Kyle Teel’s latest injury has put the White Sox right back in a familiar spot: staring at a catcher situation that suddenly feels shaky again.
Teel went down last night on a play at the plate, and the scene was an uneasy one. His cleat appeared to catch in the dirt, and it looked like he turned his left ankle.
He stayed down for a while, and when he finally got to his feet, he could not put any weight on that side. The severity still isn’t known, but there’s enough here to make Chicago plan for the possibility that this is a long-term issue.
That matters because the White Sox haven’t gotten much at the plate from their catching group this season. Teel, Edgar Quero, Drew Romo and Reese McGuire have all been part of a unit that has struggled offensively. If this turns out to be a short-term absence and Teel avoids the injured list, Chicago could simply lean on Romo and Quero, with Quero having been recalled Monday night after the fallout.
But if the injury keeps Teel out for a while, the White Sox will need to look outside the organization. Pitching remains the bigger need, but if Chicago can land a pitcher and a catcher from the same club, that would be the ideal setup.
Hunter Goodman of the Colorado Rockies and Adley Rutschman of the Baltimore Orioles would be the dream names, but both are probably beyond Chris Getz’s price range. That leaves the White Sox searching for more realistic trade deadline options.
One name to keep on the radar is Ryan Jeffers of the Minnesota Twins. The Twins took him in the second round of the 2018 MLB Draft out of North Carolina, and he reached the majors in 2020.
Over his career, Jeffers has hit .243/.328/.429 with 76 home runs. That’s solid production for a catcher, and it would be a clear upgrade over what Chicago has gotten internally.
Jeffers has been even better this season when healthy. A broken hamate bone sidelined him for a couple of months, but in 42 games he has posted 2.0 bWAR and hit .288/.401/.540 with eight home runs.
That slash line is a career best. He’s also set to become a free agent after the season, which could make him easier to pry away.
If the White Sox could get him and starter Joe Ryan together, that would be even better. And with divisional trades becoming more common, this is not a move to dismiss.
Luis Torrens is another possibility. He’s been around for nine seasons with the Padres, Mariners, Cubs and Mets, and while his bat has never been the selling point - his career line is .226/.288/.350 - his defense is elite. Baseball Savant has his framing, pop time and CS above average in the 90th percentile or better.
That kind of glove would stand out for a White Sox team that has gotten little from Quero and Romo behind the plate. The downside is obvious: he doesn’t bring much offense.
Still, he would be a major defensive upgrade. This kind of deal would likely be tied to the White Sox pursuing Mets starter Clay Holmes, a pitcher the team has reportedly shown interest in.
Torrens is signed through 2028.
Then there’s Jonah Heim, the only All-Star and Gold Glove winner in the group. He earned both honors in 2023 with the Rangers after hitting 18 home runs and posting a .755 OPS. Now with the Athletics, Heim is backing up Shea Langeliers, which makes him available if the A’s are willing to move him.
In 42 games this season, Heim has hit .230/.275/.439 with eight home runs. If he can rediscover the version of himself he showed in Texas, he could be the kind of swing that pays off. He’s also a free agent after this season.
With the White Sox’s backup catching production so thin, the front office has to at least explore these kinds of options. Even if Teel makes it back before the season ends, adding a dependable catcher could matter a lot if Chicago wants to make a real push toward the postseason.
In Other News...
As Forced Into Another Painful Roster Shakeup After Brutal Injury Night
The Athletics were forced into another roster reset Friday, placing right-hander Mark Leiter on the 15-day injured list with a right hip impingement and infielder Joshua Kuroda-Grauer on the 10-day injured list. Leiters move comes retroactive to July 19, while Kuroda-Grauers absence leaves Oakland juggling the infield after a rough night that added more strain to an already thin roster.
To fill the openings, the As recalled right-hander Hayden Juenger and infielder Max Muncy from Triple-A Las Vegas. Juenger, a recent trade pickup, gives Oakland another arm to lean on, while Muncy is back for another stint after being optioned earlier in the month, a reminder of how quickly the club has had to keep shuffling pieces just to stay afloat. [Read more 🡒]
Another A's IL Move Leaves This Thin Roster In A Tough Spot
The Athletics roster took another hit Monday when right-hander Mark Leiter Jr. landed on the 15-day injured list with a right hip impingement, a reminder of how little margin this club has as it tries to patch together pitching depth. Infielder Joshua Kuroda-Grauer also went on the 10-day IL after surgery, leaving Oakland to turn once again to the next wave of reinforcements.
Hayden Juenger and Max Muncy were recalled in the corresponding moves, but the bigger concern is how quickly these absences can stack up for a team already leaning on limited options. Leiters injury comes at an awkward time, too, with the right-handers availability and value becoming part of the backdrop as the deadline approaches and the As keep trying to hold the roster together. [Read more 🡒]