The Athletics’ catching picture could look a lot different by 2027, and not just because of who’s on the roster right now.
This season has already gone sideways for a team that was once being talked about as a real American League West contender. Injuries helped push the A’s off that path. Nick Kurtz and Shea Langeliers both missed extended time on the IL, while Jacob Wilson, Tyler Soderstrom, Luis Severino, and several other important pieces are done for the year.
Even with all that, the offense has held up. Jeff McNeil has slid over to first base in place of Nick Kurtz and has been on fire. But behind the plate, the story has been much less encouraging.
Jonah Heim was supposed to help steady the catching spot after the A’s brought him in earlier this summer. For a stretch, he did exactly that.
He became one of the club’s most reliable hitters and even picked up some DH time while Langeliers was healthy. Once Langeliers was expected to miss the rest of the season, Heim was pushed into the everyday catching job, and at first, it worked reasonably well.
Lately, though, the production has disappeared. Heim is 2 for his last 25 and has hit .182 over his last 55 at-bats.
Brian Serven hasn’t given them much either, going two for his last 20 and batting .180 in his last 49 at-bats. Serven did provide a couple of huge homers after being called up, but that early burst has faded.
That downturn matters because Heim is headed for free agency, which puts the A’s in position to shop for another catcher this winter if they want depth behind the plate.
And there’s another layer to this: Langeliers may not be a lock to stay long term either. The source of the uncertainty is his contract situation, with the expectation that the A’s would likely lose him in free agency after the 2028 season. With Scott Boras representing him, the idea of an extension looks unlikely.
Langeliers also surfaced in trade chatter before the deadline this summer, though nothing happened. That made sense, given how hard it is to move a star catcher in season. Learning a new pitching staff in the middle of a pennant race is no small thing.
Still, the offseason could bring a different kind of market. If teams come calling with a strong enough package, the A’s could seriously consider moving Langeliers and reshaping the position group heading into 2027.
In Other News...
A's Development Shift Puts One Young Bat Under Real Pressure
The Athletics season has already changed shape, and with the club moving from trying to contend to leaning harder into development, the spotlight has fallen on a few young bats trying to prove they can be part of the next core. Henry Bolte has been one of the more encouraging names in that mix, turning a rough July into a steadier stretch that has shown up in both his offense and his work in the field.
Tommy White has been the tougher evaluation, because the bat has not given Oakland much to build around and the defensive results have not helped his case at either third base or first base. In a year when the As need young hitters to make a case for more meaningful roles, the pressure on White is starting to look less like a temporary slump and more like a real test of where he fits in the organizations plans. [Read more 🡒]
Athletics Let Another Early Opportunity Slip Away In Frustrating Skid
Zack Gelof gave the Athletics an early jolt with a three-run homer in the first inning, and for a moment it looked like they might turn the page after a rough stretch. Instead, the offense never found another breakthrough, even with a few more hits scattered through the game, and the skid kept growing after the Rays completed their sweep.
Mason Barnett provided three solid innings before the game tilted in the fourth, when Cleveland began to square him up and the lineup lost its margin for error. From there, Luis Medina and Elvis Alvarado helped the bullpen settle things down without allowing a hit, but Oakland still walked away with its fourth straight loss, another reminder of how fragile those early leads have become. [Read more 🡒]
As Suddenly Face A Bigger Problem Than Another Road Loss
The Athletics at least gave themselves a quick jolt in the middle game of the series against the Guardians, scoring early before the night turned sharply the other way in a 12-6 loss in Cleveland. Donovan Walton helped keep them in it for a while with multiple RBIs, including a two-run homer, but the early push did not last long enough to cover for a rough night on the mound.
Jacob Lopez was tagged for 10 earned runs over 2 2/3 innings, and the kind of collapse that follows can create more concern than a single road defeat. Oakland has seen enough uneven nights this season, but when the starter cannot get through the third, the discussion quickly shifts from one loss to the broader problem of keeping the game from getting away so fast. [Read more 🡒]