripped the heart out of that team,” Cignetti said. “They haven’t been the same since without the quarterback.

But all I hear about is how we lost to a three-loss team. That was a team picked to win the national championship and led Texas 95% of the game, at Texas.”

Cignetti also framed Indiana’s loss as a missed chance rather than a sign the Hoosiers don’t belong in the conversation. He said the game was there for the taking, with Hoosiers receiver Nick Marsh failing to stay inbounds on a potential game-winning 27-yard touchdown catch.

“We missed a layup and you know what, they won and we didn’t,” Cignetti said. “But we missed a layup.

That’s why we’re not 26-0. We’re 25-1 (the past two seasons).”

The comments came during an almost three-minute rant from Cignetti about how Indiana - and often the Big Ten - is viewed nationally compared with the SEC, which has nine teams in the CFP rankings, more than any other conference.

“You get tired of the narratives sometimes,” Cignetti said.

In Other News...

Ohio State May Have A Real Tavien St. Clair Problem Now

Julian Sayins injury forced Ohio State to turn to true freshman Luke Fahey against Northwestern, and the Buckeyes got a win out of it. But the bigger ripple may be what it says about the quarterback room behind him, where Tavien St. Clair was passed over for the start and suddenly finds himself in an awkward spot for a sophomore who was supposed to be part of the future.

For Ohio State, this is where the depth chart starts to matter beyond one game. Lincoln Kienholz left for Louisville and has already found success there, which only sharpens the question around St. Clair: does he stay and keep waiting for a path, or look elsewhere for one? The Buckeyes can survive one injury, but the longer the pecking order stays unsettled, the harder it gets to keep every quarterback on board. [Read more 🡒]

Ohio States Ranking Jump Keeps A Bigger Goal In Play

Ohio States 28-19 win over Northwestern did more than get the Buckeyes back in the win column. It also nudged them up to No. 17 in the USA Today Coaches Poll, a small but meaningful move as the seasons bigger picture keeps taking shape around them. Georgia stayed at No. 1 with 58 first-place votes, and the Big Ten now has six teams in the top 25, a reminder of how crowded the conference race remains.

For Ohio State, the ranking bump matters because it keeps a larger goal within reach as the calendar turns and every result starts to carry more weight. The Associated Press will wait until Monday to release its Top 25 because of a schedule change in another game, so the Buckeyes will have to sit with this latest rise a little longer before the next round of movement arrives. [Read more 🡒]

Ohio State Has A New Officiating Fight Fans Wont Ignore

The replay booth became part of the conversation again in Ohio States game against Northwestern, this time over a catch by Jeremiah Smith that was initially ruled incomplete before being overturned after review. It was the kind of sequence that can linger long after the final whistle, especially when a high-profile play swings on a judgment call and leaves fans and commentators arguing over what they saw.

Ryan Day didnt feed the backlash after the game, instead defending Smiths performance and standing by the result of the review. But the debate around the call has already moved beyond one snap, with some around the sport pressing the Big Ten for more accountability whenever a ruling like this becomes the center of attention. [Read more 🡒]