Notre Dame’s offense left too much on the table in the 28-24 loss to BYU, and the missed chances showed up in every phase of the night.
The Irish finished with their lowest total-offense output since the season opener against Wisconsin, except this time the result went the other way. They beat Wisconsin 41-13 on September 6. A month and a half later, the same kind of underwhelming production helped hand them their first loss in 17 games.
The opening possessions told the story early. CJ Carr missed Faison on a wide-open touchdown, turning what should have been a touchdown march into a field goal.
Late in the first half, Notre Dame put together a 10-play, 69-yard drive and moved the ball into the low scoring zone, but a botched attempt to spike the ball left the offense with nothing. In the second half, after the defense stopped BYU on a fake punt deep in its own territory, the Irish needed 10 plays just to gain 28 yards and settled for another field goal.
Then, after Bear Bachmeier was intercepted in the fourth quarter, the offense went three and out and never gave itself a chance to close the door.
Mike Denbrock’s play-calling also came under the microscope because the offense is starting to look easy to diagnose. The source of the issue is simple enough: on certain downs and in certain spots, Notre Dame keeps leaning on a limited menu of plays.
That approach has been good enough against Rice, Purdue, Michigan State and Stanford, where the Irish had the edge in talent. Against BYU, it wasn’t.
The Cougars appeared to have a read on what Notre Dame wanted to do on third down and in the red zone, and the drives kept dying before they could turn into touchdowns.
The numbers backed that up. After going 8-13 on third down and 4-4 in the red zone against Stanford, and 4-5 in the red zone against North Carolina the week before, Notre Dame fell to 8-19 on third down and 3-5 in the red zone against BYU.
Those numbers mattered because three drives that could have become touchdowns ended with field goals instead. In a four-point game, that kind of waste is brutal.
The Irish also got beat in the “Middle 8,” an area head coach Marcus Freeman had handled well during their 2024 run. Notre Dame’s last two drives before halftime ended with a three and out and a turnover, then the first two possessions of the second half produced back-to-back punts, including another three and out and a four and out.
Even in a frustrating night, Jaden Greathouse gave Notre Dame a real spark. The senior wide receiver posted 8 catches for 125 yards on 13 targets, and the biggest part of his night was the timing of those plays.
He kept drives moving and gave the offense a chance to fight back. That breakout was enough to stand out in a night when so much else went sideways.
Now the Irish get a bye week, which comes at a useful moment with Miami looming. Notre Dame, Denbrock and Carr have work to do before that one arrives, but the effort wasn’t the problem.
The offense kept battling. It just didn’t finish enough of its chances.
In Other News...
Notre Dames BYU Loss Just Got Even More Infuriating
The ending of Notre Dames loss to BYU already felt odd in real time, and now the conference has made it official: an officiating error affected the final sequence. The Big 12 said one second remained on the clock but was not properly accounted for, which meant the game ended before Notre Dame got the extra snap it should have had on 2nd and goal.
Even more frustrating for the Irish is that the replay officiating crew cleared the play anyway, closing the door on a chance to score in the most critical moment of the night. The conference says it will review its end-of-game officiating process after the incident, but for Notre Dame that only sharpens the sting of a loss that now comes with a documented missed opportunity attached to it. [Read more 🡒]
Marcus Freeman Addresses What Went Wrong In Notre Dame's Costly Loss
Marcus Freeman had a clear read on what hurt Notre Dame in its loss to BYU, and it started with the kind of details that usually decide close games. The defense struggled with discipline against a misdirection-heavy offense, while the offense left points on the field by not being efficient enough in the red zone. For a team that had stacked up a 16-game winning streak, those lapses stood out even more because they came in the moments when control of the game was there to be taken.
Freeman also pointed to the adjustments Notre Dame made after halftime, which helped steady things but did not erase the damage from the early mistakes and missed chances. The bigger concern now is execution in the critical spots that turn solid performances into wins, especially when the margin is thin and the opponent is forcing defenders and play-callers to think on the fly. [Read more 🡒]
Notre Dame Loss Revealed Who Stepped Up When The Irish Needed Answers
Notre Dames 16-game win streak came to an end with a 28-24 loss to BYU, but the loss also highlighted a few players who answered the call when the Irish needed them most. Jaden Greathouse was a major part of the offense throughout the afternoon, finishing with a career-high eight catches for 125 yards and giving the passing game a steady presence when Notre Dame needed one.
Luke Talich made his own mark on the other side of the ball, leading the defense with eight tackles while helping adjust coverage to slow BYUs run game. In a tight game that exposed a few missed opportunities, those were the kinds of efforts Notre Dame can point to as it sorts through what worked and what still needs cleaning up. [Read more 🡒]