The Yankees got their offensive boost at the 2026 MLB trade deadline with Luis Garcia Jr. and Heliot Ramos, but the move they were truly connected to never happened. The catcher market was the missing piece, and for New York, that spot still looms as a clear place to upgrade.
Austin Wells’ production was part of why the Yankees were tied to catcher trade possibilities before deadline day, even if he turned things up in the postseason. That backdrop is why Bleacher Report’s Kerry Miller floated a bold offseason idea: New York landing Athletics All-Star catcher Shea Langeliers in a deal built around two young pitchers.
“The Athletics trade Langeliers to the Yankees for a pair of young pitchers,” Miller predicts. “It won't be Cam Schlittler.
I haven't completely lost my mind. But the Yankees have four more years of Will Warren, three years left on Luis Gil and a farm system in which nine of the top 10 players are pitchers, per MLB.com's pipeline.”
The logic is straightforward. The Yankees have pitching depth in their organization, while the Athletics are short on high-end young arms. That kind of roster match can open the door to a deal that helps both sides.
Langeliers stands out as one of the better options if the Yankees want to change course behind the plate. Hunter Goodman would be another strong fit, but the Colorado Rockies kept him through the deadline and may not move him.
Langeliers looks more attainable. The Athletics have already shown they’re willing to move quality talent, and their 2025 deadline deal involving Mason Miller is the clearest example.
Even if two young pitchers might not be enough on their own, the broad idea remains the same: if Cam Schlittler stays put, New York has other arms it can use to try to get a deal done.
And the timing works. Langeliers is a 23-homer All-Star catcher, and with free agency approaching, there’s reason for the Athletics to consider moving him now rather than later.
The Yankees also made it clear this season that they were serious about upgrading the position. Langeliers would have fit cleanly before he got hurt ahead of the deadline, and Brian Cashman could circle back this offseason to make his run at a new starting catcher.
In Other News...
As Face A Tough Shea Langeliers Decision This Offseason
The Athletics front office is still taking shape after the club parted ways with David Forst and brought in Taylor Smith as president of baseball operations, but the offseason to-do list is already crowded. Even without a general manager in place, the As are staring at a set of roster calls that could shape the next phase of the rebuild, including club options for Jeff McNeil and Jeffrey Springs.
One of the biggest questions centers on Shea Langeliers, whose name is already circulating as a possible trade chip. Moving him would not come lightly, since catcher is a premium spot and the As would have to account for what they lose behind the plate, but Langeliers also stands out as one of the few players who could help bring back meaningful talent if the club decides this is the right time to deal from a position of strength. [Read more 🡒]