The A’s spent the 2026 season searching for pitching help, and two former arms would have looked awfully handy in that chase.
That need was obvious all year. Oakland blew 28 saves in 60 chances, a brutal number in a season where the AL West race went right down to Game 162.
Houston edged in on the final day with a .500 record, and the A’s were left to wonder what might have happened with a steadier hand at the back of the bullpen. They did finish with 39 saves, but the club never really found a dependable closer.
If arms like Elvis Alvarado, Hogan Harris, and Scott Blewett could have been pushed into lower-leverage roles, a true shutdown option might have changed the feel of the whole staff.
Mason Miller is the obvious what-if. The A’s dealt him to San Diego last summer, and he immediately looked like the kind of reliever who can tilt a season.
He turned in a 0.77 ERA in 23.1 innings for the Padres last season, then followed that with a 1.67 ERA across 70 innings this season. He also led the National League with 38 saves.
Before the trade, Miller was a superstar closer for the A’s, and his presence in the ninth would have given Oakland exactly what it lacked most.
The A’s won’t be getting Miller back, of course, but his success only sharpens the point: an elite backend reliever has to be near the top of the new GM’s to-do list.
Paul Blackburn is another former A’s pitcher who could have made a real difference. Oakland sent him to the New York Mets in July of 2024, and after being designated for assignment, he landed with the Yankees last August.
This season, Blackburn made New York’s big-league roster and settled in as a long-relief option before working his way into a more important role for Aaron Boone. He finished the year with a 1.69 ERA in 85 innings.
For a team that spent the season fighting to patch together the bullpen, that kind of output would have mattered. Blackburn might not have been a headline name, but the A’s could have used every bit of that stability.
The one caveat is obvious: it’s hard to know whether he would have delivered the same results in a minor league ballpark. Still, with pitching such a persistent problem, both Miller and Blackburn would have given the A’s staff a real boost.
In Other News...
A's New Front Office Faces Two Tough Rotation Calls
The Athletics offseason reset is already underway after a disappointing 2026 season, with pitching coach Scott Emerson out and general manager David Forst gone in a mutual parting. Now the club is searching for replacements in both spots, and whoever takes over will inherit a rotation that needs more than a few tweaks as the organization tries to sort out what comes next.
One of the first calls will be on Jeffrey Springs, whose future sits in the hands of a front office that has not yet been fully assembled. Another is Gage Jump, who flashed early as a prospect but ran into trouble as the season wore on, leaving the As to decide whether he is better served by more time in the minors to regain his footing. For a team already trying to change its direction, those are the kinds of decisions that can shape the rest of the winter. [Read more 🡒]
Lawrence Butler Still Has One Concern A's Fans Can't Ignore
Lawrence Butler still gave the Athletics a much more complete offensive profile in 2026 than he had early in his career, especially after the midseason break. His walk rate climbed, his hitting improved in the second half, and there was enough progress at the plate to make him look like a player trending in the right direction as the As keep building around young talent.
Even so, there is one part of Butlers game that is hard to ignore heading into 2027: the speed and baserunning that once looked like a real weapon never consistently showed up the way Oakland would have hoped. He was thrown out or picked off multiple times during the season, and the final stretch only sharpened the concern for a player whose overall value depends on doing more than just hitting. [Read more 🡒]
Athletics Need More Than Promise From These Young Building Blocks
The Athletics spent much of 2026 sorting through a roster that still feels like it is being assembled in real time, and a few young names offered enough to suggest a better foundation is there. Henry Bolte gave the club a solid rookie season, while the pitching side had a few more uneven answers as the team continued to search for stability behind the scenes and on the mound.
The larger issue remains the same for a club trying to turn promising pieces into something more reliable: the pitching has to come along, especially in the rotation. JT Ginns emergence as the staffs most dependable starter and Elvis Alvarados flashes of power alongside some volatility both point to upside, but the Athletics still need more than encouraging signs if they want to close the gap in 2027. [Read more 🡒]