Notre Dames Defense Has One Worry Fans Cant Ignore After BYU

Notre Dame faces uncertainty as defensive coordinator Chris Ash's inconsistent strategies could impact their upcoming games.

Notre Dame’s defense looked like a different unit when Chris Ash turned up the heat against Miami. That’s why the lingering question now is simple: will he keep doing it?

The Fighting Irish were at their best when they attacked the quarterback last weekend, and the numbers make the split obvious. Against Miami, Notre Dame pressured Darian Mensah 33 times, hitting him five times and hurrying him 25 more. The Irish only logged three sacks in that game, but the constant disruption helped fuel a touchdown win.

That was a sharp contrast from the BYU game two weeks earlier, when Notre Dame’s approach looked far more passive. The Irish pressured Bear Bachmeier only seven times, finishing with four quarterback hits and three hurries. Notre Dame did tighten up after halftime, allowing just one touchdown in the second half after giving up 21 points in the first, but it still wasn’t enough to survive.

Even Marcus Freeman seemed frustrated by what he was seeing against the Cougars. Going into halftime, he said, “We got to get them off track.

We’re not getting them off track right now. They’re doing a couple new things, but it’s just the execution.

We can’t panic,” Freeman said at the time. “You can’t start calling things that your guys don’t know how to execute, so we gotta make sure we clean up what they have to do, and then they gotta play physical.

We gotta play on their side of the line of scrimmage, but you can’t be out of control.”

The uncertainty around Ash’s next move is already showing up in the locker room. Asked earlier this week whether he believed Ash would keep bringing the pressure he used against Miami, Kyngstonn Viliamu-Asa could only say, “I hope he liked it, yeah.”

That answer says plenty about where things stand. Notre Dame’s star linebacker may not have meant to reveal anything, but the comment fits the larger concern: nobody seems fully sure what Ash is going to call next.

The Miami game wasn’t just a one-off spike in pressure, either. It was Notre Dame’s season high, and the second time the Irish topped 30 pressures. They also reached 31 in a 49-10 win over Purdue, a game in which they set a season high with eight sacks.

Now the Irish head into Boston College as heavy favorites, expected to win by four touchdowns. That makes the next stretch a useful test of whether Ash keeps the defense on the front foot or shifts back into a more cautious shell. There’s also the bigger picture, with a potential Top 25 matchup against SMU looming.

For now, the concern isn’t that Ash is keeping his plans quiet. It’s that Notre Dame doesn’t yet trust him to choose the right one.

In Other News...

Boston College Fans Witnessed A Notre Dame Moment Bigger Than The Game

Dan Hicks had become such a steady presence on Notre Dame broadcasts that his absence was impossible to miss during Saturdays home game against Boston College. Jason Benetti stepped in on NBC and handled play-by-play in Hicks place, a notable change for a booth that Irish fans have associated with Hicks since 2013, when he became the lead voice for Notre Dame home games.

The moment carried extra weight because Hicks died unexpectedly at 64 following an acute illness, ending a long NBC career that stretched back to 1992. Benetti paid tribute to Hicks during the broadcast, turning what might have been a routine substitution into something more reflective, and a reminder that sometimes the most memorable part of a game day has little to do with the scoreboard. [Read more 🡒]

Boston College Faces A Brutal Notre Dame Test With Plenty At Stake

Boston College heads into South Bend carrying the burden of a two-game losing streak, and the challenge waiting there is about as steep as it gets in November. The Eagles are 4-5 and trying to steady themselves against a No. 3 Notre Dame team that has won two straight and has been one of the sports most consistent contenders this season.

For the Irish, this is the kind of late-season matchup that can keep the playoff conversation moving in the right direction, especially with the regular season winding down and the margin for error shrinking. Boston College will bring its captains, recent results and roster into a setting where Notre Dame has every reason to protect its standing, but the bigger question is whether the Eagles can turn a difficult trip into something more than just another test. [Read more 🡒]

Notre Dame Brings A Personal Edge Into Another Big Boston College Test

Nolan James Jr. brings more than momentum into Notre Dames latest meeting with Boston College. He has scored in nine straight games, giving the Irish a steady red-zone threat at a time when the matchup carries a little extra edge for him personally, since he was once committed to Boston College before ending up in South Bend.

The game also fits into a broader Notre Dame-Boston College backdrop that has usually favored the Irish, with Marcus Freemans program continuing to add to the coachs growing rsum after he became the seventh Notre Dame head coach to defeat a No. 1-ranked team. With the rivalry history and the recent form both in play, this one has the feel of another test that can say something about where Notre Dame stands now, even if the bigger picture still has a few more chapters to go. [Read more 🡒]