Taylor Smith’s search for a quality starting pitcher is shaping up as one of the trickier parts of the A’s plan.
It’s easy enough to explain the problem. The club doesn’t want to break up its position-player core, and it also doesn’t have endless money to chase free agents who likely aren’t lining up to come to West Sacramento first. That leaves a familiar reality for a smaller-budget team: starting pitching is expensive, and everybody wants it.
So where does that leave the A’s if they want to add a starter while roughly 37 other teams are trying to do the same thing? One path is the free-agent route, with names like Clay Holmes floating around because his extreme ground-ball approach would fit well. But there’s also the possibility that the A’s will look for a trade target with enough warts to make him available and enough stuff to make him worth the gamble.
Two names stand out as potential “out of the box” fits.
Brayan Bello is one of them, and the case for him starts with a simple connection: he’s with the Red Sox, and Smith has a working relationship with his former club. That has already shown up in Smith’s first deal, a minor move that brought in the versatile defender and speedster Nate Eaton.
Bello’s 2026 season got ugly fast. His first half produced a 6.06 ERA, along with 11 HR and a rough 80 hits in 65.1 IP, and he pitched his way out of the rotation. But the second half looked very different once he moved to the bullpen, where he settled in and posted a 2.12 ERA in 51 IP while allowing just 1 HR.
There are reasons he could appeal to the A’s as a hidden treasure. His career fastball velocity sits at 95.7 MPH, and it was 95.8 MPH in 2026, while his slider and plus changeup give him the kind of arsenal that has long pointed to front-of-the-rotation upside when everything clicks.
He also brings a heavy sinker and a career ground-ball rate of 52.6%, which makes him a natural fit for the A’s right now and probably in Las Vegas, too. Add in the contract - $49.5M over 4 years from 2026-29, plus a $1M buyout for 2030 - and the acquisition cost in prospect or player capital should be relatively modest.
If he becomes a solid mid-rotation starter, that deal looks like a bargain at around $12M per year. Even if he ends up as a high-end reliever, he still has value.
Drew Rasmussen is the bigger swing. He’s a true #1 SP when healthy, the kind of arm the A’s would love to land if the opportunity somehow opened up.
Under normal circumstances, he’d be well out of range. But circumstances have pushed him into the conversation.
There has been significant buzz that the Rays may move him because his 2027 salary jumped to $20M when several incentives kicked in, and he’s under contract for only one more season. Tampa Bay tends to operate with the kind of hard-edged business logic that Billy Beane’s A’s once became known for, and the thinking, according to pundits who claim to be in the know, is that they may try to cash in on Rasmussen’s value.
The A’s also have something going for them in a trade scenario that they don’t have in free agency: a real chance to get a deal done without being pushed to the margins of a bidding war. The clubs have already made trades recently, with Jeffrey Springs and Jacob Lopez coming to the A’s, and Tampa Bay is another team with whom Smith has history. If Oakland is the one making the offer that makes the most sense to the Rays, a deal is possible.
Even with only one year left on the contract, Rasmussen won’t come cheap. The $20M price tag changes the market, but it doesn’t erase how good he is.
That’s the basic tension here. Free-agent starting pitching is brutal to pursue because the best arms are expensive, and the A’s can’t realistically sell the same World Series pitch as richer contenders.
A trade feels like the more likely route to help the rotation. The real question is whether Smith can find the right starter that way, and whether one of these names ends up being the answer.
In Other News...
A's Rotation Question Suddenly Puts A Familiar Arm Back In Play
The Athletics offseason picture has already shifted once, with Luis Severino choosing to stay for another year while the club moved on from Jeffrey Springs and Jeff McNeil. That leaves the front office with work to do in two places at once, especially in the rotation and at second base, and it puts a familiar name back into the conversation as the As sort through their next move.
Springs is the one to watch here because the door is not necessarily closed on a return, even after a rough year. Oakland still has younger arms like JT Ginn and Jacob Lopez expected to factor into the rotation, but the club may also look for low-cost ways to stabilize the staff, and Springs fits that profile if his market does not develop the way he hopes. [Read more 🡒]