As Opening Day approaches for the Athletics, the team is on the brink of some pivotal decisions. With just two weeks left, manager Mark Kotsay has his work cut out for him. From selecting the starting third baseman-where Max Muncy seems to have the edge-to finalizing the rotation, bullpen, and bench spots, every choice matters.
A key decision revolves around right fielder Lawrence Butler. After a breakout second half in 2024, where he hit .300/.345/.553 with 13 homers in just 61 games, Butler earned himself an extension alongside Brent Rooker.
However, his first season under the new deal didn’t meet expectations, as his performance dipped across the board. It was later revealed that Butler played through a torn patellar tendon in his right knee, which likely impacted his stats, particularly in the second half.
The hope is that Butler's injury was the root cause of his 2025 regression. Expectations remain high for him as he enters his third full season.
While he hasn’t seen spring action yet, Kotsay assures that Butler is getting his swings in, working in the cage and against minor leaguers. Butler himself feels confident about his progress, stating, “I feel great at the plate.”
The next step is for Butler to get back on the field. The plan is to ease him into game action soon, though whether he’ll play the outfield or serve as a designated hitter remains to be seen.
With Rooker likely occupying the DH spot, Butler needs to be ready defensively to avoid starting the season on the injured list. If not, he might need to strengthen his knee and get some reps in Triple-A.
Should Butler miss the start of the season, the A’s have a few options. Colby Thomas, despite a tough spring, could see time in right field.
Carlos Cortes, fresh off playing for Team Puerto Rico, might also be in the mix, especially against right-handers like Toronto’s Dylan Cease. Jeff McNeil, primarily brought in for second base, has outfield experience, but the A’s are unlikely to move him.
Another option could be Andy Ibanez, though his experience in right field is limited.
If the A’s decide to take a bold step, they might call up top prospect Henry Bolte. The 22-year-old has impressed in camp, showcasing speed and potential at the plate.
While not a direct replacement for Butler’s power, Bolte’s agility could offer a different dynamic. However, with only 34 Triple-A games under his belt, more seasoning might be wise.
The Athletics face a crucial decision in right field. Will Butler make a surprising return for Opening Day, or will the team rely on a temporary solution until he's ready?
Or perhaps they’ll give a promising prospect a shot. The coming days will reveal much about the A’s strategy as they gear up for the season.
Feel free to share your thoughts on how you see the right field situation unfolding. Will Butler defy the odds, or is a Plan B in the cards? Let the debate begin!