The Athletics still have a mathematical route to the playoffs, but it runs through a gauntlet so extreme it borders on fantasy.
They’ve won four straight, and that tiny spark is the only reason this conversation even exists. From here, the A’s would need to keep stacking wins - a whole lot of them - to have any real shot at sneaking into the postseason. The math is brutal: they’d need 23 straight victories, counting the current four-game run, to finish 76-86 and stay alive in the race.
That would mean sweeping the Blue Jays, Mariners, Rays, Guardians, Angels, and Astros. It would also mean asking for 19 more wins after the current streak, a run that would break baseball history.
And that’s before even getting to the injured-list firepower the Athletics are missing. One loss, in this setup, would make the climb even steeper.
Toronto is the key obstacle. The Blue Jays are tied with Cleveland for the final A.L.
Wild Card spot, and if they keep winning, the Athletics are basically finished. The two clubs meet in a three-game set after the final game of the Mariners series, and that matchup could decide everything.
Before that can matter, though, the Athletics would have to win the series finale against Seattle and then sweep the Blue Jays.
If that somehow happened, Toronto would still need to stumble badly, finishing 3-16 to land at 75-87. Cleveland is in the same neighborhood at 72-71, which means the Guardians would also have to collapse to 75-87, with three of those losses coming against the Athletics in the Sept. 18-20 series.
Texas is another problem. The Rangers are in the mix at 70-73, and unlike the Blue Jays and Guardians, they don’t face the Athletics to close the season.
That removes any chance for Oakland to directly damage their record. For the A’s to finish ahead of them, Texas would need to lose at least 14 of its final 19 games.
If you’re hoping for the miracle path, that’s another team to root against.
There are still a few more clubs in the way, even if their required downfalls look a little more believable. The Orioles would need to go 6-13, the Twins 7-13, and the Mariners 9-10 for the Athletics to jump them.
And because these teams overlap so much, the results of their head-to-head matchups matter just as much as Oakland’s own games. The biggest non-Athletics series to watch are the final two between the Orioles and Blue Jays.
The ideal outcomes there would be 2-1 and 3-0, since those six games could supply five of Toronto’s needed 16 losses. Add an Athletics sweep, and half the job is done.
Cleveland’s path gets judged the same way. The Guardians would need to drop two of three against both the Orioles and the Twins, with Baltimore and Minnesota taking the series.
There’s also the Toronto-Texas series, and that one needs to break in a very specific way. The Rangers would need to win it 2-1, since the Athletics can live with a Texas series win far more easily than another Blue Jays victory.
So yes, there is a path. It just asks for a miracle every night for the rest of the way. If every one of those results broke the Athletics’ way over the final 134 games involving Wild Card contenders, the A’s would probably deserve a second movie.
In Other News...
As Young Core Is Creating A Tough Long-Term Decision
Young cores can be a blessing and a headache, and the Athletics are getting a dose of both as they sort through the long view on their roster. The same volatility that can make a player look like a breakout one month and a question mark the next is showing up in real time, with names like Lawrence Butler and Zack Gelof sitting at the center of the conversation for Oakland as it tries to map out who belongs in the next wave.
Butlers uneven path has still included signs of real growth, while Gelofs value has come with a different kind of profile as the As evaluate how much flexibility and upside they can count on moving forward. For a team that has to balance patience with certainty, the challenge is less about whether these players can help and more about how much stability they can offer in roles that are still being defined. [Read more 🡒]
Bolte Gave The As A Rickey Henderson Feeling Again
A fast, opportunistic night at the ballpark gave the Athletics a reminder of what their speed can look like when it takes over a game. Against the Blue Jays, Bolte was in the middle of everything, swiping three bases in the first three innings and adding a solo home run to help fuel a 6-5 walk-off win that had a little bit of old-school As flavor to it.
The performance fit the kind of game Oakland rarely gets to revisit, with baserunning pressure showing up early and often. Boltes blend of power and speed stood out on its own, but the bigger picture was the way the As kept forcing the issue on the bases, creating an inning-by-inning urgency that has not shown up this dramatically in years. [Read more 🡒]
Athletics Can Still Make Things Miserable For A Desperate Blue Jays Team
The Athletics are long out of the playoff race, but they still have plenty of leverage over teams that are trying to survive it, and Toronto is one of them. Oaklands offense has struggled to put enough balls in play with authority, and the bullpen has been a work in progress, but there is still a little spoiler value left in a team that can make a contender work for everything. Mark Kotsay will have to navigate the series with that in mind, because even a club with little left to play for can alter the mood of a desperate October chase.
The opening game sets up as a test of whether Oakland can scratch together enough early offense to avoid falling behind quickly, especially with Jacob Lopez lined up against Dylan Cease. The As do not need to be perfect to matter here, only stubborn enough to keep Toronto uncomfortable and force the Blue Jays into a game they would rather not play. If Oakland can find a way to get a better start than it has in recent series openers, the rest of the matchup starts to look a lot less routine for a team still trying to hold onto its postseason position. [Read more 🡒]