Josh Pate’s preseason Big Ten quarterback rankings didn’t sit well with Todd McShay, and the reaction came fast and direct.
The biggest flashpoint was the gap between UCLA’s Nico Iamaleava and Michigan’s Bryce Underwood. Pate slotted Iamaleava at No. 10 and Underwood at No. 5, and McShay thought that spread was too wide to make sense.
“With all due respect, Nico at 10 with Bryce at 5 is bordering on criminal,” McShay wrote. “But to each their own. And FYI, I'm out west, so this isn't some weird 1:42 a.m. post.”
Pate’s response made the logic behind the list clearer. He wasn’t ranking the quarterbacks purely on what they’ve already done. He was projecting forward.
“Based on resume thus far, true,” Pate replied. “This is what I expect this year. As we all know, there's no crime in expectation.”
That distinction matters here. Pate’s list leans into what he thinks these quarterbacks will become in 2026, not just where their college careers stand right now. McShay, by contrast, seemed to value the more proven player and the cleaner evaluation of current ability.
At the top of Pate’s list were Ohio State’s Julian Sayin, Oregon’s Dante Moore and USC’s Jayden Maiava. After that, there’s a noticeable drop, and the next group - Indiana’s Josh Hoover, Underwood, Penn State’s Rocco Becht and Washington’s Demond Williams - can be shuffled in different ways.
Iamaleava’s ranking is the one that really invites debate, because his recent path has been bumpy. After the 2024 season, he led Tennessee to a 10-3 record and the College Football Playoff, throwing for 2,616 yards and 19 touchdowns. Then came a split with the Vols amid reported NIL negotiations.
Iamaleava later said going back home to California was the main reason and called other versions of events “false reports.”
His first season at UCLA didn’t give him much of a lift. The Bruins opened 0-3, fired coach DeShaun Foster and finished 3-9. Iamaleava threw for 1,928 yards with 13 touchdowns and 7 interceptions in 11 games.
Even so, there were still signs of why he remains such a tricky player to place. He completed 64.4% of his passes, led UCLA with 505 rushing yards and four rushing scores, and was responsible for five touchdowns in a 42-37 upset of No. 7 Penn State.
The Bruins have made changes around him, too. They hired Bob Chesney away from James Madison this offseason, and former NFL quarterback Derek Carr recently joined the staff as a special advisor. Carr, who also grew up in California, is set to help guide the 21-year-old quarterback.
Underwood’s case is different, but it also fits the same broad argument about projection versus production. The true freshman started all 13 games for Michigan, passed for 2,428 yards and added 392 rushing yards and six touchdowns. His 11 touchdown passes and nine interceptions show there’s still plenty to clean up, but handling that kind of load at Michigan mattered.
That’s really the heart of the disagreement: Pate is betting on the future, while McShay is pushing back on how far apart the two quarterbacks should be based on what’s already been shown. Underwood may be the better 2026 play, but Iamaleava still has enough talent to make that No. 10 spot look aggressive.
In Other News...
Ohio States Quarterback Pipeline Looks Dangerous For Years To Come
Christopher Vargas commitment gives Ohio State another layer to its quarterback picture, and it only adds to a room that already includes Julian Sayin and Tavien St. Clair. With Sayin expected to finish this season and St. Clair projected to follow for another year or two, the Buckeyes now have the kind of depth that lets them think about succession far beyond one recruiting cycle.
Vargas brings a different style and skill set than the quarterbacks already in place, which is part of what makes the whole setup so intriguing for Ohio State. If the pieces line up the way the Buckeyes hope, they could keep a five-star-caliber quarterback at the center of the offense for years, with each passer bringing something a little different before the next one takes over. [Read more 🡒]
Jalen McCuin Is Giving Ohio State Fans A New Reason To Watch
Early fall camp is giving Ohio State a better sense of what its receiving room might look like beyond Jeremiah Smith, and Jalen McCuin has quickly become part of that conversation. The transfer has drawn notice for the way he has settled in and positioned himself as a player worth watching as the Buckeyes sort out who can handle a larger workload once the season begins.
McCuins rise matters because Ohio State is not just looking for bodies at the position, it is looking for reliable separation behind its top target. The early impression around camp is that he has put himself in the mix for a meaningful role, which adds another layer to a receiver battle that already has plenty at stake for players trying to earn trust before the real games arrive. [Read more 🡒]
Ohio State Freshman Is Suddenly Changing The Buckeyes Secondary Battle
Ohio States secondary has been one of the cleaner little battles to watch in fall camp, and freshman cornerback Jay Timmons has quickly forced his way into the conversation. The Buckeyes have given him plenty of work at the nickel spot, and the early returns have been strong enough to get the attention of both teammates and coaches as the team sorts through roles before the season begins.
Timmons rise matters because nickel is one of those spots where trust can matter as much as talent, and a freshman suddenly pushing for meaningful snaps changes the shape of the depth chart. If his camp momentum keeps building, Ohio State may have to make some difficult decisions about how it wants to divide playing time among the rest of its defensive backs. [Read more 🡒]