The Arizona Fall League is almost done, and the Athletics’ group with the Mesa Solar Sox has already given the organization a pretty clear snapshot of where a few prospects stand heading into the winter.
With two games left before the playoffs, the A’s are looking at a short finish in the abbreviated mini-season. They sent seven players to Mesa this year - four pitchers, two catchers and an outfielder - and four of those seven rank among the club’s top 30 prospects.
The headliner is Breyson Guedez, the 19-year-old outfielder who is already the third-best outfield prospect in the system. Guedez reached High-A this season in his first year in pro ball, and even at that age there’s still plenty of room for his career to take shape.
The expectation is that he won’t be driven by big power or speed, but the bat is the draw, and the Fall League has given him the extra reps he needed. The numbers haven’t followed yet, though.
He’s hitting just .164/.271/.213 with no home runs, no stolen bases and an 18-to-7 K-to-BB ratio.
The catching side of the group has been more encouraging. Davis Diaz, a top-20 prospect, looks close to the majors after moving from High-A to the Aviators last year.
He’s 23, so the power ceiling probably isn’t going to change much, but he has continued to show a strong eye at the plate. In recent weeks, he has walked nearly as much as he has walked while hitting .271/.400/.391 with one home run.
He’s also positionally flexible, which only helps his case for next season.
Cole Conn, ranked No. 21 by MLB Pipelin, has been quieter in terms of playing time but has made the most of his chances. In nine games, he has four doubles and no homers, plus an 8-to-6 K-to-BB ratio and four stolen bases.
That speed stands out for a catcher. Conn also crushed Triple-A pitching at the end of last year, and that could give him an edge over Diaz on the organizational depth chart.
The pitching group has been a mix of breakout looks and rough outings. Kenya Huggins has been the best of the bunch by a wide margin, throwing 10 1/3 innings of relief and giving up only two runs while striking out 13. The right-hander came over from the Reds in exchange for half a season of Miguel Andujar, and right now that looks like a strong return, even if his long-term role is still unsettled.
Jared Johnson, another right-hander, has worked seven games and allowed six earned runs. There doesn’t appear to be much upside there, but he did pitch for the Aviators last year and could still serve as organizational depth next season.
Jay Dill, a recent 18th-round pick, spent most of last year at Double-A and had uneven results there. That pattern has continued in Arizona, where he has given up seven earned runs in just 5 1/3 innings.
Tucker Novotny, the lone lefty in the group, has also made a case for attention. The 23-year-old has made three starts and five total appearances, allowing five earned runs in 13 12/3 innings while striking out 16.
The walks have been a problem, but the strikeout production is real. Another 18th-rounder, Novotny only reached High-A last year, so he still has a long climb ahead before he becomes a big league option.
Overall, it’s been uneven work for the A’s in the Fall League, but not without some encouraging signs. The two catchers look like the clearest candidates to reach the majors soon, especially if the club decides to move Shea Langeliers.
The A’s still need a backup catcher right now, too. Could one of them break camp as Bangeliers’ backup?
This AFL made that a real possibility.
In Other News...
As Could Face A Defining Offseason For Their Young Core
The Athletics young core is starting to give the front office something real to build around, and this winter could tell a lot about how aggressively the club wants to lock that group in. Oakland has a track record of extending players after early success, and with new general manager Cam Castro now in place, theres at least a sense that the organization may look to keep emerging talent from getting too expensive too quickly.
Theres also a practical baseball reason to act sooner rather than later. The As still need help on the pitching side, and veteran additions could be part of the plan to steady a rotation that needs more depth around its younger arms. For a team trying to turn promise into a sustainable core, the next few months could shape not just the roster, but the timeline. [Read more 🡒]